Pakistan vs Interquest Informatics: TRANSFER PRICING CASE
The Full Summary as published by The Academy of Tax Law:
Case Information:
Judgment Summary
The case revolves around the taxation treatment of receipts received by Interquest Informatics Services, a Netherlands-incorporated company, under agreements with Schlumberger Seaco, Inc., operating in Pakistan. Interquest claimed the receipts as "business profits," invoking Article 7 of the Netherlands-Pakistan Double Taxation Convention (DTT) to exempt them from Pakistani taxation. However, the Pakistani tax authorities treated these as "royalties" under Article 12, subjecting them to a 15% income tax.
The case passed through the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, which upheld the tax authority's stance. The Sindh High Court subsequently ruled in Interquest's favour, asserting that the receipts were not royalties. However, in 2023, a Supreme Court majority judgment overturned the High Court's ruling, reinstating the Tribunal's decision. The present review petition challenges this majority judgment, highlighting errors in fact and law.
The review petition argued that the Supreme Court erroneously dismissed the High Court's jurisdiction in addressing questions of law and misinterpreted critical treaty provisions. The review Bench examined these claims and identified several errors apparent on the record. These included misjudgments about alternate remedies under the DTT, an erroneous assumption of material facts regarding receipts' nature, and reliance on a stricter interpretation of the treaty's "royalties" clause.
The Bench ruled in favour of the petitioner, overturning the majority judgment. It concluded that the receipts were "business profits," not taxable as "royalties" under Pakistani law. This decision reinstates the High Court's earlier ruling, emphasizing the dynamic interpretation of DTTs to promote equitable international tax practices.
READ THE REST OF THE SUMMARY HERE:
(INCLUDES ALL THE POINTS BELOW)
Key Points of the Judgment
1. Background
2. Core Dispute
3. Court Findings
4. Outcome
Transfer Pricing Method Used
Major Issues or Areas of Contention
Was This Decision Expected or Controversial?
Significance for Multinationals
Significance for Revenue Services
Similar Cases for Review
This is a reminder that applications for our Postgraduate Programmes are now open for the March 2025 intake.
Postgraduate Programmes in Transfer Pricing:
APPLICATIONS NOW BEING ACCEPTED (Closes End of March 2025)
Postgraduate Programmes in International Taxation:
APPLICATIONS NOW BEING ACCEPTED (Closes End of March 2025)
Postgraduate Programmes in South African Tax Law:
APPLICATIONS NOW BEING ACCEPTED (Closes End of March 2025)
Have some questions about the programmes?
Please don't hesitate to contact our Education Consultant, Ben Ellis, at [email protected] or call us at +44(0)2080522710.