Optimal Early Exercise Boundary for American Options: The Free Boundary Problem

American options, unlike their European counterparts, give the holder the right to exercise the option at any time before or at expiration. This flexibility brings additional value but also makes pricing and valuation more complex. One of the most important aspects in understanding American options is the concept of optimal early exercise and the corresponding optimal exercise boundary (also known as the free boundary problem).

This article delves into the mathematical and practical aspects of finding the optimal early exercise boundary for American options, a key to accurately pricing these instruments. We’ll discuss the characteristics of American options, the free boundary problem, numerical approaches for solving it, and the implications for traders and risk managers.

Understanding American Options

To grasp the concept of the optimal exercise boundary, let’s first define what makes American options unique:

• American Call Option: Gives the holder the right to buy the underlying asset at a specified strike price before or at expiration.
• American Put Option: Allows the holder to sell the underlying asset at a specified strike price at any time before expiration.

The main advantage of American options is the flexibility to exercise early, which can be valuable in certain market conditions. For example, exercising an American call option early might make sense before a dividend payment, where holding the stock provides value to the holder in the form of dividends.

However, deciding when to exercise is not straightforward. If exercised too early, the holder loses the time value of the option. On the other hand, delaying exercise could result in a less favorable price. This leads us to the concept of the optimal exercise boundary, which separates the region where early exercise is optimal from where it is not.

The Free Boundary Problem

The optimal early exercise boundary problem is known as a free boundary problem in mathematical finance. The challenge here is to determine the boundary (or point) at which it is optimal for the option holder to exercise the option early.

The free boundary refers to the asset price at which the option holder is indifferent between exercising the option and holding it further. For an American option, the holder's decision to exercise the option early introduces a non-linear problem, making the pricing more complex than European options.

For American options, this boundary is not fixed. It changes over time as the expiration date approaches and is influenced by factors like volatility, interest rates, and dividends.

The Mathematics of the Free Boundary Problem

The pricing of American options is typically formulated as a partial differential equation (PDE) similar to the Black-Scholes equation, but with additional boundary conditions that account for the possibility of early exercise. The core equation for an American option, without early exercise constraints, is:

Where:

• V(S,t) is the option value as a function of the stock price SSS and time t,
• σ is the volatility of the underlying asset,
• r is the risk-free interest rate,
• and S is the price of the underlying asset.

For American options, the decision to exercise early introduces a condition where the option’s value must be compared with the payoff function:

V(S,t)≥Payoff(S)

• For a call option: Payoff(S)=max(S?K,0),
• For a put option: Payoff(S)=max(K?S,0),

where K is the strike price.

The optimal exercise boundary is the asset price S* at which early exercise becomes optimal. This creates a boundary where:

• For S > S*(t), it is better to hold the option (do not exercise).
• For S = S*(t), the holder is indifferent between exercising or holding.
• For S < S*(t), early exercise is optimal.

Finding this free boundary S?(t)S^*(t)S?(t) becomes a key challenge in pricing American options.

Solving the Free Boundary Problem

Analytical Approaches

The free boundary problem does not have a closed-form analytical solution for American options, except in special cases (e.g., the McKean formula for perpetual American options). In most cases, numerical methods are required.

Numerical Methods

Several numerical methods are commonly used to solve the free boundary problem and find the optimal early exercise boundary:

1. Binomial Tree Model The binomial tree model is a commonly used approach for pricing American options. It discretizes both time and the underlying asset's price, and calculates option prices at each node of the tree. The key idea is to backtrack from the expiration date, checking at each node whether it is optimal to exercise the option early.
2. Finite Difference Methods Finite difference methods (FDM) solve the PDE governing American option pricing by discretizing time and asset prices into a grid. This approach converts the continuous PDE into a system of linear equations that can be solved numerically.
3. Monte Carlo Simulation While Monte Carlo methods are traditionally used for European options, they can be adapted to American options using techniques like the Least-Squares Monte Carlo (LSMC) approach. This method involves simulating multiple price paths of the underlying asset and then regressing the payoff against the option values to determine the optimal early exercise strategy.
4. Penalty Method The penalty method introduces a penalty term into the pricing equation that forces the option value to meet the early exercise condition. This term is added to the PDE, and the resulting equation is solved numerically to find the free boundary.

Challenges with Numerical Methods

While these numerical methods are widely used, they come with certain challenges:

• Accuracy: Accurately determining the free boundary, particularly for long-dated or deep-in-the-money options, requires fine discretization, which can be computationally expensive.
• Convergence: Some methods, like binomial trees, may converge slowly, requiring more computational effort for complex cases.
• Handling of Dividends: Dividends impact the optimal early exercise decision, as the holder of an American call option might choose to exercise before the ex-dividend date. Including dividends complicates the free boundary problem and requires adjustments to the pricing model.

Characteristics of the Optimal Exercise Boundary

The optimal early exercise boundary exhibits certain characteristics:

1. Time Dependence: The boundary is not constant. It changes over time, generally approaching the strike price as the option nears expiration. For American put options, the boundary typically declines over time, while for American call options, the boundary may rise (particularly if there are dividends).
2. Impact of Volatility: Higher volatility tends to push the boundary further away from the strike price, as the option holder has more to gain from waiting for price movements.
3. Interest Rates: Higher interest rates increase the value of holding onto cash, making early exercise of American put options more attractive. This shifts the boundary downward.
4. Dividends: For American call options, dividends increase the incentive to exercise early. This creates a noticeable jump in the boundary before the ex-dividend date.

Practical Implications

The optimal exercise boundary has direct implications for traders, risk managers, and option holders:

• Traders: Knowing the exercise boundary helps traders make informed decisions about hedging and trading strategies, especially when managing portfolios with American-style derivatives.
• Risk Managers: Understanding the boundary enables risk managers to more accurately assess the risks of holding American options, particularly when modeling early exercise risks.
• Option Holders: For option holders, being aware of the optimal exercise boundary allows them to make better decisions about when to exercise their options to maximize value.

Conclusion

The optimal early exercise boundary is a key component in understanding and pricing American options. This free boundary problem, while complex, can be tackled through various numerical methods like the binomial tree model, finite difference methods, and Monte Carlo simulation. Accurately determining this boundary is essential for traders, risk managers, and financial engineers working with American-style derivatives.

Incorporating dividends, interest rates, and volatility into the model is crucial to solving the free boundary problem and maximizing the value of American options. As computational techniques continue to evolve, solving these problems will become more efficient, but the fundamental principles behind the optimal exercise boundary will remain a cornerstone of American option valuation.

?? Follow Prateek for more such amazing content in Quantitative Finance and Risk Management.

Disclaimer: The ideas, views and opinions expressed in my LinkedIn posts and profiles represent my own views and not those of any of my current or previous employer or LinkedIn.