Navigating chokepoints: How Suez and Panama Canal disruptions are changing global trade routes

TL:DR

Maritime chokepoints like the Suez and Panama Canals are crucial to global trade but face increasing disruptions due to climate challenges, geopolitical tensions, and operational inefficiencies. These disruptions lead to higher costs, increased emissions, and supply chain instability, disproportionately affecting vulnerable economies. UNCTAD recommends stronger international cooperation, early warning systems, support for regional trade, and sustainable infrastructure investments to enhance resilience and combat rising carbon emissions in the maritime sector.

Chokepoints are essential to global trade, acting as crucial intersections where maritime traffic converges. Among the most notable chokepoints are the Suez Canal and the Panama Canal, which facilitate a significant share of the world’s maritime commerce. These canals not only improve shipping efficiency by considerably shortening travel distances but also serve as critical components in the complex network of the global supply chain.

Recent disruptions highlighted in the Review of Maritime Transport 2024 reveal the vulnerabilities encountered by least developed countries (LDCs) and small island nations. These countries frequently suffer the most from disruptions stemming from various issues, including geopolitical conflicts, environmental challenges, and operational inefficiencies. Consequently, they face increased exposure to supply chain vulnerabilities, resulting in considerable economic consequences.

Furthermore, the growing distances that vessels are required to travel due to these disruptions are intensifying existing challenges. Rising fuel and labour costs, coupled with prolonged shipping durations, introduce additional layers of complexity and expense to global shipping operations. This scenario poses a particularly grave threat to vulnerable economies, which find it difficult to absorb such rising costs and are often disadvantaged in the global market. The relationship between chokepoints, supply chain disruptions, and their effects on the poorest nations underscores the pressing need for strategies aimed at enhancing resilience and mitigating risks in global trade.

Suez Canal disruption and its widespread impact

The closure and disruption of the Suez Canal have reverberated through global trade networks, forcing vessels to reroute around the Cape of Good Hope at the southern tip of Africa. This detour, while necessary to maintain delivery schedules, demands extensive resources and disrupts shipping timelines. The economic costs of these extended routes are particularly pronounced on key shipping lanes, such as those between the Far East and Europe, where the rerouting significantly increases both travel distance and operational expenses.

One of the most impactful cost drivers is the rise in CO? emissions from these extended journeys. Under the EU Emissions Trading System, each rerouted trip incurs approximately $400,000 in additional costs due to elevated carbon emissions, a burden that escalates overall expenses for shipping companies. These costs inevitably ripple down to consumers, exacerbating price instability and inflation, especially in regions heavily dependent on imports.

Adding to the complexity, geopolitical uncertainties loom over the Suez Canal, with prolonged disruptions anticipated until at least 2025 or early 2026. This protracted timeline injects further unpredictability into global trade flows, compounding the logistical and economic pressures on already stretched supply chains. The extended impact underscores the canal’s importance not only as a strategic trade artery but also as a geopolitical flashpoint, with significant repercussions for global commerce and economic stability.

Panama Canal as a chokepoint: Drought and diversion

The Panama Canal serves as a vital conduit for international trade but has encountered significant operational limitations due to extended drought conditions. The decline in water levels has necessitated strict limitations on vessel draft and transit capacity, compelling numerous shipments to adopt longer and more expensive routes. For instance, vessels that would normally navigate the Panama Canal to reach the U.S. East Coast are now redirected to West Coast ports or entirely rerouted through the Suez Canal, thereby exerting additional pressure on global shipping systems.

The ramifications of these detours are considerable. On average, the affected shipping routes have experienced a 31% increase in sailing distances, resulting in not only extended travel times but also heightened fuel and labour expenses for each voyage. The cumulative costs associated with these longer journeys escalate shipping expenses, which are ultimately transferred along the supply chain, impacting prices and delivery schedules for end consumers.

Regions that rely heavily on these critical trade routes have felt the effects acutely. For example, East African countries like Djibouti and Sudan depend on the Suez Canal for approximately one-third of their international trade. The disruptions in both the Panama and Suez Canals have unsettled vital trade pathways, posing challenges to these economies and obstructing access to essential imports. This situation highlights the necessity for robust supply chain strategies capable of addressing the vulnerabilities introduced by environmental factors and shifting trade dynamics.

Economic consequences: Rising costs and increased emissions

The repercussions of disruptions at critical chokepoints, such as the Suez and Panama Canals, penetrate deeply into the economic structure of international trade, resulting in significant increases in expenses related to fuel, labour, insurance, and chartering. As vessels are compelled to take longer routes, fuel consumption rises sharply, and labour costs escalate due to prolonged travel times. Furthermore, the necessity for rerouting has resulted in elevated insurance premiums, as these extended and more intricate paths expose cargo to greater risks. Concurrently, the heightened demand for shipping capacity has driven up chartering costs, with freight rates reflecting this increased financial burden across key trade routes.

Freight rates have experienced a remarkable surge, as illustrated by the current average rates of the Drewry World Container Index (WCI), which now stands at $4,058 per FEU, a significant rise from the 10-year average of $2,833 per FEU. Certain routes have witnessed even more pronounced increases. Between January and July 2024, the Shanghai Freight Index reported exceptionally high costs: Latin American routes averaged $9,026 per TEU, while rates to South Africa and West Africa reached $5,426 and $5,563 per TEU, respectively. These rising costs ultimately trickle down to consumers, affecting economies on a global scale.

