Obituary: Annual Performance Review: “Ranking†Has Died
Daniel Patrick Forrester
Accelerating C-Suites in Tech companies to align for sustained revenue growth and relevance. Founder, Entrepreneur, Author, and Adjunct Faculty helping Chief Product Officers and Managers to thrive.
Annual Performance Review (APR) died last Sunday after a decades-long reign over Human Resources. He is perhaps best remembered for the millions of hours he spent categorizing people into meaningless buckets and alienating workers around the world.
Nick-named “Ranking†by his very few friends and confidants, APR had been suffering for the last few years from several chronic conditions, including subjectivity, silo-mentality, bureaucracy, posturing, detachment, and gaming the system. Though bed-bound for weeks, APR kept working until the end. He was found smiling and hugging an iPad open to one of his favorite spreadsheets, which qualitatively ranked employees at the multinational company he had been advising
Reaction to his death has been pouring in from around the world. Openness, Candor and Opportunity Costs-- all vocal opponents of APR, took to Twitter:
Growth-Planning, who has flourished with international acclaim in recent years, shared a haunting picture of a leader mentoring a junior employee with patience and wisdom during their regular, monthly check-in. Within an hour, the image became a symbol for Leaders seeking to live in a new corporate culture devoid of APR’s grip.
APR’s memorial service will not take place until next year. His will stipulated that those wishing to attend must apply online and be ranked in the top 5% of mourners (as determined by an algorithm he worked on for years). Those wishing to speak must show proof of a TED Talk with at least five million views. Would-be speakers will also be required to interview with APR’s appointed Global Leadership Team (GLT) and demonstrate their ability to show his life as “well above the mean.â€
APR was born in the late 1960s to parents Rigid and Structure. Both were activists inside large companies throughout the 1980s. APR earned his PhD in Hierarchy from the University of High-Costs and Unclear-ROI in 1993. There, he studied under the famous academics, Microsoft Excel and Pivot Table.
APR is survived by several younger siblings and numerous cousins. All declined to be interviewed for this article, though one cousin did remark for the record: “Whatever we told APR we were most proud of always came back to haunt us, so we just smiled and left him alone.â€
The family has asked that, in lieu of flowers, mourners subjectively rank people in their community or companies from lowest to highest value. Newly empowered employees have, however, rejected this request and begun to walk arm-in-arm into their offices around the world. According to several sources, water coolers are becoming hubs for recovering employees to share, convene, and dream again about why they joined their companies and how they hope to grow.
Agile Lean Agility Capability Advisory Owner @ Richter Consulting Group | Strategic Business Consultant
8 å¹´Allowed short-term non servant team based/collaborative performance, not to mention the poor leadership behaviours and biased outcomes for some !
“Complex problem solver and influential solutions provider†for any environment the Kaizen way | Operations Leadership | Transformation | Kaizen Leader | Toyota Production System | Specialty - Lean in Nuclear Power
8 å¹´The basis for the legacy perf system was always fouled. High performing organizations will not have them due to the fact everyone contributes everyday. The legacy system is a stick with a carrot and sometimes the carrot is nowhere the stick.
CEO and Dir of Application R&D, introducing executives to humaneering - 21st-century OS for the human side of business (humaneeringtech.com). Resolve people problems, unleash achievement, delight employees and customers.
8 å¹´The comprehensive Performance Management System (e.g., performance target setting, imaginary continuous coaching and feedback, annual ritual of performance appraisal forms to complete, normal distribution ratings or linear rankings, employee accountability for process/system performance), which was based on now outdated and disproven conceptions of human nature, if fully costed, will go down in business history as the single most costly ill-conceived management initiative. Can you think of another that was more costly?
Vice President of Sales | Def Tech | OSINT | Artificial Intelligence | Strategy, BD & Sales
8 å¹´but...but...but...how will we figure out bonuses and raises without the all knowing APR??? He appeared to know so much about who was most valuable, how will I get to know my people now? NICE OBIT.