"One thing. Just one thing. You stick to that and the rest don't mean s#%*."

"One thing. Just one thing. You stick to that and the rest don't mean s#%*."

Why would I ever quote a line of dialogue from the movie City Slickers, specifically the "one thing" dialogue between the main protagonists Curly and Mitch in the context of a fintech blog? Readers might think I have lost my mind... and they may not be entirely wrong.

The context within which I invoke such colloquial and colorful Hollywood prose is that of banks and more specifically checking accounts.

I just finished reading the "World Class Payments in the UK" report from Payments UK, downloadable here, and encourage all interested in payments to read it. There are a few nuggets in this report. The crux of the report's argumentation is to push for customer-centric focus when it comes to payments. This can be achieved easily currently as most of the technologies and products to make for a more service oriented experience already exist. The report goes on to advocate for more control over payments, better and richer data and data analytics, better service, 24/7 service, faster and instantaneous payments. All worthy goals. One item that caught my attention is the advocation of third party access to customer data and customer accounts. This would seem to be an innocuous feature. I venture to say it is "THE" feature, no correction, "THE ONE THING" Curly would harp on all day long had he been talking to a banker in City Slickers.

What does ease and instantaneity of payments coupled with third party access to customer data have to do with banks and checking accounts. Surprisingly a lot IMHO.

Banks have an unassailable competitive advantage granted to them by licensing fiat. They are deposit gatherers. Most of these deposits come in the form of amounts sitting in demand deposits, that is checking accounts. These amounts allow banks to enjoy the lowest cost of funding available to any entity in the world. I contend that banks have gone out of their way to make sure these deposits are sticky. One of the way this has been achieved has been through the relative friction anyone encounters when trying to make payments. Another way has been to make it difficult for you to share your account data and meta data. That data sits in your account, within your bank's guarded walls and is seldom used and mined in an effective manner.

Any initiative that pushes for 24/7 instantaneous payments - in and out of a checking account - weakens the cost of funding advantage of a bank. Any initiative that pushes for as open an access as possible to checking accounts and checking account data by third party service providers weakens the dominant position a bank has on its customers checking accounts. Mind you, this is very material. An important part of a bank's economics is built on the risk/return profile of a checking account. Any change on the economic return of a checking account will have a material impact on bank returns in the aggregate.

Queue the European Union directive that will mandate/facilitate granting third party access to customer accounts + initiatives such as that of Payments UK + service providers (payments, data and others) piling on at the gates and you have a seminal turning point for the industry. One may argue this to be limited to the UK. I have heard of similar initiatives on third party access in other jurisdictions - Singapore immediately comes to mind. I suspect this will become an unavoidable trend which may prove much more impactful than other fintech trends. I am intrigued and fascinated this potential disruption would come from legislators, regulators and bodies such as Payments UK as opposed to directly from the "technology" world. Innovation can be enabled from different corners I guess.

To be clear, I am not declaring banks defeated, I merely point to checking accounts being central to their economic return profiles and the weakening position they will hold going forward on said accounts. I expect counter measures from banks for sure. I expect them to stick to that ONE THING. Well make it two things really. The first "ONE THING" being the checking account, the second "ONE THING" being how to provide excellent service to their customers around that checking account. Note that service is the operative word here. SERVICE is the future of the industry. They may stick to that ONE THING and view it as a store of value or - think innovation here - as a store of data and identity management?

The checking account wars have just begun.

And if you still are skeptical, then ponder on these two moves:

- Apple just announced a p2p payment solution, do you think banks will like the fact this solution may be linked to a checking account? Read here.

- Western Union announced it is powering Wechat's p2p remittance solution, read here.

Samuel Hu, CFA

Over 20 years of experience solving finance and legal challenges using technology

9 年
回复
Lamine Zarrad

Founder and CEO @ StellarFi

9 年

Good point Pascal! However, one need not look further than the long-standing practices of the credit-card banks. These institutions, particularly the ones with large portfolios of pre-paid cards, are quantifying volatility of their cards (which behave similarly to your "democratized" checking accounts), by focusing on the decay rates of aggregate balances. Such technique allows them to estimate average volume per any given period and treat the fluidity of "stored value," rechargeable cards, as "core" deposits. I am certain that this approach will be ubiquitous in liabilities management as banking moves closer to payment democratization

回复
Richard A Williams

Producer / Director - Corporate Video Services

9 年

Here comes David Cam LOL

回复
Alex Medana

FinTech CEO I Repeat Entrepreneur with 1 Exit (DLT, Digital Identity, Tokenisation since '15) I Board Member I Adviser & Coach

9 年

Interesting to think that a single piece of regulation will disrupt the incumbents that a regulator aim to control and protect (in terms of the risks to the society at large: keep banks solid and the taxpayers will be happy). Volcker move aside, Europeans are showing the way with PSD2!

回复
Sudhir Kesavan

Chief Operating Officer

9 年

This "ONE THING" is perhaps the single biggest innovation in favour of the customers that the regulators could provide. The beginning of customer's control over their financial and legal identity. It will force banking towards "need servicing" org design and procedures. Expect one touch platforms that bring on demand deals to customers. Maybe even a reverse auction managed by the customer themselves. Thank you for your article.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

?? Pascal Bouvier的更多文章

  • A New fund for the Next Decade

    A New fund for the Next Decade

    All of us at MiddleGame Ventures collaborated to write this piece: Michael Meyer, Patrick Pinschmidt & myself - it…

    18 条评论
  • New Beginnings

    New Beginnings

    I hope everyone had a festive and relaxing holiday break. Happy New Year! In my previous post I announced the end of my…

    14 条评论
  • just follow while i innovate

    just follow while i innovate

    "cruisin' on the interstate, just follow while i innovate too many try and imitate, medallion like a dinner plate front…

    4 条评论
  • Ch-ch-ch-ch-Changes

    Ch-ch-ch-ch-Changes

    "Ch-ch-ch-ch-Changes (Turn and face the strange) Ch-ch-changes Oh, look out you rock 'n rollers Ch-ch-ch-ch-changes…

    6 条评论
  • The Startups at Money 20/20 Las Vegas 2018

    The Startups at Money 20/20 Las Vegas 2018

    This is my last post on the Money 20/20 2018 extravaganza in Las Vegas. The event is coming soon, plus I need enough…

    3 条评论
  • Making sense of the Money 2020 craziness – the Las Vegas 2018 edition

    Making sense of the Money 2020 craziness – the Las Vegas 2018 edition

    To each her own way of organizing for and experiencing Money 2020. I know some like to plan each day to the minute…

  • Money 2020 on my mind - the Las Vegas 2018 edition

    Money 2020 on my mind - the Las Vegas 2018 edition

    I will attend Money 20/20 in Las Vegas this coming 21-24 October. By my count, this will be my 7thattendance (European…

    1 条评论
  • A Tale of Two Help Desks

    A Tale of Two Help Desks

    It was the best of customer service, it was the worst of customer service, it was the age of legacy thinking, it was…

    4 条评论
  • The Sacred and the profane

    The Sacred and the profane

    Two spheres cohabit within every society or group within societies: the Sacred, and the profane. The sacred sphere…

    15 条评论
  • A plethora of cryptocurrencies

    A plethora of cryptocurrencies

    This article appeared first under the title "Where Will the Crypto Craze Lead? A Venture Capitalist’s View" on…

    11 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了