Open Source is Great…until it Isn't

Open Source is Great…until it Isn't

I sell commercial test automation software. On a daily basis, I compete against Selenium, an open source alternative. Competing against "free" can be challenging. The primary saving grace is that "free" is a fallacy.

Let me tell you a story…

I host a Minecraft server for my kids. I thought this would be relatively simple, but it has turned out to be quite a challenge. Updates, backups, firmware, connectivity, more updates. It all takes time, research, and seemingly never-ending troubleshooting. And while I don't publish SLAs, my kids' uptime expectations are quite stringent.

One day, while looking for a solution to disk drive performance issues, I stumbled upon a self-proclaimed legendary website hosted by James A Chambers. While I came to James' website for the comprehensive, detailed coverage of hard drive performance, I stayed for his Minecraft script.

James had developed an almost magical script for installing and maintaining Minecraft on a Raspberry Pi. The script would install Minecraft from scratch, ensure all the required components were also installed, impose a reasonable backup practice, and manage the upgrade process. And if anything went wrong, it was properly modularized so you could simply erase everything and start over without losing any data.

Even more impressive than his script was his responsive and comprehensive support. Posting a question in his comment section received a seemingly instant response, always friendly and delivered in a supportive, patient manner with an emphasis on educating the user and broader audience.

I have used James' script and his responsive support for at least three years. My kids and their friends enjoyed hours of uninterrupted gameplay.

Recently, James' website encouraged users to transition from the script to a Docker container. As I have recently been experimenting with Docker…and dependent on James…I jumped in, successfully moving my world to his new model.

I did, however, have some questions. As was my habit, I posted my query on his site and waited for a reply. And waited. And waited. I became concerned. I had always envisioned James as a wizened, senior engineer, potentially in retirement, impulsively keeping himself busy. Was he sick? Did he die?

As I scoured comments hoping to find an answer to my question in prior posts, I came across an uncharacteristically candid post from James explaining the situation. From what James posted, he had dedicated several years of his life to building and maintaining the website, scripts, and Docker containers. He had hoped he could make a reasonable living from donations and sponsors but found the endeavor impossible to maintain. He had to get a real job.

All of James' scripts and containers are open source. I have the ability to continue using and maintaining them myself. But without James doing the heavy lifting, this will become a tremendous burden. James' superior support meant I didn't have to properly educate myself on the internals of his scripts/containers. I also adopted his architecture without fully understanding the implications.

We will see how long I can coast on James' work, but I suspect I am in for a considerable amount of research and re-education to keep the kids happy. And while James had created a vibrant community of users, his comment section is moderated and without an active moderator, we are all locked out.

I wish James the best. His post indicated he was struggling to find a junior software role. He also commented that the site and projects had done little to bolster his resume. I find that hard to believe. I would recommend him highly to anyone seeking an intelligent and highly diligent programmer. His patience, curiosity, attention to detail, and instructional approach would make him a great addition to any team.

So what does this have to do with open source?

My server is a hobby. I could have paid any number of hosting companies to maintain my server. Indeed, my older son pays $3.99/month for Microsoft to host his Minecraft world on Realms. Over three years, that would have cost $143.64. I am pretty sure I paid more than that for the 8GB Raspberry Pi 4 and SSD, let alone my hours of time and effort (even with James' magic scripts). But I felt the time was worth it because I was learning. In an enterprise, these cost differentials add up quickly.

As a business, you may be interested in providing your employees with a learning experience, but when considering value and total cost of ownership, open source is often a red herring. Commercial solutions spread the cost of development and support over a broad user base. A viable business model supports both the user and the developer. When it delivers value, commercial solutions are sustainable.

And it won't have to go off and get a real job.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Tom Payne的更多文章

  • A Tale of Dirty Data

    A Tale of Dirty Data

    A while back, our Accounts Receivable team asked for help tracking down a past-due invoice. After two weeks or so, we…

    1 条评论
  • The Reality of Testing

    The Reality of Testing

    When discussing the process of software testing, we typically start with the idea of a "requirement". This is then sent…

  • Selenium pitfalls

    Selenium pitfalls

    In the classic movie, Monty Python and the Holy Grail, King Arthur has an encounter with “Dennis” regarding their form…

    2 条评论
  • The Tosca Difference

    The Tosca Difference

    When I first joined Tricentis, Tosca had the reputation for being an excellent test automation solution, but I honestly…

    3 条评论
  • I asked chatGPT about Data Errors

    I asked chatGPT about Data Errors

    There has been a lot of talk lately about OpenAI's conversational AI beta, known at chatGPT. While not a truly…

    5 条评论
  • Clarity and the Agile Testing Pyramid

    Clarity and the Agile Testing Pyramid

    I have been in the software testing space for the past 20+ years and never experienced greater clarity regarding the…

  • Diversity & Inclusion: Actionable Tech Hiring Ideas

    Diversity & Inclusion: Actionable Tech Hiring Ideas

    Diversity and inclusion are on the mind of every HR professional these days. The challenge is identifying actionable…

    2 条评论
  • Leveraging my Network

    Leveraging my Network

    LinkedIn is a great concept, in theory. Building and maintaining a robust network should be highly beneficial to all…

    2 条评论
  • Tales from the Wild: The "Key" to Good Customer Experience

    Tales from the Wild: The "Key" to Good Customer Experience

    I have been traveling quite a bit lately and was looking forward to finally trying out the new "use your phone as a…

    1 条评论
  • Tales from the Wild: Testing Big Ideas

    Tales from the Wild: Testing Big Ideas

    In their book, Sprint, Google Venture consultants Jake Knapp, John Zeratsky and Braden Kowitz describe how they came to…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了