Performing a Board Architecture Assessment

The Foundational?Structure of the Board Matters More Than You May Think

(Originally appeared in the September 16th, 2020 'Across the Board' digital publication, a Board Director, Board Advisor, C-Level, and Business Leader publication reaching 48,000+ exceptional business leaders in over 70 countries with articles focused on leadership, strategy, and governance topics - sign up here)

How a Board is structured, or as I like to say,?"architected,"?has much to do with its current and future effectiveness, efficiency, and success. As I wrote in last month's article,?'Heeding The Board's 5 Observables,'?this is because proper Board architecture considers multiple facets of a Board's makeup, not solely each individual member's area of professional expertise or experience.?

Following the publication of?last month's article, I received a large amount of response emails asking the question,?"...how do I actually rate or measure my Board's architecture?"?So many emails, in fact, that I decided to?dedicate this month's?Across The Board?newsletter article and?'Monthly Board Special'?(below)?to exactly this topic.?Many of the Boards that I?advise and provide consulting services have underlying issues with their architecture, causing?the?vast majority of their chronic issues. For this reason, I always take an in-depth look at how the Board is structured first.?Remember, Board Architecture Assessments are important for not only Boards to perform, but can also be extremely valuable for?a Board Candidate in deciding whether or not to accept an offered Board position. The long-term risk associated with not fully understanding a Board's foundational structure is too high to ignore.?

Regardless of entity type (public, private, nonprofit), or whether you are building a new Board from scratch or rebuilding/enhancing an existing Board, a?properly architected Board should have direct focus on its:

1. 'Sphere of Influence'?-?Vertical considerations such as leadership acumen, operational experience, and expertise coverage.
2. 'Planes of Congruence'?- Horizontal considerations such as personality trait balance, strategy and governance acumen, emotional intelligence (EQ),?mindfulness intelligence?(MQ), among others.
3. 'Coverage and Balance'?- Ensuring the depth and overlap of important expertise to allow for identification and meaningful deliberation / conclusion.

Let's systematically step through each of these 3 areas with the ability, at a high-level and starting point,?to score your Board's architecture through an abridged and shortened?version of a Board Architecture?Assessment.

1. Sphere of Influence

What exactly is meant by your Board’s Sphere of Influence??This refers to your Board's industry & industry vertical diversity and experience. You can think of your Sphere of Influence (actual Board Members) as including chosen skill sets in vertical orientations.

I am a proponent of having Board Member representation from numerous industries at the table, not just those with direct experience in your company's industry or industry vertical. If this is ignored, you are essentially creating a bubble of intelligence that is insulated from the rest of the world's?best practices and devoid of other industry advancements - a dangerous proposition in these times of fast change, where quick adaptability can be one of the keys to survival.

Example?Sphere of Influence?high-level / starting?point?assessment:

Note: It is not uncommon for Boards to score around 50% or less in?this?section, as well as the following 2 sections, when initially performing an assessment and prior to any corrective actions.

(See pages 99?- 117?in my book?'Across The Board - The Modern Architecture Behind an?Effective Board of Directors'?for in-depth details on proper Board?Sphere of Influenceconstruction and considerations)

2. Planes of Congruence

Above and beyond industry and industry vertical expertise included in the design of your Board, Board Member composition for your team should additionally be evaluated at multiple?'planes,'?or horizontal considerations, spanning across the entire Board makeup. These horizontal planes add depth to your Board by creating additional?‘character’?starting with the individual Board Members and effectively encompassing the entire Board as a single operational entity.

These horizontals, called?‘Planes of Congruence,’?provide initial and additional evaluation criteria for Board candidates, as well as offer further structure for in-place Boards. In my experience, it is amazing how many existing Boards, or those in the process of being built, simply stop at unfinished portions of?the previous Sphere of Influence step. These organizations have failed to infuse?‘character’?into their Board, which in many cases leads to stagnant interaction and sub-par performance.

In most scenarios, Boards have a combination of standard and consistent Planes of Congruence requirements (many of which are seen in the above example) mixed with other more fluid requirements dependent on risks and challenges, phase of growth, changing social norms, and other important factors.?

(See pages 119 - 125 in my book?'Across The Board - The Modern Architecture Behind an?Effective Board of Directors'?for in-depth details on proper Board?Planes of Congruenceconstruction, categories, and considerations)

3. Coverage & Balance

Similar to your Planes of Congruence creating the?‘character’?of your Board, the Coverage & Balance?of your Board, as it correlates to Board Members' expertise and experience, creates the?‘depth’?of your Board. Depth is an important characteristic of Boards as it offers relevant guidance and deeper thought processes leading to more effective deliberation on important Board topics and strategies.

In essence, Board Member Coverage & Balance refers to two basic concepts:

• Coverage: Ensuring that you have engaged at least one true expert in each of your designed Sphere of Influence areas on your Board, while also meeting your Planes of Congruence requirements.
• Balance: A strategic and predetermined overlap of expertise and experience as it relates to your Board’s Sphere of Influence areas, while also meeting your Planes of Congruence requirements.

In the following example view, this particular Board was aiming for at least 1 subject matter expert (SME) and at least 1?additional?'deep knowledge'?or greater representative?in each of their Sphere of Influence areas. Although they hadn't reached their goal at the time of this assessment, we developed a?strategy?and plan of requirements for all new future Board Members to support the desired outcome, which we accomplished in the subsequent 3 quarters of?that year.

