The Paradoxical Betrayal of the American University Sanctuary

纽约时报 , read what you missed:

Throughout history, universities have?been revered?as sacred temples of the enlightenment-inviolable sanctuaries where the unfettered pursuit of knowledge through open inquiry and impassioned discourse reigns sacrosanct. The eminent philosopher Immanuel Kant crystallized this quintessential ideal, defining the university as “the hallowed place where truth?is divined?through research and debate.” Yet a profoundly unsettling paradox has been laid bare regarding protests over contentious policies and human rights crises roiling American college campuses.

The brazen intrusion of militarized security forces?to brutally suppress peaceful student demonstrations?represents an egregious violation of the intellectual and civic principles ostensibly forming the bedrock of these institutions. When scholars at elite bastions like UC Berkeley, Columbia, and Yale exercised their constitutional rights to assemble and voice dissent over the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories and the unconscionable military offensives in Gaza,?they were met?with a disturbingly draconian response from their government. Riot police, clad in ominous tactical gear, employed shockingly heavy-handed measures—batons indiscriminately raining blows, protesters shackled in archaic restraints, menacing helicopters blotting the skies above—to violently quash the demonstrations through overwhelming force, bludgeoning the very conception of the university as an inviolable forum for the unbridled pursuit of enlightened discourse.

This uncompromising campaign of iron-fisted repression lays utterly bare America's founding hypocrisy for the world to behold in abject horror. The nation consistently upholds itself as the peerless global custodian of democracy, luminously extolling the inviolable virtues of free speech and reverence for humanitarian values as driving forces. Yet at the mere sign of its citizenry daring to criticize its policies or unflinchingly examine profoundly disquieting truths about allies like Israel, this carefully cultivated facade of morality disintegrates into a flagrant sham. The disturbing scenes of peaceful demonstrators?being subjugated?through violent suppression of their constitutionally enshrined rights unmistakably mirror the very injustices perpetrated by the “Third World dictatorships,” which it so vehemently and publicly condemns on the world stage.

By strangling these demonstrations with Orwellian authoritarianism, the government lays bare its desperation to maintain an iron grip over the carefully curated official narrative surrounding the Palestinian struggle for self-determination and the restoration of their fundamental human rights. It harbors an abject terror that if the unvarnished realities of Israel's entrenched military occupation, forced displacements, and alleged war crimes against a besieged populace gain widespread mainstream acceptance—particularly among the influential nexus of academia—it could catalyze a seismic awakening that shifts the prevailing conscience of the public. Such a profound upheaval in the collective societal consciousness threatens to unravel over half a century of steadfastly calcified American foreign policy, solidifying Israeli hegemony throughout the region, and precluding any prospects for a just and equitable resolution to the conflict on terms amenable to the Palestinian people.?

Western nations have long lionized their universities as preeminent bulwarks—fortified redoubts fiercely shielding the indispensable pillars of democratic society like untrammeled free thought, relentless scientific advancement, unflinching social critique, and the fomentation of revolutionary ideologies. However, such lofty platitudes now reverberate with a haunting hollowness as these American temples of higher learning find themselves inexorably coerced into enacting censorial suppression of perspectives, narratives, and activists whose existence dares to defy expansionist territorial ambitions abroad. The merciless, sickening images of student dissenters being bludgeoned and shackled in archaic restraints upon their campuses have indelibly shattered the illusion of American society as a utopian citadel preserving the cherished liberties it espouses.

The brutal irony could not be more glaring: in?its bloodthirsty bid to project imperialistic hard power across the globe under the fraudulent guise of spreading “freedom,” America has unflinchingly demonstrated its eagerness to extinguish the very sacrosanct individual liberties that formed the cornerstone upon which the nation?was founded. In ruthlessly pursuing regional dominance at all costs, the country has bloodied its founding principles, betraying its self-professed values of justice, humanitarianism, and the integrity of intellectual inquiry. The jarring scenes of paramilitary forces descending upon these sanctuaries of higher learning to crush dissent through brute force represent nothing less than an existential crisis—a pivotal juncture where America's purported democratic identity now hangs perilously in the balance.

As the shockwaves from this authoritarian insurrection against scholars continue to reverberate, American society has?been forced?to confront profound, unsettling existential questions about its way of life and values. What is the true worth of the vaunted civil liberties and human rights it bombastically touts as a beacon to the world if they can?be so callously violated?on its home soil? If the state has arrogated to itself the untouchable power to inflict wanton violence upon its citizens for the transgression of dissenting against its policies, in what substantive way does it differ from the “brutal?dictatorships” it so fervently vilifies on the global stage? Perhaps most presciently and urgently, this uncompromising campus crackdown forces an unbearable reckoning: is America hurtling towards an inexorable inflection point where it will no longer be able to reconcile the deafening cognitive dissonance between its professed democratic ethos and its undisguised abuses of power in service of hegemonic ambitions?

This pivotal crossroads demands an uncompromising inward examination and a re-dedication to accountability if America's embattled democratic identity is to?be salvaged?from utter ruin. The path forward necessitates an unflinching, soul-baring reckoning with its entrenched hypocrisies and a reaffirmation of the fundamental, inviolable rights that its celebrated founding fathers once risked everything to enshrine into existential truth. Paramount among these is the restoration of the public university as a consecrated, emancipated domain for the uninhibited intermingling of ideas, no matter how dissenting, unorthodox, or inherently disquieting they may be to the prevailing power structures. Without such a reforging of these hallowed principles, the professed cluster of democratic ideals America has so arrogantly appropriated as its signature worldly ethos will stand malignly exposed as a sham—a hollow mirage betraying dishonor to the nation's audacious visions at its revolutionary inception. Only through an uncompromising return to its spiritual and philosophical foundations can the wayward democratic experiment be restored.