The One Thing That Creates High-Performing Teams? Accountability, but It Isn't Forced—It’s Built into the Successful Culture

By Eric Whitmoyer | Founder & CEO | My Biz Coaches

When it comes to building high-performing teams, many leaders assume that accountability means cracking down on employees, setting strict performance metrics, or micromanaging tasks. But the truth is, forced accountability rarely works. The secret to sustained success lies in cultivating a culture of accountability—one where team members naturally take ownership of their work and responsibilities.

This subtle but powerful shift transforms the entire dynamic of a business. Teams that feel empowered to hold themselves and each other accountable consistently perform better, innovate more, and adapt to challenges quickly. But how do you build this kind of culture? Let’s break down the strategies and real-world examples that small business leaders can implement to create self-sustaining, high-performing teams.

Now, before we jump in, you may be asking yourself, why should I be listening to this guy about Leadership? Well, that is a great question, and I am glad you asked. I happen to know a bit about this topic because I have a proven history of building successful teams for almost 30 years, mostly during my tenure in the wireless retail sales industry.

Throughout my career, I have attained several awards for exceptional performance. Although I was a successful salesperson, the most prominent portion of my career was leading sales teams on a large scale, which I attribute to having and developing an exceptional team every time. There is no question that I had the privilege of working with great people; at the same time, I often orchestrated, recruited, and developed those teams and the leaders that delivered those results. That is Leadership on a high level.

I was once called the Bill Parcells of Wireless Retail Sales Leaders. I partially took offense to this because I am a die-hard Pittsburgh Steelers fan; however, you can't deny his success throughout his career, and as I looked more closely at his Leadership style, the reference seemed spot on.

I am often remembered for my reiterated quote, "Attitude is a Reflection of Leadership," and as such, I have worked hard to emulate the attitudes that I wanted my teams to display. Now, it's not a perfect science, but if you can't demonstrate what you expect from a team, how could you ever expect them to follow you? My pragmatic, motivational, tough love, and influential style of Leading while tailoring my teams to adapt and find different paths to success was a key to my career success overall.

This is just one approach that worked for me and that I developed over time. There are certainly other styles and approaches that get results, but the key is to understand and embrace what works for you and your personality.

Regardless of your leadership style or approach, one thing that is key to effective leadership is holding teams accountable for their performances. Both collectively as well as individually.

Why Accountability Drives High Performance

Research confirms that accountability is directly linked to high performance. According to a study by Gallup, teams that feel accountable to each other see 21% greater profitability and 17% higher productivity than those with poor accountability structures. Yet the same research shows that only 15% of employees feel actively engaged in their workplace—indicating that most organizations struggle to get accountability right.

Accountability goes beyond following rules. It’s about creating an environment where team members feel a sense of ownership over their roles, goals, and outcomes. Employees are more likely to perform at a higher level when they believe their contributions matter and when the culture encourages collaboration rather than punishment.

3 Strategies to Build a Culture of Accountability

1. Set Clear Expectations From Day One. Ambiguity is the enemy of accountability. High-performing teams know exactly what’s expected of them. Leaders should communicate specific, measurable goals and outline responsibilities from the start. For example, using frameworks like SMART goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) ensures that every team member knows what success looks like and how to get there.

Tip: Align individual goals with company objectives. When employees see how their work contributes to the bigger picture, they are more likely to stay engaged and accountable.

2. Create a Feedback Loop That Builds Trust. Feedback plays a crucial role in maintaining accountability—but only when delivered constructively. Teams thrive when they have ongoing, two-way feedback loops that encourage self-reflection and continuous improvement.

A great example of this is Netflix’s “No Rules Rules” culture, where employees give candid feedback frequently, both upwards and sideways. This open communication builds trust, reduces silos, and ensures that performance issues are addressed in real-time.

Tactic: Schedule regular one-on-one meetings or team check-ins to discuss progress, identify challenges, and recalibrate goals. This reinforces accountability without making it feel like a top-down directive.

3. Recognize Efforts and Celebrate Wins. Accountability should feel rewarding, not punitive. Recognizing individual and team efforts reinforces a positive culture and motivates people to keep taking ownership of their work.

Consider implementing peer recognition programs where employees can celebrate each other’s contributions. These initiatives create a ripple effect—employees are more likely to hold themselves accountable when they feel seen and valued.

Pro Tip: Celebrate small wins along the way, not just major milestones. Regular recognition creates momentum and keeps motivation high.

Real-World Example: How HubSpot Embedded Accountability in Its DNA

HubSpot, a leading CRM platform, is well-known for its high-performance culture rooted in accountability. From the very beginning, HubSpot embedded its core values—like ownership and autonomy—into every aspect of the business. Managers don’t micromanage; instead, they empower employees to take risks, learn from mistakes, and own their decisions.

This approach has been instrumental in scaling HubSpot’s growth while maintaining a strong internal culture. The result? A business that continues to grow at an impressive pace—with happy employees who are aligned with company goals.

The Takeaway: Make Accountability Part of the Everyday Culture

Creating a high-performing team requires more than setting performance targets or relying on rules. True accountability emerges from a culture where ownership is shared, and collaboration is encouraged. Small business owners must model accountability from the top, reward efforts consistently, and foster environments where trust and feedback flow freely.

P.S.

Want to dive deeper into leadership strategies tailored for small business owners? Register for a free coaching session with Eric Whitmoyer to explore how leadership coaching can transform your business.

Register for a Free Initial Coaching Session