Is Plagiarism Stealing?

Plagiarism has been a subject of intense debate and scrutiny across educational, professional, and creative domains.

With the advent of digital technology and the internet, the ease of copying and pasting text has further complicated the issue. But a fundamental question persists: is plagiarism stealing?

To answer this question comprehensively, we must delve into various aspects, including the definitions, ethical considerations, legal perspectives, and the impact on both the plagiariser and the original creator.

Definition of Plagiarism and Stealing

Plagiarism is commonly defined as the act of using someone else’s work, original ideas, or expressions without proper acknowledgment, thereby presenting them as one’s own.

It encompasses a range of activities, from verbatim copying to paraphrasing without citation, and even the unauthorised use of another’s artistic or scientific contributions.

Stealing, on the other hand, is the act of taking another person’s property without permission with the intent to permanently deprive them of it. This definition is clear-cut when it comes to physical property, but the notion becomes more abstract when applied to intellectual property.

While both plagiarism and stealing involve taking something that doesn’t belong to the perpetrator, the nature of what is taken and the implications differ significantly.

Former concerns intangible assets—ideas, expressions, and intellectual creations—whereas later traditionally involves tangible property.

Ethical Considerations

From an ethical standpoint, plagiarism and stealing are both acts of dishonesty.

Plagiarism deceives the audience into believing that the plagiariser is the original creator, thereby unfairly gaining credit, accolades, or even financial benefits that rightfully belong to someone else. This deception undermines the trust essential to academic, professional, and creative communities.

In academia, plagiarism violates the fundamental principles of scholarship, where the advancement of knowledge relies on honesty and proper attribution.

Students and researchers who plagiarise compromise the integrity of their education and the credibility of their institutions.

In professional settings, plagiarism can damage reputations, lead to legal repercussions, and erode trust within industries.

Must Read? Is Grammarly Plagiarism Checker Good?

Stealing, ethically, is condemned because it deprives the rightful owner of their property and benefits.

It is a breach of moral and social codes that emphasise respect for others’ possessions and rights. The intent to deprive the owner of their property is central to the moral condemnation of stealing.

Legal Perspectives

Legally, plagiarism and stealing are treated differently, though they can overlap in intellectual property law.

Plagiarism is not a criminal offense but rather an ethical breach often addressed by academic institutions and professional organisations through policies and disciplinary measures.

However, any form of plagiarism can lead to legal consequences if it infringes on copyright laws.

Copyright law protects the original expression of ideas fixed in a tangible medium, such as books, articles, music, and art.

When plagiarism involves the unauthorised use of copyrighted material, it becomes a matter of copyright infringement, which is a legal offense. The original creator can seek legal remedies, including monetary damages and injunctions to prevent further unauthorised use.

Stealing, in the legal sense, is typically addressed through criminal law. Theft of physical property is punishable by fines, imprisonment, or both, depending on the severity of the crime.

Intellectual property theft, which includes the unauthorised use or distribution of copyrighted works, can also be pursued legally under various statutes protecting intellectual property rights.

Impact on the Plagiarizer and the Original Creator

On the Plagiariser: The consequences of plagiarism can be severe. In academic settings, students may face failing grades, suspension, or expulsion.

Researchers can suffer irreparable damage to their reputations, loss of professional standing, and revocation of degrees or honors. In the professional realm, plagiarism can lead to job termination, legal action, and long-term career damage.

On the Original Creator: The impact on the original creator varies but is often significant. Creators who find their work plagiarised may experience frustration, anger, and a sense of violation.

The unauthorised use of their work can diminish the value of their original contributions, affect their reputation, and potentially result in financial losses if the plagiariser profits from their work.

This article is originally published on the Bytescare Blog.