Navigating Crisis: A Guide to Overcoming the Ostrich Paradox

In times of crisis, human behavior often takes unexpected turns. The "ostrich paradox," a term coined by behavioral economist Howard Kunreuther, refers to the tendency of individuals to ignore or underestimate the likelihood and impact of low-probability, high-consequence events. This paradox can lead to poor decision-making and exacerbate the effects of a crisis.

Understanding and overcoming the ostrich paradox is crucial for effective crisis management, whether it's a natural disaster, a financial meltdown, a health emergency, or any other crisis.

Understanding the Ostrich Paradox

The ostrich paradox stems from psychological factors that influence our perception of risk and our ability to make rational decisions in the face of uncertainty. One key factor is our innate aversion to acknowledging improbable yet catastrophic events. Additionally, cognitive biases, such as the availability heuristic (relying on readily available information), confirmation bias (seeking information that supports our pre-existing beliefs), and optimism bias (believing we are less likely to experience negative events), contribute to our tendency to downplay potential crises.

?

Strategies to Avoid the Effects of the Ostrich Paradox

Education and Awareness: The first step to overcoming the ostrich paradox is to educate yourself and your community about the potential risks. By understanding the nature of the crisis, its potential consequences, and historical examples, you can counteract the tendency to underestimate the impact.

Scenario Planning: Engage in scenario planning exercises. Develop and discuss hypothetical crisis situations, including worst-case scenarios through When/Then Thinking and 5/15 Crisis Rehearsal. This can help you mentally prepare for the unexpected and reduce the shock factor if the crisis does occur.

Diverse Perspectives: Encourage diverse viewpoints and engage experts. When making decisions collectively, a variety of opinions can help avoid groupthink.? Groupthink is a psychological phenomenon in which people strive for consensus within a group. In many cases, people will set aside their own personal beliefs or adopt the opinions of the rest of the group. Groupthink causes people to ignore or silence opposing viewpoints, creating the illusion that members of the group are in agreement. This may cause them to ignore potential dangers or take excessive risks. Encourage your team members to have a more balanced assessment of risks and potential outcomes.

Data-Driven Decision Making: Rely on data and statistics rather than gut feelings. Understanding the probability and potential consequences of different outcomes can aid in making more rational and informed decisions.

Regular Updates: When a crisis strikes, stay informed about the situation through reliable sources. Regular updates on the crisis and its developments can help prevent the ostrich paradox by keeping the potential threat at the forefront of your mind.

Preparedness Measures: Actively engage in preparedness measures. Whether it's creating an emergency kit (Go Bag), having a crisis management plan in place (E.O.P.), or undergoing relevant training, taking tangible steps toward preparedness can make the crisis feel more real and manageable.

Psychological Training: Train yourself to recognize cognitive biases and emotional responses that may lead to ignoring potential crises. Mindfulness techniques and cognitive-behavioral strategies can help you approach the situation with a clearer and more balanced mindset.

Leadership and Communication: If you're in a leadership position, it's crucial to communicate openly and transparently about the crisis. Downplaying risks or withholding information can amplify the ostrich paradox. Encourage open discussions and empower others to voice their concerns.

Conclusion

The ostrich paradox is a cognitive trap that can lead to disastrous consequences during a crisis. To effectively manage and mitigate the impacts of crises, it's essential to recognize and counteract this tendency to underestimate risks. Individuals and communities can navigate crises with a more rational and informed approach by fostering awareness, seeking diverse perspectives, relying on data, and actively engaging in preparedness. Overcoming the ostrich paradox requires a combination of education, self-awareness, ongoing crisis rehearsal, and a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths – all of which are vital for effective crisis management and crisis leadership.

About the Author:?Michael C. Kimball has over 30 years of experience as a sworn law enforcement officer in the State of California.?Michael helped to co-develop the Monterey Peninsula Regional S.W.A.T. team and was both a Tactical Commander and later the Logistics Commander for the Team.?Michael Co-Authored one of the State of California’s First Active Shooter Protocols back in the early 1990s and again post-Columbine.

?1989 Michael Founded his company, and in 2000, his company formally became M.C. Kimball and Associates, LLC.?Michael is a Nationally Certified Instructor in Options Based Training to Mitigate Active Killers and has traveled nationwide with Homeland Security since 2010, conducting train-the-trainer for School Districts, Hospitals, Businesses, Churches, and the Hospitality Industry in English and Spanish. In 2021, Michael and his executive team of experts developed the We’ve Got Your Back ? Program (A Team Approach to School Safety), a trauma-informed, inclusive safety training program for students.

?

?