Example?Coverage & Balance?high-level / starting?point assessment:

(See pages 127 - 135 in my book?'Across The Board - The Modern Architecture Behind an?Effective Board of Directors'?for in-depth details on proper Board?Coverage & Balance?construction and considerations)

In these example high-level / starting?point?assessment criteria, it has been?assumed that all 3 categories are equally weighted. When performing?an in-depth and?longer-form assessment, certain categories may take on?higher significance in weighting due to current and future importance.

Confirming proper Board architecture is extremely important to ensure successful Board operations and valuable support for?the organization. For existing Boards?it offers a unique entry point for?a holistic?evaluation without relying on preconceived notions. For?newly forming Boards it offers a blueprint for success and Board-build efficiency. Spending the time to do this correctly is not only important, but imperative.

Do you trust in your Board's foundational architecture to ensure success?

Reach out?directly to Mark A. Pfister?to assess and enhance your Board's architecture with his?Consulting &?Advisory?offerings?and?International Speaking Tour?topics.

Mark A. Pfister - Board Consultant?|?Non-Executive Director?|?Strategist?|?Board Macro-Influencer?|?Speaker?|?Author - www.PfisterStrategy.com

About the Author:?In addition to serving?on numerous Boards, Mark A. Pfister is a renowned Board Consultant,?'Board Macro-Influencer,'?certified Board Director, speaker, author, and advises public, private, and nonprofit Boards in efficient and effective operations. Known as?'The Board Architect,'?he is also the inventor of the?'Board as a Service'?(BaaS) engagement model and an expert Project Executive?frequently advising on strategic global initiatives in their initiation and operational phases......?<< read full bio?here?>>

____________

____________

Sponsored Advertisements

Advertise With Us

Have something that could benefit the?'Across The Board'?community and further elevate leadership? By all means,?click?for audience engagement details,?pricing, and multi-article discounts. Get your coveted offerings in front of the premier curated group of 27,500+ Board Directors, Board Advisors, C-Level, and Business Leaders in over 70?countries. The right audience makes all the difference!

____________

Have Mark join you on his?National & International?Speaking Tours?[?14,500+ attendees / 80+ speaking engagements every year?]

Available in online / video conference formats

'Becoming an Exceptional Board Director Candidate'?Learn the proven and effective steps to plan and implement your Board Director strategy. Experience how these achievable & focused efforts help you convey the expertise and confidence needed for serious Board Director / Board Advisor consideration (Available as?a?speaking engagementand/or a?1:1 individualized preparation coaching plan).

'Building an Effective Board For Your Company'?shows business owners and leaders the immense value of creating or rebuilding an experienced?'go-to'?Board of Directors or Board of Advisors - and most importantly, how to do it via a step-by-step roadmap. Make your company soar with the right foundational elements of an effective Board. (Available as?a?speaking engagement?and/or?consulting engagement).

'Customizable Board of Directors and Leadership Topics'?With a passion for teaching, collaborating, and sharing information, Mark A. Pfister has joined the stage as a keynoter, sole presenter, moderator, and panelist on countless speaking engagements on the topics of strategy, governance, leadership, and Board Directorship. When organizations search for a speaker to leave a lasting impression, Mr. Pfister is frequently considered due to his combination of experience, presence, and ability to make a true connection with audiences. It has been quoted,?“Mark’s ability to collaborate and seamlessly incorporate a requested topic into his repertoire during our many conferences has not only elevated our organization’s image, but also made our yearly event a ‘must attend’ for many executives joining us from around the world.”?(Available as?a?speaking engagement?and/or?consulting engagement).

'The Strategy of Strategy'?Guides Boards and audiences through the 2500+ year history, evolution and next phase of formal Strategy -?'Amorphic Strategy.'?Learn why strategy is so relevant to you personally,?your organization, and your role as a Board Director. Build a viable strategy and?experience how these focused efforts will help you and your organization thrive and reach full potential?(speaker video).?(Available as?a?speaking engagement?and/or?consulting engagement).

____________

____________

Learn the proven and effective steps to successfully plan and Implement your personal Board Director Candidate strategy. Experience how these achievable & focused efforts help you convey the experience and confidence needed for serious Board Director and Board Advisor consideration. Coaching Course is designed for customization at any stage of your career and any level of Board experience (aspiring to experienced).

As is the case in any industry, the Board Director vertical has specific requirements that are a must to land coveted Board seats. Most aspiring as well as experienced Directors approach Board Directorship opportunities in much the same way they would apply for a job - this is a big mistake.?Even when working with an executive /?Board search or placement agency, packaging yourself first is a must!?The fact is that both aspiring and experienced Board Directors of all ages are still in high demand, however, if you are not viewed as a next-gen Director and haven’t properly packaged yourself for serious consideration, your chances of appointment are greatly minimized. Remember, the key is in your packaging... Make the effort to do it right.

<< See the new, more affordable individual pricing models! >>

____________

Here's Some Additional Reading

'Heeding The Board's 5 Observables'

'Getting Back To Board Basics'

'Human Capital Disclosure & The Board'

'5 Steps to Nailing Your Board Director Interview'

'Your Personal Strategy During Times of Crisis'

'Forms & Filings Every Board Director Needs To Know'

'How Much Should You Be Paid as a Board Director?'

'5 Valuable Tips For Proper Financial Reviews'

See all articles?here

??????????????????????★???Join Our Mailing List???★

____________

"Get Quoted"

Want to be quoted in an upcoming?'Across The Board'?article on a topic you are passionate about? Over 200 experts have done so to-date. Propose an article topic or let us know your expertise area?and let's work through the details.?Contact me?to get your name and company in front of the premier curated group of global Business Leaders, C-Level, Board Directors, & Board Advisors - go ahead, make a name for yourself!

Also, explore the possibility?of providing an article quote and supportive?advertisement?simultaneously - these get the best traction and response.