The old practice of "Quiet Cutting" seriously affects Employee Engagement, Performance and leads to Attrition!
Quiet Cutting - Monster - April 2024

The old practice of "Quiet Cutting" seriously affects Employee Engagement, Performance and leads to Attrition!

?? This term has appeared in management articles since last year and in some research after the Quiet Quitting trend.

?? 77% of workers have witnessed quiet cutting at their company, and 58% say they have been impacted by it.

?? 80% have less trust or loyalty to their employer and 79% no longer feel loyal to their employer,

But only 18% of employees would quit immediately, according to a new interesting research published by Monster using data from US employees during March 2024.


?What is Quiet Cutting?

First of all, this practice is an old practice with a new name. Researchers defined Quiet cutting when employers reassigning workers to new roles (downgrading roles, responsibilities, and/or compensation) in hopes they will eventually quit so the company saves the cost of severance.

?? Unlike a dismissal, employees will be persuaded to resign on their own.


?Huge impact on Employee satisfaction

Dissatisfaction is the most impact

Researchers noticed that the majority of workers have complaints about their opportunities for growth at their company.

Employees have:

  • Reported a lack of opportunity for upwards mobility (59%)
  • Experienced a lack of career direction from their direct manager (57%)
  • Did not receive an expected bonus (36%)
  • Did not receive a promotion they thought was deserved (31%)
  • Had a salary reduction (15%)


?Quiet cutting impacts Employee Performance and Productivity

Researchers noticed that knowing quiet cutting is occurring at their company has affected workers’ performance in the following ways:

  • 80% have less trust or loyalty to their employer
  • 65% report that it contributes to a toxic work environment
  • 64% experience a negative impact on their relationship with leadership
  • 62% find work to be more stressful
  • 58% feel less motivated to execute their duties
  • 58% report their overall wellbeing has suffered
  • Only 2% of workers say it has had no impact on them


?Different Employees reactions after Quiet Cutting

Different scenarios after Quiet Cutting


Researchers have found that workers react in different ways if they realize they are being affected by Quiet cutting:

?? Talk it out

  • 24% would speak with their supervisor immediately
  • 24% would ask their manager how they could improve their performance
  • 20% would speak with HR
  • 14% would speak with executive leadership

?? Adapt

  • 27% would remain in their role and adapt to changes
  • 21% would attempt to negotiate the terms of their modified role
  • 10% would work harder to preserve their role

?? Leave

  • 18% would quit immediately

?? Do nothing

  • However, 9% of workers would do nothing if they realized they were being impacted by quiet cutting


Researchers discovered that employees who have witnessed or directly experienced quiet cutting have seen their long term relationship with their company impacted in the following ways:

? 79% lost trust in their company

? 79% no longer feel loyal to their employer

? 75% wouldn’t recommend their company to a friend

? 73% lost respect for their senior leadership

? 71% are no longer interested in a long term role at their company



?? ???? ???????????????? ????????:

This research highlights this old practice of "Quiet Cutting" that appeared last year and create a climate of fear and mistrust between employers and employees. This phenomenon impacts employee engagement and can seriously affect the reputation of the company as well so organizations need transparent communication and ethical practices in workforce management to eradicate this bad behavior.


Thank you ?? Monster researchers team for these insightful findings:

Scott Gutz

Dave Ulrich


?? Follow me as a LinkedIn Top Voice on LinkedIn (+32 000), and click the ?? at the top of my profile page to stay on top of the latest on new best?HR, People Analytics, Human Capital and Future of Work research, become more effective in your HR function and support your business, and join the conversation on my posts.

???Join?more than 15,500+ people and subscribe to receive my Weekly People Research

Everyday, I share a new research article about?People Analytics, Human Capital, HR analytics, Human Resources, Talent,…

#quietcutting #attrition #trust #performance

Ahlam Bakkal

I build effective Compensation & Benefits structures for GCC-based organizations. To win in the talent market.

7 个月

For companies to reduce the impact of quiet cutting, it would be fair that the line managers are more transparent with their employees on why they want them to leave, and provide a good 'handshake' for that. Typically, when companies do quiet cutting, it's usually to avoid to pay for that handshake. At least, when there is that transparency, open communication and payment for the employee's exit, it would be more fair and more respectful to the employee. Nicolas BEHBAHANI

回复

Thank you for sharing our data, Nicolas BEHBAHANI ??

Noah Little

The only CSM coach who ACTUALLY IS A CSM (not retired) ? I help underpaid and laid off CSM's get Customer Success Jobs WITHOUT networking via my F.I.R.E framework ?? ? $9.6M in Salaries ? 96 success stories ?? Proof ??

7 个月

Your research sheds light on the detrimental impacts of Quiet Cutting in organizations, emphasizing the importance of transparent communication and ethical practices. Nicolas BEHBAHANI

Kailash Raghuvanshi

Growing business in Hybrid Cloud, Gen AI, and Banking - transforming through strategic consulting, increasing profits by developing high performing engaged teams, and delighting clients through delivery

7 个月

70+% percentages are significant, but not surprising. This issue is correlated with other issues, and would create bigger issues for the organizations/leaders in the medium and long term; some leaders might be oblivious to this impact; due to short term visible gains.

回复
Namita Gopinathan,MBA

Human Resource Professional | MBA | Coporate Recruiting Professional- ASA | Ex-Wirtgen Group,A John Deere Company

7 个月

Insightful post!Thank you. I am new to this term. After reading a little bit about this topic, It's concerning to see the detrimental impact it has on both employees and company trust. Fostering an environment of openness and trust, employers can mitigate the negative impacts outlined in the research, such as loss of employee loyalty, trust, and respect. This can also be achieved through regular team meetings, anonymous suggestion boxes, or one-on-one sessions with managers.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了