Non-Destructive Testing for Detailed Bridge Condition Survey
Non-Destructive Testing for Detailed Bridge Condition Survey - FPrimeC Solutions Inc.

Non-Destructive Testing for Detailed Bridge Condition Survey

We were recently involved in a detailed bridge deck condition survey in Perth, Ontario. The main objective was to inspect and evaluate the existing condition of the bridge deck, identify surface and subsurface defects, and evaluate the corrosion activity. As one might expect, the scope of project leaves little room for creativity and innovation. Concrete sawing and coring has long become market standards, and it looks quite impossible to bring any change. Half-Cell corrosion potential mapping and ground penetrating radar (for rebar locate) were the only NDT methods involved. As we were trying to deliver the scope of the project, I was thinking how things can be improved withing a cost-effective and timely framework.

The Second Strategic Highway Research Program - NDT Concrete Bridge Deck

The Second Strategic Highway Research Program (SHRP 2) has identified various NDE techniques for condition survey for of bridge decks. The report ranks these methods based on their effectiveness in detection and characterization of four major deterioration types: delamination, concrete degradation, reinforcement corrosion, and vertical cracking. SHRP 2 useful review of some of the NDT methods such as the ground penetrating radar (GPR), impact echo (IE), ultrasonic surface waves (USW), half-cell potential (HCP), electrical resistivity (ER), and chain drag/hammer sounding for bridge deck evaluation.

The Most Common Questions

In most bridge deck condition survey projects, the contractor/consultant is asked to provide the following information about the bridge deck:

  • Visual Inspection and Sounding (Learn more)
  • Thickness of Concrete Deck
  • Cover thickness
  • Concrete Cutting/Sawing
  • Extract Concrete Cores
  • Inspect condition of steel rebar and concrete
  • Corrosion inspection and monitoring
  • Compressive Strength
  • Chloride Content (Chloride at steel rebar level)
  • Air content

Except for corrosion inspection, where half-cell corrosion potential mapping has become market standard, application of NDT in other areas are very limited. The following discusses how different NDT methods can be utilized to provide information about some of these parameters.

Concrete Coring - Concrete Delamination

Visual Inspection and Chain Dragging

Chain dragging or hammer sounding is still one of the most popular tests. The main reason behind their wide use is its simplicity, and cost. No special equipment is needed. However, the application of the method for detecting delaminated area can be limited when the background noise (from the traffic) is too high.

Most recent developments in this area is the use of advanced acoustic sensor to collect the hollow sound at the traffic speed. Ground Penetrating Radar is another promising non-destructive alternative for this purpose. The main advantage of these methods is that they do not need special traffic control or lane closure.

Thickness of Concrete Deck

Extracting through the thickness concrete core (full depth) is used to evaluate the total thickness of the concrete deck. While this is important in evaluating the dead load of the bridge deck, the procedure provide limited information. For bridge inspections that Bridge Master is not used, access to the underneath of the deck is often limited and extracting full depth core is challenging.

Impact-Echo Test for Bridge Deck Condition Survey

As an alternative, Non-Destructive Test method such as Ultrasonic Pulse Echo can be used to evaluate the thickness of the bridge deck. While the accuracy of the test method in areas with dense rebar spacing is limited, the results from the Mid-Span are accurate. Impact-Echo is another great NDT tool for evaluating the thickness of concrete decks.

Concrete Cover Thickness

Evaluating concrete cover thickness using Non-destructive test method is already a market standard. The test results can be verified at the location of concrete sawing. Most modern Ground Penetrating Radar devices can provide a good estimate of the rebar depth. Assuming that the rebar depth is not going to change over time (unless there is a major intervention), application of NDT can significantly reduce the number and areas that need to be uncovered for this purpose.

Concrete Strength

Concrete cores are often extracted to study the mechanical and durability properties of concrete. Cores can be tested to provide information about the compressive strength. They can also be tested for chloride content and air content. While the total number of concrete cores can be quite significant for larger bridge decks, a few of these cores are further studied for strength or chloride content. Some of the most common challenges of concrete coring is summarized here.

Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity (UPV)

When it comes to concrete strength, combined NDT methods can be used. A combination of rebound hammer and ultrasonic pulse velocity can help engineers estimate the strength of concrete. The method can help reduce the number of cores that are needed for this purpose.

Concrete Chloride Content

Chloride and air content are the only tests that cannot be determined through NDT at this time; However, the use of surface electrical resistivity can enhance our understanding of the bridge deck condition.

