Nation's Basic Charter vs Central & State Laws

https://swaminathanv208.blogspot.in/2016/07/deeming-legal-fiction-contd.html

As summed up therein:

"The vital and fundamental  issue involved requiring special focus is the  validity , legality and legitimacy , or otherwise, of the amendments (more than one) made, of the constitution, to pave the way for the governments to impose the subject levies of VAT and Service tax. It might be worthwhile to have a close study and appreciation of the well-considered opinion of the renowned legal legend / the law expert, par excellence - n a palkhivala - as expressed, time and again, in his annual fiscal budget and other public speeches on the propriety or otherwise of such amendments periodically made in the past. The published memorable versions thereof are contained in the special chapters, in the two popular books- WE, THE PEOPLE (PART III) – I * & We, the Nation ( 10. Other Constitutional Issues) -II **; a must read."

  In one’s independent but deep perspective, must be so read, closely and mindfully are the eminent, expert opinion, contained / covered under the following topic heads:    

       I * Out the four topic heads there under, the finest points and the most crucial of all are:

          “Should we alter our Constitution ? (pg. 190 – 194 )

          “ The light of the Constitution “        (pg. 199 – 206)

That, however, is not to be mistaken or misconstrued, impudently,  to even remotely suggest, that those under the other topic heads need not be gone through; but , on the contrary, ought to be , prudently, read/nay studied, so that none of the points of every relevance are over sighted or glossed over.

           II  ** “Misconceptions about Legislative Privilege”