Open to interpretation

Open to interpretation

Cate Blanchett conducting in the movie Tar
Cate Blanchett in Tàr, Picture from Focus Features, Canberra Times, 27 January 2023

Tàr is an entrancing, complex and disturbing film. Its eponymous character, played by Cate Blanchett, is brilliantly flawed.

And it has lots of lessons for facilitation – especially the (fl)awesome kind.

I’m not implying that Lydia Tàr’s often monstrous behaviour can be compared to any facilitator I’ve met, although I do believe that facilitators can, at times, be dictators. And sometimes for good reason.

Rather, the lessons this intriguing film has for facilitation are about imitation and interpretation, and why we might choose to do one over the other.

Let’s start with imitation.

I often get asked for the step-by-step instructions for workshop processes by clients I train and mentor. You can almost feel their relief when they get the steps in their hands. ‘Yay!’ I imagine them thinking, ‘I can do exactly the same thing with my group!’

Maybe, but unlikely.?

A step-by-step process on a piece of paper is a little bit like a composer’s piece of music. Brilliant on its own, but only brought to life by an orchestra, through the conductor’s interpretation.

Same for a workshop process. It is interpreted by a facilitator and it’s brought to life by the group they’re working with.?

You as the facilitator bring your ‘twist’ to it, your experience, your own authentic flair.?

If my client is not panicking about a workshop taking place on the following day, I will put the process aside and work through a few questions with them.?

  • Why is this group meeting?
  • What brings them together?
  • Why this process now?
  • What thinking will it encourage?
  • What problems will it help solve?
  • How?

These and other questions often suggest different ways to build on or vary the process that they’re so eager to get their hands on. And hey presto, another facilitation process is born, interpreted by my client. It’s theirs, in all it’s (fl)awesome glory.???

I might be stretching the analogy but my point is echoed in the film. Lydia doesn’t ask an orchestra she’s working with for the first time to open their music and start rehearsing. She talks to them about the composer’s intention.

I’m taking a bit of my own advice with colleagues in a global facilitation community. We’re having fun interpreting tried and true processes. There are so many methods on offer it would be easy to just take a ‘handout’ and copy. But we’re mixing methods, curious to see what happens. Our aim is to learn, be inspired, not to copy.?

Imitation is tempting and easier. But as Lydia Tàr advises a fellow conductor who has been pestering her for conducting advice, ‘There’s no glory for a robot, Eliot. Do your own thing.’?

Herman Melville, the author of Moby Dick, once said that, ‘It is better to fail in originality than to succeed in imitation.’?

Interpretation is all about making progress with your facilitation, not aiming for the perfect copy. That’s (fl)awesome.

Are you open to interpretation? I’d love to hear.


No alt text provided for this image

Jacinta talks about facilitation, facilitates for you and builds your facilitation capability. She helps organisations, experts and thought leaders:

?? Elevate engagement, boost collaboration and gather gold from groups.

?? Deepen a team’s sense of belonging and appreciation of how to work effectively together.

?? Build facilitation ‘know how’ to design and facilitate workshops that create wonder.

To find out more, please visit?www.jacintacubis.com

Josephine Newman

Community engagement practitioner | Facilitator + educator | Building engaging organisations

2 年

‘There’s no glory for a robot, Eliot. Do your own thing.’?LOVE THAT

Leonie Morgan AM

Experienced Non-Executive Director (FAICD) and Mentor

2 年

I loved Tar as well Jacinta Cubis and yes there sure was a lot to reflect on and to learn from

Vinay Nair

Mental Health & Social Wellbeing - Consultant | Counsellor | Workshop Facilitator | Mental Health First Aid Instructor | Dad X 2 | Passionate about wellbeing for migrants

2 年

Without interpretation, I wonder if the ChatGPT tool would do a good enough job of facilitation. The humanness in the session is what makes the participation worthwhile.

Julia Tresidder

Strategy, impact, capability builder

2 年

I must see this film - thanks for your analogy

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jacinta Cubis的更多文章

  • ‘I need a facilitator!’

    ‘I need a facilitator!’

    ‘I need a facilitator.’ Before you pick up the phone to talk to one, take a few minutes to ask yourself ‘why’.

    8 条评论
  • Facilitation Felony

    Facilitation Felony

    ‘We worry about time, but it’s what we do with it that matters.’ That made me sit up.

    4 条评论
  • Bored (with) games

    Bored (with) games

    ?? “I HATE games!!” ?? Quite a startling response to my question about what people like and don’t like about team days.…

  • Beautiful strength

    Beautiful strength

    I wondered where my mighty May had gone as I struggled to hang in ‘skin the cat’ for 5 seconds last week. Photo by Alex…

    6 条评论
  • Game On

    Game On

    We’re planning a Scrabble Olympics. We’ve sorted the process and defined the rules.

    4 条评论
  • Take the money off the table

    Take the money off the table

    It’s that time of the year when we’re reminded that money doesn’t grow on trees. We all have to make do—or do more—with…

  • 25g and packs a punch

    25g and packs a punch

    I love getting a treat with my coffee. In Melbourne’s little Italy this week, it was a tiny, but tough, biscotti.

  • Why your decision won't stick

    Why your decision won't stick

    ? RANT ? Companies. Governments.

    9 条评论
  • The Q&A Tightrope

    The Q&A Tightrope

    ‘Q&A is the easiest thing to facilitate,’ said my co-facilitator. ‘We can relax.

    2 条评论
  • One for the collection

    One for the collection

    Public transport has many benefits beyond being sustainable for the planet and your budget. Finish that podcast.

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了