A new course for our colleges and universities
John Stackhouse
Senior Vice-President, Office of the CEO, Royal Bank of Canada. Host of Disruptors, an RBC podcast
Our colleges and universities are among the greatest forces of change in society. They have been for centuries.?And yet they’re also among the most resistant to change.?
How do we change that?
Some of the country’s top post secondary leaders and executives met this week in Toronto to discuss the challenge, as part of the Business + Higher Education Roundtable , which is chaired by RBC ’s CEO Dave McKay .
Here are some of the key points I took away:
1. We need to instill more risk in post-secondary education. That means more risk-taking with curriculum design, delivery models, research and learning. Perhaps letting students help lead the way can help. They’re the ones taking big risks, with the prime of their lives, by investing themselves in post-secondary education.
2.?Better align post-secondary education with the Canadian economy.?Sometimes colleges and universities seek to reflect the society or economy that they envision and can get a little too far away from the one they represent. We have a diverse economy, including a very innovative natural resources sector that would benefit from more post-secondary engagement. Same for the digital economy, including artificial intelligence.
3.?Change the pricing model. Post secondary education still relies on largely a fixed-price, fixed-term model, while much of the economy has moved to dynamic pricing. How can the education of tomorrow reflect the economy of choice, and pricing that reflects that.?Can the sector experiment with subscription models, or membership models? Or can basic programs be priced over longer periods of time
领英推荐
4. Delivery models. How can the sector continue to evolve the model of getting education to a diverse market? We need more mobility and wider reach. The pandemic showed how education can be scaled to markets not just across the country but around the world.?
5. More differentiation.?Of course there is some stratification in our post-secondary system, but we may need more.?More private universities, for example and more elite programs, including more PhD programs. While Canada does well in post-secondary enrolment, we lag the U.S. in PHD achievement, especially in the sectors that are driving the economy and society. (See Point 2.)
6. International students. We all know about the crisis, with a far greater number of students coming into the country in recent years than was widely anticipated. How do we use this crisis to our advantage, to set a new international student strategy for the next decade? How can we keep Canada at the forefront of international education and brings many of the world’s best and brightest to our schools without diminishing the overall academic experience and broader social outcomes and costs?
7. More corporate connectivity.?One of Canada’s productivity challenges is the clearly insufficient levels of corporate research and development. That can be changed through our colleges and universities, just as we see in the U.S. It’s on corporate Canada, as well as the post-secondary sector, to lean into the challenge, and develop a much more ambitious goal for corporate and academic research, especially in the areas that will shape Canada’s economic future.
One of Canada’s greatest strengths is post-secondary education. But we’ve not invested adequately in it. Colleges and universities, with some great exceptions, have not kept pace with a rapidly changing world.
It’s a great moment for business, academia and government to come together to chart a new course.
Writer
2 个月The plethora of human rights and other legal cases levelled against the University of Toronto, Canada's largest and best known university, are telling. Ever since records have been kept by the university beginning in the year 1913, it has been involved in 472 legal disputes. The case against UofT which has by far the highest number of citations -- 154 citations and counting -- involves a newly-minted PhD and Canadian citizen in 2004 who was banned from setting foot on university premises for over six years. The University was found "not guilty" due to the statute of limitations which requires plaintiffs to press charges within a year of the first act of discrimination. Fortunately, the legal citations of this have ensured that thousands of researchers have been educated about how nominally public Canadian educational institutions operate: https://www.canlii.org/en/on/onhrt/doc/2010/2010hrto1495/2010hrto1495.html
Writer
2 个月Colleges and universities are ideally meant to be places where young minds are challenged and inspired to push the boundaries of knowledge and advancement. However, Canada's deep-seated "culture of silence" -- based on the dictum see nothing, hear nothing, and say nothing to fit in -- continues to cast a long shadow over the country's educational and government institutions. How and why else would a country with "free speech" wait until 1996, 14 years after adopting its Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and becoming an independent country, to officially abolish its century-and-a-half long Indian Residential School System? If you can't discuss issues openly and honestly, how can you be expected to solve them?Any real progress will require overcoming Canada's stultifying culture of silence. Here's an essay of mine on the ways in which Canadian institutions hinder the development of a sense of solidarity and belonging among the population, especially immigrants. It’s titled, "The Missing Link in Canada's Government and Educational Institutions: Promoting Belonging and Solidarity" https://alidadmafinezam.medium.com/the-missing-link-in-canadas-government-and-educational-institutions-promoting-belonging-and-378b6140c91b
Owner, Altima Millwork, Altima Homes and Altima Kitchens And Closets | Transforming Spaces with Precision and Style | Elevating experiences with Commercial Millwork
2 个月Sounds like an important discussion, John! Ensuring our colleges and universities evolve with the changing world is key to building a future-ready workforce. Looking forward to seeing the innovative solutions that come out of this...
Tooling Manager at Molded Precision Components | Skilled Trades Advocate | Member of PAC Advisory Committee at Georgian College | OYAP Manufacturing Advisory Committee Simcoe County
2 个月John Stackhouse I’m happy to hear that these type of meetings are taking place, we all know that if we’re not progressing in the way we do things we regressing. With the increased awareness from the Ontario Government | Gouvernement de l’Ontario on the need for 500,000 skilled trades people over the next 10 years in Ontario. I’m curious to hear if the skilled trades came up in your conversations? This could happen in the form of the collaboration with industry you touched on, it could also involve “advanced” training for specific trades. I’m not 100% what this would look like, but I believe there is an opportunity there for Universities to capitalize on.
Institutional Analyst, Board member, Adjunct Faculty, Data Adorer, Mentor, Community Advocate
2 个月Thanks John Stackhouse for sharing the summary of lessons learned. Some of these nuggets of wisdom need more clarification. Is there a detailed outline of policy recommendations out there from the Round table conference?