Origins: The Lost Brothers
In 1951 Betty Klein awaits news that never comes of her missing sons

Origins: The Lost Brothers

How I discovered, developed, and wrote an article, book, and podcast about one of history’s most puzzling disappearances of children.

This is the second in my series of Origins essays about the spark and development of my books, articles, and other works. You’ll find the first in the series?here.

On November 9, 1997, a Sunday, I opened my local newspaper.?In the classifieds section, I saw an ad pleading for information on a trio of missing brothers — aged 8, 6, and 4 — who had been missing since 1951. I didn’t know it, but that ad had appeared in the newspaper every November for the previous 35 years. I was curious. I called a phone number listed in the ad.

I spoke with Betty and Kenneth Klein, who invited me to drive from my home in Minneapolis to rural Monticello, Minn., to meet them. They lived in an old farmhouse and had then been married for 56 years, most of that time a nightmare of not knowing, endless searching, and waiting. Their sons, Kenneth, Jr., David, and Danny, had vanished in a single afternoon, unaccountably and without resolution.

The Kleins’ story

Betty, 73 when I met her, was calm and determined, and she did most of the talking. Kenneth, 81, had recently undergone treatment for cancer. He looked pained and spoke slowly. The Kleins had a large family: five remaining sons, five grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren.?They felt devoted to their family, but they could not stop thinking about the sons?who went missing after leaving home to play in a neighborhood park in 1951.

I became aware that even when entertaining me inside their home, they directed a small part of their attention outside. Their ears were especially attuned to arrivals on their long gravel driveway. The crunching of tires, footsteps, stray male voices — the Kleins strained to catch sounds like these. Someday, somehow, their sons might return home. Betty kept a collection of the missing boys’ clothing, photographs, and schoolwork.


No alt text provided for this image
The Klein family a year before the boys vanished


Some people told Betty and Kenneth to give up, to stop searching for their missing boys after so many years. The Kleins refused. Kenneth pointed out that nobody had ever proven the boys dead. Nothing would stop him and Betty from worrying about them. “These kids come into the world,” he said, “and whatever happens you’ve got to stand behind them.”

An article, a book, a podcast

I left, conscious of the sounds I made on the gravel driveway, and I wrote for?Minnesota Monthly?a magazine article?about the Kleins and their missing boys. I published it in 1998, and it gave me false conviction. I thought I understood the complexities of the case and the purgatory in which the Kleins lived. I thought the case of Betty and Kenneth’s vanished sons was doomed to have no ending.

I was wrong.

Fifteen years later, I received an email from a sheriff’s deputy in Wright County, Minn. Something was developing in the case of the missing Klein boys. This case could still be solved.


No alt text provided for this image
From the FBI’s file: the first page of a ransom note sent in 1951


The deputy and her partner met Betty Klein ten years after I did, after Kenneth’s death. Intrigued by her story, they began collecting?and organizing evidence on their own time. The Minneapolis Police Department, which had investigated the disappearance of the boys for a mere?five days in 1951 before declaring them drowned on little evidence, had nothing to share, but the FBI and a Minneapolis Park Police sergeant who had looked into the case during the 1990s provided valuable files. It was now possible to identify suspects who might have abducted the boys and to determine a new course for the investigation.


No alt text provided for this image
The book that emerged from my reporting on the Klein family and their missing sons


I tumbled into the story once again. This time the result was a book,?The Lost Brothers: A Family’s Decades-Long Search, published in 2019 by the University of Minnesota Press. I had collaborated with the U of M Press on two earlier books. I later teamed with Twin Cities PBS and wrote and narrated the?Long Lost?podcast based on the book and on new reporting.

A story with more to say

It’s now more than 70 years since the boys disappeared, and we are inching closer to finding out what happened to them. What Betty and Kenneth and their remaining family experienced is an unforgettable tragedy, and I wrote the book and podcast to focus on their lives.

Too few people know about Kenneth, Jr., David, and Danny and the ongoing efforts of their family to find them. It’s one of the most moving true-crime stories of recent years. It’s ready for a retelling on the screen.



#truecrime #writing #journalism #history

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jack El-Hai的更多文章

  • Damn History / March 2025 / Issue 88

    Damn History / March 2025 / Issue 88

    Don't be too friendly Last month on Washington’s birthday, I read an excerpt from a letter the first president sent to…

  • Damn History \ Issue 87 \ February 2025

    Damn History \ Issue 87 \ February 2025

    Not yet obsolete Welcome this month to the many new subscribers of Damn History. Every few weeks someone asks me for…

  • Damn History / January 2025

    Damn History / January 2025

    Issue 86 In Public The start of January is one of my favorite times. With the turning of the new year, an enormous…

  • Damn History / Issue 85 / December 2024

    Damn History / Issue 85 / December 2024

    My recommendations are not the best Some of you already know about my dislike of end-of-the-year “best books” lists. No…

    2 条评论
  • Damn History #84 | November 2024

    Damn History #84 | November 2024

    An unpleasant message from 1948 As I wrote in my book The Nazi and the Psychiatrist, Douglas M. Kelley, M.

    2 条评论
  • In Love with a Delusion

    In Love with a Delusion

    Jacob Moreno, the psychiatrist who created psychodrama group therapy, put on the therapeutic stage a patient infatuated…

  • Damn History #83 | October 2024

    Damn History #83 | October 2024

    Out of context? In history, context is everything. Twenty years ago, when I began researching my book The Lobotomist, I…

  • Damn History #82 | September 2024

    Damn History #82 | September 2024

    Block that history meme! On social media, fake news afflicts history writing. Many of the most popular purveyors of…

  • Damn History #81 | August 2024

    Damn History #81 | August 2024

    Hard work, but there's worse Even though many popular-history writers love their work, some like to complain about it…

  • Damn History #80 | July 2024: It's summer!

    Damn History #80 | July 2024: It's summer!

    Summer has arrived, and I didn’t feel like writing an introductory essay. Here in Damn History you'll find, as usual…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了