Nuanced Landscape of Product-Market-Customer Fit: Why We Need to Go Beyond Product-Market Fit

Pursuing the often-quoted term "Product-Market Fit (PMF)" has almost become a rite of passage for every entrepreneur. While PMF is undeniably crucial, it may only cover part of the scope of what businesses need to achieve for long-term sustainability and success.

I propose extending this framework to "Product-Market-Customer Fit" to address the nuanced relationship between markets and the individual customers that comprise them.

Traditional Understanding of Product-Market Fit

PMF is the alignment between your product and a robust market demand. It is the sweet spot where your product satisfies a need and does so in a market large enough to drive sustained growth and profitability. Andrew Chen, a renowned venture capitalist, has identified a few signals that indicate a strong PMF, such as customer surveys, competitive metrics, and market tests.

Standard Approach to Achieving Product-Market Fit

Dan Olsen, in his book The Lean Product Playbook, outlines the following high-level steps to reach PMF:

1. Determine Your Target Customer: Identify your product's most promising customer segments.
2. Identify Underserved Needs: Conduct research to pinpoint your target audience's unmet or underserved needs.
3. Define Your Value Proposition: Could you develop a compelling narrative that outlines why your product is uniquely suited to meet these needs?
4. Specify Your MVP Feature Set: Could you determine the core features essential for satisfying your target audience's needs?
5. Develop and Test Your MVP: Create a beta version and get it in the hands of your target customers to gather invaluable feedback for refinement.

These steps offer a structural approach towards achieving PMF. However, one must question: Is this comprehensive enough?

Introducing Product-Market-Customer Fit: The Missing Puzzle Piece

What we often overlook is that 'market' is an abstraction. It's an averaged model of multiple customer behaviours, needs, and preferences. Therefore, achieving PMF might satisfy the 'market's average needs but may miss out on meeting the nuanced requirements of different customer sub-segments within that market.

In a Product-Market-Customer Fit model, we refine our strategies better to match the variances among customers within a market. This entails:

1. Segmenting Your Target Market Further: Go beyond broad categorizations to identify micro-segments within your target market, each with distinct needs and pain points.
2. Personalized Value Propositions: Tailor your value propositions for each of these segments. One size does not fit all, even within a defined market.
3. Adapt Your MVP: When designing your Minimum Viable Product, consider whether a more targeted MVP could better serve one or more of these micro-segments.
4. Feedback Loops for Each Customer Segment: When you test your MVP, please make sure you have a feedback mechanism that considers the perspectives of each of your identified customer segments.

Leveraging Business Advisory for Product-Market-Customer Fit

If all this seems overwhelming, engaging a business advisor specialising in this nuanced approach might be beneficial. They can offer tailored expertise to help you identify micro-segments, develop targeted value propositions, and, importantly, measure the right metrics for each customer segment.

Conclusion: A New Framework for Business Success

The traditional model of Product-Market Fit serves as a robust foundation, but it often needs more granularity to meet individual customer expectations. By extending this to Product-Market-Customer Fit, we can navigate the complexities and subtleties of customer preferences within any given market. Adopting this framework can significantly elevate your chances of building a successful, sustainable business in an increasingly competitive landscape.

So, if you're navigating the complex waters of establishing a robust business, it's time to reassess whether you're truly achieving Product-Market Fit or if it's the more nuanced Product-Market-Customer Fit that you should be aiming for.

?

Author

Andy Hamer

Andy has consistently been the guiding force behind numerous B2B technology startups, spanning areas like hardware, networking, services, and SaaS. Not restricted to just the UK, his influence is recognized internationally. With an illustrious track record, he possesses a knack for shaping innovative go-to-market strategies, addressing the needs of emerging startups to sprawling global corporations.

Years of professional experience, I am well-versed in the realms of communications, electronics, information services, silicon, and software. Throughout an expansive 40-year career, Andy has secured esteemed senior management and board positions in renowned firms, including Marconi, Strategic Analytics, Equant, Informa, Wongs Electronics, and Bentley Systems.

More recently, he delved into the Architecture, Engineering, Construction, and Owner sectors, specifically in the areas of building information management and digital twins. Here, his leadership acumen was evident as he worked at senior and board levels at institutions like Codebook, Xinaps, Invicara, Bentley, XYZ Reality, and Archdesk.

Andy, a graduate with a BA (Hons) in Marketing Engineering, is also a certified BIM Information Manager. Adding to his repertoire, he has authored a book on structured data management in BIM. His proficiencies have been further stamped with his esteemed title as a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Marketing (FCIM).