Parenting, or Performance Monitoring

Parenting, or Performance Monitoring

Lately, it seems that everyone wants to fix performance management. There is good reason for this. By most estimates, between 99 and 100% of workers, managers, HR leaders and executives hate their performance management processes. The problems are legion:

  • Restriction of range (only using the middle of the scale)
  • Inconsistent standards (managers using different implicit rating criteria)
  • Rating inflation (everyone is rated "Above Average")
  • No dialogue / performance coaching throughout the year

The list goes on...

So, here is my humble contribution to the discourse.

To me, the performance management problem is analogous to parenting. There may not be a strict / precise measure of "good performance" that we apply to our kids, but there are guidelines (be kind, be generous, share with your friends, have proper manners, don't be too wild). For the most part, parents know when their children are behaving well and the good ones encourage and positively reinforce those behaviors. I think most kids know when they're misbehaving and attentive parents work with teachers, friends' parents and continual communication ("how was your day?") to assess where they can improve. Obviously, no manager will love their employee unconditionally the way that a parent does, but they should be operating from a similar mindset and looking out for their well-being.

In the organizational context, without setting clear expectations for the year (i.e. creating SMART goals, by position) and defining a performance baseline (combination of where you're starting as an organization, and how the rest of industry is doing), one cannot expect to resolve the issue of uneven performance appraisals.

These parametric settings are neccesary, but insufficient. The remaining challenge is the measurement interval. There are, of course, jobs in which performance is measured in days, shifts or even hours (garment workers, call center representatives and factory workers come to mind), but these examples offer little when it comes to professional positions.

For the broad class of "knowledge workers," it is necessary to regularly revisit targets, evaluate their suitability (given the macroeconomic context) and calibrate progress against stated goals. As an example, imagine someone working in the shale industry. The recent collapse of oil prices would, in all likelihood, impact every performance objective and target that they had, but just because nobody is going to hit their original targets, we need not lose all sense of proportion and relativity.

What are your thoughts?

Aaron Ziff

Tech-Fluent, Analytical HR Executive | Employee Experience | Competitive Workforce Insights

10 年

Yeah, because I (like you) totally have the free time to write a book!

回复
Jordan Cusner

Senior Director, Consumer Insights and Research

10 年

Well said, Mr. Ziff. I feel a book coming ...

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Aaron Ziff的更多文章

  • WHAT ARE JEWS SO WORRIED ABOUT? (An explainer)

    WHAT ARE JEWS SO WORRIED ABOUT? (An explainer)

    What the average American (or citizen of virtually any other country) can’t fully comprehend or relate to is that the…

    9 条评论
  • Welcome to Alcoa!

    Welcome to Alcoa!

    Ever have one of those weeks that you dread coming in on Monday? Well, this week I could not have been more excited to…

    3 条评论
  • The “Go-Live” of My Career

    The “Go-Live” of My Career

    Today marks a significant milestone for my employer, Alcoa. You see, today is our Go-Live, the day we release the HR…

    28 条评论
  • Is your recruiting strategy like Hipmunk? Indeed...

    Is your recruiting strategy like Hipmunk? Indeed...

    If you've ever searched for a flight using an aggregator like www.Hipmunk.

  • Don't Fight: What to do About the "War for Talent"

    Don't Fight: What to do About the "War for Talent"

    Look out, folks. With the economic recovery running at full partial strength approaching its seventh year, HR experts…

    7 条评论
  • Employee Feedback: Intent Matters

    Employee Feedback: Intent Matters

    A recent wave of sentiment has questioned the increasingly popular trend of strengths-based feedback, with some going…

    1 条评论
  • Changing Expectations in HR Software Applications

    Changing Expectations in HR Software Applications

    Amid the frenetic pace of acquisitions in the HR and Talent Management software space, an interesting theme has…

    2 条评论
  • Recruiting in the Age of Machines

    Recruiting in the Age of Machines

    In the last several decades, the markets for both recruiting technologies (the outmoded - yet still dominant - ATS) and…

    4 条评论
  • Benefits + Analytics? You Betcha!

    Benefits + Analytics? You Betcha!

    I recently designed a new project for a large client that I am proud of and thought it might interest others. Have a…

  • Loss and Meaning

    Loss and Meaning

    Yesterday, we lost my wife's grandmother, a woman of unparalleled compassion and resilience. I had the pleasure of…

    6 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了