If You Host the Olympics, Will You Get Higher Economic Growth?
Average GDP growth for host nations before, at, and after the Olympic Games, for all Games since 1960. Year 0 = year of the Games, moving average.

If You Host the Olympics, Will You Get Higher Economic Growth?

Understanding the financial and economic impact of major investments like the Olympic Games and big infrastructure projects is critical for governments to make sound decisions about their expenditures. This is even more the case with the covid-19 pandemic, where debt-based major investments are used to stimulate the economy in attempts to avoid recession. After the splurge on the pandemic, a global economic climate of austerity in government spending is likely to return, in order to bring debt down again.

To illustrate the relationship between hosting the Olympics and economic growth, consider the Athens 2004 Games. Here cost overrun and associated debt from the Games weakened the Greek economy and contributed to the country's deep financial and economic crises, which began in 2007 and was dubbed the "forever crisis" by The Financial Times, because it seemed to never end (Flyvbjerg 2011, Kuper 2017).

Similarly, in June 2016 – less than two months before the Rio 2016 opening ceremony – Rio de Janeiro's governor declared a state of emergency to secure additional funding for the Games. When Rio decided to bid for the Olympics, the Brazilian economy was doing well. Now, almost a decade later, costs were escalating and the country was in its worst economic crisis since the 1930's with negative growth and a lack of funds to cover costs.

This is a common pattern due to the cyclical nature of recessions: if the economy had high GDP growth when a city decided to bid for the Games, which is typical, then during the seven to 11 years until the opening ceremony the economy is likely to weaken, as shown in the following figure, which shows the average GDP growth for host nations before, at, and after the Olympic Games, for all Games since 1960. Year 0 on the first axis is the year of the Games:

No alt text provided for this image

Potential hosts – and especially those with small and fragile economies – will want to make sure they do not end up like Athens and Rio. They can protect themselves by undertaking a realistic assessment of costs and cost risks before they bid for the Games.

For how to do this, and for full references to the above text, see:

Bent Flyvbjerg, Alexander Budzier, and Daniel Lunn, 2020, "Regression to the Tail: Why the Olympics Blow Up," Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space, published online September 15, free pdf available here: https://bit.ly/3bYfMWO.

Raphael Düa

DBA,FAICD, FAPE, GPCF, FPMCOS, MACS(Snr), CP, IP3, Grad DISC Consultant – Senior Planner and Senior Master Scheduler and Lead Project Controls

4 年

Montreal and Munich are classic examples of going broke. But Sydney did very well. We Aussies are smarter than the world thinks we are. During Covid-19, which we take very seriously only 35 per million Australians are dying. The US has a rate of 627 per million, 17.9 time our rate. Population numbers do not account for the difference. Our population is only 7.5% of the US. What this all means I am not certain, but it probably explains why so many projects fail. We keep our eye on the ball and deliver (well! most of the time) Paul, I am sure can create a series of curves out of these statistics. Something to do, on a wet Tuesday afternoon.

Darko Ursicic

Project Planner Offshore Wind

4 年

This is interesting, but there should be another curve with GDP curve of similar countries that were not hosting Olympic Games. For Greece it should be Southern Europe, for Brazil - Latin America, for China - East Asia etc.

Scary for my country, I hope Paris makes the right decisions

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Prof. Bent Flyvbjerg的更多文章

  • Four Ways to Scale Up

    Four Ways to Scale Up

    Figure 1 illustrates four ways to scale up a venture, based on a simple two-by-two matrix. On the horizontal axis, the…

    6 条评论
  • My First Megaproject: 20,000 Schools in Nepal

    My First Megaproject: 20,000 Schools in Nepal

    My first megaproject was Nepal's Basic and Primary Education Program (BPEP). This was a billion-dollar venture to…

    9 条评论
  • Building Back Better after Covid-19: What Does It Take?

    Building Back Better after Covid-19: What Does It Take?

    The massive stimulus spending programmes that governments use to restart economies in recession typically comprise…

    4 条评论
  • Six Steps to Better Olympic Games

    Six Steps to Better Olympic Games

    Hosting the Olympic Games is the most risky type of megaproject that a city or nation can take on, in terms of…

    7 条评论
  • Six Reasons Why Olympic Costs Blow Up

    Six Reasons Why Olympic Costs Blow Up

    With Alexander Budzier and Daniel Lunn [H]osts are forced to throw good money after bad, which is the type of behavior…

    9 条评论
  • 3 Things You Should Know about the Olympics, before You Decide to Host

    3 Things You Should Know about the Olympics, before You Decide to Host

    [T]he bid budget is more of a down payment than it is a budget; further installments will follow, written on the blank…

    1 条评论
  • Open letter to President of the IOC, Thomas Bach

    Open letter to President of the IOC, Thomas Bach

    Oxford 11 September 2020 Dear Thomas Bach, We hope you are well. We have noted with interest the IOC's response in the…

    4 条评论
  • Yes, You Can Generalize from One Case

    Yes, You Can Generalize from One Case

    "The secret to generalizing from case studies is the strategic selection of cases." It is a common tenet in the…

    2 条评论
  • What Is Scalability?

    What Is Scalability?

    With Atif Ansar, Alexander Budzier, and Daniel Lunn The Oxford English Dictionary defines "scalable" and "scalability"…

    5 条评论
  • Complementarity of Case Studies and Statistical Methods

    Complementarity of Case Studies and Statistical Methods

    The table below summarizes the complementarity between case studies and statistical methods. The main strength of the…

    4 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了