Small island nations and developing states in particular have been adversely affected by these escalating costs and changing logistics. Over the last decade, maritime connectivity for these vulnerable economies has diminished by 9%, highlighting the increasing challenges they encounter as trade connections weaken. This decline disrupts vital imports and exports, exacerbates inflationary pressures, and diminishes trade competitiveness for these nations, which are already susceptible to economic volatility. As these disruptions persist, the compounded economic challenges posed by rising emissions costs and soaring freight rates create a significant obstacle to the stability of these regions, necessitating immediate action to bolster the resilience of global supply chains.

Recommendations from the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) for resilient trade routes

The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) has outlined a series of recommendations aimed at fortifying global trade routes against the mounting risks posed by geopolitical tensions and climate-induced disruptions. These proposals emphasise the need for a more resilient, cooperative, and transparent approach to maritime logistics.

International collaboration

UNCTAD emphasises the vital role of international collaboration in stabilising trade routes. To address the challenges posed by geopolitical tensions and climate-related risks, the organisation advocates for a unified strategy among nations and industry participants. Through collective efforts, countries can formulate contingency plans, pool resources, and adopt proactive strategies that diminish the occurrence and effects of chokepoint disruptions, thereby promoting a more secure global trading landscape.

Proactive monitoring and early detection systems

To enhance the detection of chokepoint challenges and facilitate more effective rerouting, UNCTAD suggests the implementation of sophisticated early detection systems and improved monitoring capabilities. These systems would empower shipping networks to swiftly identify and address emerging threats along critical trade routes, thereby reducing delays and associated expenses. By enhancing visibility and offering real-time information on potential obstructions or environmental hazards, these systems contribute to the uninterrupted flow of goods and lessen the dependence on reactive solutions.

Support for regional trade

To reduce dependency on vulnerable international routes, UNCTAD advocates for bolstering regional trade networks. Intraregional trade, which saw a decline of 3% last year compared to a 2% increase in intercontinental trade, could offer a valuable alternative by enabling countries to trade more locally and minimise reliance on chokepoints like the Suez and Panama Canals. Strengthening regional trade frameworks can also enhance economic resilience for developing nations and small island states, which are often disproportionately affected by global supply chain disruptions.

Combating fraudulent ship registrations

Fraudulent ship registrations pose risks to the reliability and security of global trade routes. To address this issue, UNCTAD suggests implementing stronger verification processes, expanding information-sharing frameworks, and establishing a robust legal foundation to monitor and validate ship registration practices. By enhancing transparency and accountability in vessel registration, these measures help deter illegal practices and support a more trustworthy and resilient maritime sector.

UNCTAD’s recommendations provide a comprehensive roadmap for enhancing the resilience of global trade networks, advocating for proactive measures and regional cooperation that prioritise stability and sustainability in the face of escalating global challenges.

Decarbonisation and sustainable infrastructure needs

UNCTAD's analysis underscores the pressing necessity for low-carbon infrastructure to mitigate climate-related vulnerabilities that disproportionately impact critical maritime chokepoints such as the Suez and Panama Canals.?

The escalating effects of climate change on these vital passages—including droughts, rising sea levels, and extreme weather phenomena—highlight the urgent requirement for decarbonisation initiatives and the development of more sustainable infrastructure within the global shipping sector. By reducing emissions and investing in green technologies at these chokepoints, the resilience and efficiency of trade routes could be significantly enhanced.

Nevertheless, the current rate of fleet renewal presents a significant obstacle to this transition. In 2023, the global fleet saw a growth of 3.4%, yet only 14% of the newly added tonnage was equipped for alternative fuels, a statistic that UNCTAD characterises as "below historical averages." This sluggish pace of adoption hinders the shipping industry's movement towards sustainable practices and continues its dependence on high-carbon fuels, thereby amplifying environmental risks.

The long-term consequences of failing to decarbonise the maritime sector are considerable. A lack of transition to lower-carbon operations could result in heightened operating expenses as fuel prices and regulatory compliance costs escalate. Furthermore, companies that do not embrace sustainable practices may face fines and other penalties as global environmental regulations become more stringent.?

Most critically, the industry risks diminishing its market competitiveness, as both consumers and policymakers increasingly support companies that are dedicated to reducing their carbon emissions. UNCTAD's focus on sustainable infrastructure and fleet decarbonisation emphasises the urgent need for the shipping industry to innovate and adapt in order to succeed in a low-carbon future.

Get in touch with a procurement consultant?

Looking to connect with a procurement consultant? Strategic procurement management consulting provides the tools and insights to navigate these challenges head-on. Our expertise in proactive risk management, sustainable sourcing, and supplier diversification empowers organisations to mitigate vulnerabilities in their supply chains, reducing dependency on critical chokepoints.?

By strengthening your procurement processes with real-time data insights and comprehensive risk assessments, we help secure stable supplier relationships, manage costs, and maintain business continuity—even in the face of unforeseen disruptions.