Navigating the ETRM Maze: Choosing the Right Solution for Power, Gas, and Crude Trading

Selecting the right Energy Trading and Risk Management (ETRM) solution is a critical decision that depends on the commodities a company trades - whether power and renewables, natural gas, liquid hydrocarbons, or environmental products. Among the leading ETRM solutions, RightAngle, Allegro, and Endur stand out due to their specialized capabilities.

This article explores how these solutions address specific client needs with real-world examples.

RightAngle for Liquid Hydrocarbons (Crude Oil and Refined Products)

RightAngle is widely used by companies trading crude oil, refined products, and liquid hydrocarbons. It is particularly strong in logistics, refinery integration, and risk management.

Key Features & Strengths

• Logistics and Supply Chain Management: Tracks crude and refined product movement through pipelines, terminals, and marine vessels.
• Refinery Integration: Manages feedstock procurement and scheduling for refineries.
• Blend Optimization: Ensures cost-effective blending of crude and refined products.
• Risk Management & Hedging: Tracks exposure across physical and financial trades.

Example: North American Refiner

A major North American refiner handling crude imports and refined product distribution implemented RightAngle to streamline operations.

• Challenges: Manual logistics tracking, lack of integration with refinery scheduling, and difficulty managing multi-currency transactions.
• Solution: RightAngle automated scheduling, integrated refinery operations, and improved hedging strategies. The refiner reduced inventory costs and enhanced trading efficiency.

Allegro for Power & Renewables, Natural Gas, Liquid Hydrocarbons, and Environmental Products

Allegro is a versatile ETRM solution supporting multiple commodities, including power and renewables, natural gas, liquid hydrocarbons, and environmental products.

Key Features & Strengths

• Power & Renewables: Real-time power trading, renewable forecasting, and market integration.
• Natural Gas: Pipeline and storage management, nominations, and balancing.
• Liquid Hydrocarbons: Crude oil, refined products, and NGL (Natural Gas Liquids) trading.
• Environmental Products: Carbon credits, RECs (Renewable Energy Certificates), and emissions trading.
• Contract & Pricing Flexibility: Manages index-based pricing and long-term contracts.
• Risk Analytics: Supports VaR (Value at Risk) and scenario analysis.

Example 1: European Natural Gas Trader

A European gas company needed to optimize its pipeline scheduling and manage gas storage amid increasing market volatility.

• Challenges: Inefficient nominations, high imbalance penalties, and limited market visibility.
• Solution: Allegro provided real-time pipeline scheduling, integrated with TSO platforms, and improved demand forecasting. The company reduced imbalance costs and improved trading decisions.

Example 2: US Renewable Energy Provider

A US-based energy provider managing solar, wind, and hydro power assets wanted to improve renewable trading and REC (Renewable Energy Certificate) management.

• Challenges: Difficulty forecasting intermittent generation and meeting regulatory compliance.
• Solution: Allegro integrated with market operators and automated REC tracking. The provider optimized renewable generation bids and ensured compliance with sustainability goals.

Endur for Power, Natural Gas, and Environmental Products

Endur is known for its real-time power trading, natural gas management, and environmental products trading. It is widely used by utilities, independent power producers (IPPs), and multi-commodity traders.

Key Features & Strengths

• Real-Time Power Market Integration: Connects with ISOs (ERCOT, PJM, CAISO) for spot trading.
• Natural Gas: Supports trading, scheduling, nominations, and risk management.
• Environmental Products: Manages carbon trading, renewable credits, and emissions compliance.
• Advanced Risk Management: Dynamic hedging strategies for volatile markets.
• Regulatory Compliance: Ensures adherence to REMIT, EMIR, and other regulations.

Example 1: Independent Power Producer (IPP) Managing Renewables & Thermal Assets

A European IPP with a mix of renewable and conventional generation needed a solution to optimize power trading and risk.

• Challenges: Lack of real-time integration with ISO platforms, poor forecasting accuracy, and regulatory compliance issues.
• Solution: Endur provided real-time market integration, automated reporting, and improved risk analytics. The IPP reduced imbalance costs and increased trading profitability.

Example 2: US Natural Gas Utility

A US-based gas utility needed a comprehensive trading and risk platform to manage its natural gas portfolio.

• Challenges: Complex pipeline nominations, seasonal demand fluctuations, and exposure to gas price volatility.
• Solution: Endur provided a centralized gas trading system with real-time risk monitoring, contract management, and demand forecasting. The utility improved operational efficiency and reduced financial risk.

Comparison of RightAngle, Allegro, and Endur

Future-Proofing the ETRM Solution:

With energy markets rapidly evolving due to decarbonization, hydrogen trading, and digitalization, ETRM solutions must adapt:

• RightAngle: Expanding into biofuels and renewable liquid hydrocarbons.
• Allegro: Supporting emerging commodities like hydrogen, LNG, and carbon markets.
• Endur: Strengthening renewables, grid balancing, and battery storage trading.

Conclusion:

Choosing the right ETRM solution - RightAngle, Allegro, or Endur - depends on your client’s commodity focus, operational complexity, and regulatory requirements.

• RightAngle is ideal for liquid hydrocarbons, focusing on logistics, refining, and blending.
• Allegro provides a multi-commodity platform, excelling in power, gas, renewables, and environmental products.
• Endur is best for power and natural gas markets, ensuring real-time trading, risk management, and regulatory compliance.

By aligning the right solution with specific business challenges, companies can optimize trading, manage risk, and stay ahead in the dynamic energy markets.

Disclaimer: The opinions and views expressed in this [article/post/poll] are entirely my own and do not represent those of my employer or any associated organization.

Most of the statistics and information has been sourced from various publicly available open sources and respective organization websites. Therefore, the accuracy of the figures and information is only as reliable as the sources.

Subscribe to my Newsletter for free: LinkedIn