Is There a Place for Mixed School Sport?
Co-education was late to the party.??Almost all of the early British schools were single sex, with the foundation of many boys’ schools having a fifty year start on the girls.??Even when comprehensivisation brought mixed schools to the state system in the 1970s and 80s, physical activity was very separate, often with sex-specific facilities and staff and usually at opposite ends of the school.??Most independent schools that are now co-educational began life as boys’ schools and took girls at varying stages in the last quarter of the twentieth century - not always for the altruistic reasons which they claimed.
In the early years of co-education, numbers of girls were often small, and unstable.??They were not always welcome in cultures that recognised achievement in Rugby through special blazers and honours boards.??Girls’ sport was undertaken in a pioneering spirit, deploying resources left over from the boys’ programme and fighting for recognition.??As numbers settled, and female school populations grew, the aim was to have a programme which operated in the way that it always had for the boys.??Hockey in the autumn term was a direct equivalent for Rugby: Netball after Christmas allowed boys to use the astro pitches whilst the girls put the tennis courts – usually derelict in the winter – to good use for Netball.??The sports were different, the facilities and staff were different, and never the twain shall meet.??Even when boys teams and girls teams came to have opponents in common, the fixtures were rarely on the same day.
Mature co-education brought some modifications.??Changing attitudes in society made traditional sports that were previously male-dominated, typically Cricket and various codes of football, part of the girls’ experience.??Occasionally girls appeared in ‘boys’ teams, notably in Cricket.??The first ones were regarded with suspicion.??Changing attitudes to gender issues complicated the situation further.??School sport for the sexes moved closer, but they were still slow to get on the same bus to the same destination.
British schools overseas school don’t have this baggage.??Mostly founded as co-ed organisations, their attitudes and programmes have been inclusive from the outset.??They have left the mother country behind.
领英推荐
The UK sector has been slow to work out what co-educational school sport means, or looks like.??Is it boys and girls having access to the same activities? Is it sharing staff and facilities???Would it be combined match days against a similar opponent?
A feature that is rarely considered is mixed sport.??Teams comprising of males and females playing together.??Against mixed teams from other schools, as part of the regular fixture programme and alongside the traditional teams. Some sports are better suited to this than others:??Hockey, Netball, Tennis, Badminton,??Cricket, Golf are all games where mixed teams have always existed (though not always in UK).??The Victorians invented Lawn Tennis, and Badminton for precisely this reason.??It happens in club sport, but infrequently in schools.
Sports programmes have widened incrementally over the last 25 years.??A relentless diet of Rugby, Hockey, Netball and Cricket has been leavened with new activities, new facilities and greater choice.??Association Football is part of the programme of twice as many schools as it was at the turn of the millennium.??Mixed sport will not be a replacement for this, nor will it satisfy pupils striving for the highest achievement in traditional games.??However, it could be a bigger part of the programmes of the future.??It is a legitimate dimension of an ever broader sports offer, aimed at engaging a wider spectrum of pupils in sport and physical activity.??It isn’t something that must be confined to the end of term, and conducted in fancy dress.?
Deputy Principal for Middle and High School
3 年In theory this is a great idea, in some of the sports at my school we run them with boys and girls together, but not all. Whilst the provision and opportunities are the same for both, there is still an underlying culture of girls not wanting to sweat and work hard in front of boys and boys wanting to show off in front of girls. This side of it along with some natural differences make differenting classes extremely challenging.
Teacher passionate about learning, Trauma informed practitioner
3 年Our curriculum is mixed lessons for 2 out of their three lessons per week from year 5-9. Years 10/11 are completely mixed for their PE lesson and seperate in competative games.
Founder of Kidz4 | Non-Executive Director SportCheer England | GB Age-Group Triathlete |
3 年In our Games programme which we stream (up until year 10) its boys/girls competitive and then mixed, we offer the opportunity for students to move within this, and all of out inter-house sport is mixed, e.g. Netball teams have to have 2 boys, and Football teams have to have 2 girls. We've started to have a lot of boys want competitive Netball games too, which would be interesting to see introduced beyond high 5 netball, and I think Governing bodies will have to start looking at . I get questioned all the time from parents at KAS about why some of our programmes are gender split.
Head of PDHPE Kambala / Sun and UV at School Curriculum designer / Sessional Academic Charles Sturt University
3 年I think the concept is a given based on ability in competitive sports. My challenge is as we see participation levels decrease in the teenage years what environment provides all students with the best possible opportunity to encourage participation in sporting activities. Consider the research that suggests the shift from competitive to non-competitive sports: Eime, R. M., Harvey et al (2016, p.1) conclude for female adolescents. there was a clear trend over time of decreases in competitive sport, and more specifically club sport participation. This decrease in organised, structured competitive physical activity was substituted by participation in non-competitive physical activity, which was often unstructured. Similarly, Garcia, A. C. (2015, p. 140) found that friendship and the opportunity to participate in a competitive activity were the main positive experiences the interviewees got from their high school sports participation. Problems with coaching were prevalent for high school athletes, and were more problematic a negative factor than were injuries or conflicts with other activities.
High Performance Strength & Conditioning Consultant - Strategic Planning and Physical Preparation Coach with 20+ years of elite planning/management and coaching experience.
3 年Working in an all girls school I have reached out to our local boys' school to a) play girls v boys fixtures (badminton and squash), and b) mixed doubles fixtures and games (badminton & tennis). There are many positive aspects to this - including inclusivity, breaking down barriers and stereotypes, and the social interactions.