The Perils of Snowball Throwing: A Case Study

Management & Organizations assignment rewritten as an article with AI, Summer 2020

The consulting firm at the heart of this case study found itself in a peculiar predicament: a reliance on a business model akin to snowball throwing. Consultants were primarily focused on acquiring new clients, building relationships, and expanding the firm's reach – a strategy that yielded impressive growth. However, this emphasis on breadth over depth came at a cost.

As expectancy theory posits, individuals are motivated by the expectation of rewards. At this firm, the path to success was clear: excel at client acquisition and relationship management. Promotions, recognition, and status were largely contingent on these abilities. Consequently, the intrinsic value placed on developing deep industry expertise, or what we might term "snowball making," was significantly diminished.

Maslow's hierarchy of needs further illuminates the situation. While autonomy might have been afforded to those pursuing specialized knowledge, the lack of clear purpose, recognition, and belonging within this specialist role hindered motivation. In a firm where status was equated with client base, specialists risked being perceived as second-class citizens, jeopardizing their self-esteem needs.

The firm's reward system inadvertently discouraged the development of essential expertise. By prioritizing external factors like network size and client referrals, it created a disincentive for consultants to invest time in building in-depth knowledge. This misalignment between desired outcomes and reward structures is a classic example of how organizational behavior can undermine strategic goals.

Cultural Roadblocks to Snowball Making

The firm's culture, a complex interplay of norms, rituals, and symbols, significantly impeded the transition to a snowball-making model. Socialization processes reinforced the primacy of client acquisition and generalist skills. New hires were immersed in a culture that celebrated broad-based problem-solving and network building. The expectation was clear: to be a successful consultant, one had to be a relationship-builder, not a deep-dive specialist.

Norms around knowledge sharing also hindered the development of expertise. While the firm espoused a "One Firm" mentality, the reality was that knowledge often resided within individual consultants' networks. The emphasis on cross-office transfers and client-based assignments further reinforced the generalist model. A culture of "helping out" on various projects, while commendable in spirit, diverted attention from specialized skill development.

The firm’s rituals and symbols inadvertently reinforced the status quo. Expansions into new markets were celebrated as milestones of success, overshadowing the importance of building internal capabilities. The firm's mission statement, focused on client service rather than knowledge creation, further entrenched the snowball-throwing mentality.

It is within this cultural context that the specialist role struggled to gain traction. The firm's reward system, coupled with its cultural norms, created a powerful disincentive for consultants to deviate from the well-trodden path of generalism.

A Path Forward: Cultivating Snowball Makers

The firm faced a critical juncture: either continue down the well-trodden path of snowball throwing or embark on a transformative journey towards becoming a hub of industry expertise. To navigate this transition, a strategic plan was essential.

The first step involved a comprehensive assessment of client needs and the competitive landscape. By identifying specific areas where specialized knowledge was in high demand, the firm could prioritize the development of corresponding expertise. This data-driven approach would ensure that the firm's investment in snowball making aligned with market realities.

Simultaneously, a cultural shift was imperative. This would involve a concerted effort to reframe the value proposition of specialists. By elevating the status of expertise within the firm, it would become more attractive to consultants. Recognizing and rewarding contributions to knowledge management, such as authorship of PDNet documents, would be crucial.

Leveraging existing platforms like the PDNet and Practice Olympics could accelerate this transformation. The PDNet could be transformed into a knowledge repository and a platform for showcasing expertise. The Practice Olympics could incorporate competitions focused on specialized skills, thereby elevating the profile of specialists within the firm.

Ultimately, successful implementation hinged on leadership commitment. By championing the snowball-making initiative and modeling desired behaviors, leaders could inspire employees to embrace the change. Moreover, fostering a sense of community among specialists would be essential for creating a supportive environment.

This strategic plan outlined a roadmap for the firm to evolve from a collection of generalists to a dynamic organization capable of delivering specialized solutions. By addressing the cultural, structural, and motivational challenges, the firm could position itself for long-term success in an increasingly complex marketplace.

Conclusion: A New Chapter for the Firm

The transition from snowball throwing to snowball making is undoubtedly a complex endeavor. It requires a fundamental shift in organizational culture, reward systems, and leadership mindset. However, the potential rewards are substantial. By cultivating a culture of expertise and innovation, the firm can position itself as a thought leader in its industry, attract and retain top talent, and deliver exceptional value to clients.

While the journey may be challenging, the transformation is achievable. With careful planning, persistent execution, and unwavering leadership, the firm can successfully navigate this transition and emerge as a stronger, more resilient organization.

Overcoming Resistance to Change: A Critical Hurdle

One of the most significant challenges in implementing any organizational change is overcoming resistance. In the context of transitioning from snowball throwing to snowball making, this resistance can manifest in various forms, including fear of the unknown, loss of status, and concerns about job security.

To address these challenges, it's crucial to adopt a change management approach that involves open communication, employee involvement, and clear articulation of the benefits of the transformation. This includes:

• Transparent communication: Clearly communicating the reasons for the change, the expected benefits, and the potential challenges is essential. Employees should be kept informed throughout the process.
• Employee involvement: Involving employees in the change process can help build ownership and reduce resistance. Creating cross-functional teams to develop the new model can foster a sense of collaboration.
• Addressing concerns: Providing opportunities for employees to voice their concerns and address their fears can help alleviate anxiety. Offering training and development programs can also help employees acquire new skills and build confidence.
• Recognizing and rewarding change champions: Identifying and rewarding employees who embrace the change can inspire others to follow suit.

By proactively addressing resistance, the firm can create a more supportive environment for the transition and increase the likelihood of successful implementation.

Uyi Uwadiae

LinkedIn | Instagram | Twitter (X) | TikTok