Corrosion Inspection and Monitoring

Corrosion inspection in concrete bridge deck is mainly done through Half-Cell Corrosion Potential Survey (ASTM C 876). Half-cell test provides valuable information about the likelihood of corrosion activity in concrete bridge decks. However, the results can be inconclusive for epoxy coated rebar, decks with asphalt overlays, and decks with waterproofing membrane.

No alt text provided for this image

Another important test can be corrosion rate monitoring. This is very useful in evaluating the service life of the bridge structure. Surface electrical resistivity can also help engineers in getting useful information about the concrete quality.

Concluding Remarks

Most of the tests that are currently included in most bridge deck condition surveys can be replaced or complemented with commercially available NDT solutions in the market. Most NDT solutions can deliver results with same or higher accuracy, while reducing the inspection timeline, intervention in the structure, and reducing the damage to critical elements. Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) solutions are becoming more cost-effective for general applications, and can help engineers and owners in near future.



DWARKADAS SHARMA

CIVIL CONTRACTOR'S

5 年

GOOD ARTICLE ON THE STRUCTRAL

回复
Yaroslav Bondarenko

4Dseist Entrepreneur, 4D-7Dseist technology Developer, Founder of 4D-7Dseist Projects

5 年

A sensational 2D-3Dseist mapping of lineament structure of stresses and deformations by decoding an image showing a lateral spread triggered by the Alaska Earthquake! https://flic.kr/p/2h7P53P

回复
Karla J. Benitez

Directora Ejecutiva del Instituto Salvadore?o del Cemento y el Concreto

5 年
Karla J. Benitez

Directora Ejecutiva del Instituto Salvadore?o del Cemento y el Concreto

5 年

Great article, thank you for sharing it.

回复
Suresh Chandra Tripathi

Civil Engineer with >37 yrs of exp in Green & Brownfield Projects. Expert in Precast Technology (11 yrs), KyC using Maturity Meter, SHM, 4D-5D integration BIM services, Diversity Inclusion (Human Factor)

5 年

Good read on condition survey But this way is time consuming SHM is very much needed for bridge performance & RLA

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Hamed Layssi的更多文章

  • Miami Condo Collapse - A Perspective

    Miami Condo Collapse - A Perspective

    First things first, my condolences to all who have lost their loved ones in the tragic collapse of Miami Condo in…

    20 条评论
  • How to Test Concrete Using Impact-Echo

    How to Test Concrete Using Impact-Echo

    Introduction to the Impact-Echo Method? Impact Echo is a non-destructive testing (NDT) method for structural integrity…

    1 条评论
  • How Nondestructive Testing can Help Construction Engineers & Contractors?

    How Nondestructive Testing can Help Construction Engineers & Contractors?

    Over the past few years, we have helped many contactors from Coast to Coast to Coast with the problems that might rise…

    12 条评论
  • Ultrasonic Crosshole Test for Drilled Shafts

    Ultrasonic Crosshole Test for Drilled Shafts

    What is Crosshole Sonic Logging? Ultrasonic Crosshole Test or Corsshole Sonic Logging (CSL) is a widely used…

    4 条评论
  • Quality Control of Drilled Shafts - Pile Integrity

    Quality Control of Drilled Shafts - Pile Integrity

    Pile Integrity refers (ASTM D 5882) to certain characteristics of deep foundations and piles such as: Physical…

    8 条评论
  • Concrete Imaging and Scanning for Structural Assessment

    Concrete Imaging and Scanning for Structural Assessment

    Structural Assessment is an engineering process where the engineer, or well-trained inspector collects observations and…

    1 条评论
  • Leadership at the Time of Covid-19

    Leadership at the Time of Covid-19

    Corona virus is the headline of the news in many places around the world. Covid-19 spreads just fast enough to send…

  • What is Pile Integrity Testing ?

    What is Pile Integrity Testing ?

    Over the past two years, I have heavily been involved with developing and promoting iPile for the low strain integrity…

    11 条评论
  • Concrete Foundations and How to Test Them

    Concrete Foundations and How to Test Them

    Concrete foundations are a key component in every major structure. They provide the much-needed stability to structural…

    3 条评论
  • Non-Destructive Testing of Wind Turbine Foundation

    Non-Destructive Testing of Wind Turbine Foundation

    Over the past decade, Canada has heavily invested in wind energy, increasing its annual capacity from nearly 2,000 MW…

    4 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了