Our Tax System is Why Robots Will Win the Job Market (if we let them)

Our Tax System is Why Robots Will Win the Job Market (if we let them)

In our quest for efficiency and cost-effectiveness, businesses are increasingly turning to automation (I see it everyday). But is our tax system inadvertently accelerating this trend, potentially at the expense of human workers?

The Tax Equation: Humans vs. Robots

Consider an Australian entrepreneur faced with a choice: hire 1,000 workers or deploy 1,000 robots.


1,000 Human Workers:

- Income tax withholding

- 11% superannuation contributions

- State-dependent payroll taxes

- Workers' compensation insurance premiums


1,000 Robots:

- Significant depreciation deductions

- Substantial R&D tax offsets

- Tax-deductible maintenance costs


The Bottom Line

Over a year, the financial implications are stark:


1,000 Human Workers:

Income tax withholding: AUD 18,000,000 remitted to ATO

Superannuation contributions: AUD 6,600,000

Payroll tax: AUD 3,000,000

Workers' compensation insurance: AUD 1,200,000


Total tax-related costs: AUD 28,800,000


1,000 Robots:

Depreciation deductions: AUD 20,000,000

R&D tax offset: AUD 43,500,000

Tax-deductible maintenance costs: AUD 10,000,000

Total tax benefits: AUD 73,500,000


The difference is striking: While human workers result in AUD 28.8 million in tax-related costs, robots provide AUD 73.5 million in tax benefits - a net difference of AUD 102.3 million in favour of automation.


Unintended Consequences

Our current tax structure is unintentionally making it more financially attractive to replace human workers with automation. While technological advancement is crucial, we should try to rethink our tax system so we don't drive widespread job displacement.


A Call for Balance

We need tax reforms that:

1. Level the playing field between human and automated labor

2. Encourage innovation without penalizing human employment

3. Ensure the benefits of technological progress are shared equitably


It's time to reshape our tax policies to foster a future where technology and human workforce coexist harmoniously. Let's drive innovation while preserving meaningful employment opportunities for all.


#TaxReform #FutureOfWork #AI

Anf Chans ?

Digital Marketer | Course Facilitator | Content Creator | Community Builder for Mission-Driven Organisations | Multipotentialite

7 个月

Remember when people were screaming "AI will take our jobs?" Well yeah, when businesses are being incentivised in this way - of course they will.

Kinsen Siu

I help emerging fashion brands scale | Fashion Manufacturing | Servant-leader

7 个月

A bit of a more nuanced situation is that its becoming harder to hire folks who want to do the types of jobs that robts can fill. The case against robots presumes that there's this readily available and wiling workforce to do mundane jobs over a long period of time. Sure, some young folks don't mind doing it but they frequently show up and place the burden of training on the business. And after the business invests in this training the employee will do their term and then move on . Anecdotally, even here in China its becoming hard to hire qualified factory workers and we pay 60% over the livable wage. Younger generation folks would rather take less money to work in the gig economy because the thought of having to work on site in a regular cadence is totally not attractive to them at all.

Leigh Sherry

Co-Founder & CEO desk.coach & Wini Health

7 个月

I’d be very interested to see how countries like Denmark, Finland would deal with these issues.

Emily Bobis

?? Building better, safer cities with car data | Founder @ Compass IoT

7 个月

We have pretty frequent water cooler conversations about how painful BAS and payroll tax gets once you start to hire consistently. I can understand why businesses that are struggling with cashflow would be considering hiring AI or robots over humans... do you think that's why so many startups exploit free interns for longer than they should?

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Alex Carpenter的更多文章

  • The Future of Education in a World of AGI

    The Future of Education in a World of AGI

    As a father of two young boys and someone who's taught entrepreneurship at the university level, I'm deeply fascinated…

    5 条评论
  • AI gets the vote?

    AI gets the vote?

    As someone deeply involved in helping companies adopt AI for efficiency and growth, I've witnessed firsthand the…

    11 条评论
  • Part 2: AI and the economic outlook

    Part 2: AI and the economic outlook

    (This is a follow on article from yesterday's - Hype or not; AI leads to unemployment) As someone who is assisting…

    2 条评论
  • Hype or not; AI leads to unemployment

    Hype or not; AI leads to unemployment

    If AI is hype, jobs are gone and if AI isn't hype, jobs are gone. Let me explain.

    10 条评论
  • The Rising Tide of Wealth Concentration: A Deep Dive into the Numbers

    The Rising Tide of Wealth Concentration: A Deep Dive into the Numbers

    Ever wondered how much wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few? Let's take a journey through the past few decades…

  • Finding your strategic focus

    Finding your strategic focus

    Thomas Edison, in 1877, was still an unknown inventor focused on developing better hardware for telegraph operators. In…

    2 条评论
  • Paying customers will kill your company

    Paying customers will kill your company

    There is a lot going on. The world is full of noise.

    10 条评论
  • If you're a failure and you know it clap your hands

    If you're a failure and you know it clap your hands

    Over the past 6 months I have coached a lot of startups and while I feel enormously blessed that they want to talk to…

    19 条评论
  • Beware the Sirens of Covid-19

    Beware the Sirens of Covid-19

    Staying true to your value proposition is always good advice. As a quick refresher; what is a value proposition? It is…

    2 条评论
  • An open letter to entrepreneurs

    An open letter to entrepreneurs

    In the words of Stanford economist Paul Romer: “A crisis is a terrible thing to waste.” There are two facts that you…

    6 条评论

社区洞察