Nation as the New Religion: Where Are Our Temples?

In an increasingly fractured world, where divisions along the lines of religion, ethnicity, and language seem to deepen by the day, the concept of nationalism has taken on a new and profound role. As traditional religious affiliations wane in influence, the nation has emerged as a new kind of religion—one that provides identity, purpose, and collective meaning. But if the nation is the new religion, where are our temples? How do we, as citizens, create and maintain the sacred spaces and rituals that sustain this modern faith?

1????????????? Nation as an Emotional Relationship

Just as religion is not merely a set of beliefs but a deeply emotional relationship with the divine, so too is nationalism an emotional bond with the nation. The idea of the motherland, historically imbued with reverence and devotion, is more than a geographical concept; it is a sociological construct deeply embedded in the collective consciousness of a people. Drawing from Durkheim’s theory of collective consciousness, we see how shared rituals, symbols, and narratives foster a sense of belonging and identity. The nation, like a home, is built over time through these shared experiences and emotions.

However, unlike the enduring and sacred connection fostered by religious devotion, the emotions tied to nationalism can sometimes be as fleeting as the transitory affections seen on social media—a “like” here, a momentary surge of pride there, but often lacking the deep-rooted commitment necessary for sustained national unity. In today’s digital age, where emotions can be commodified and consumed as quickly as they are produced, the challenge lies in cultivating a more profound, enduring sense of national belonging that transcends the ephemeral nature of social media-driven emotions.

2????????????? Historical Sacrifices and Modern Amnesia

One of the most significant challenges to sustaining this emotional connection to the nation is what can be termed "modern amnesia"—the tendency to forget the sacrifices of past generations. In India, the horrors of Partition serve as a grim reminder of the destructive power of religious and cultural divisions. Millions were displaced, and countless lives were lost in one of the most tragic events of the 20th century. This collective trauma is a stark contrast to the often superficial way in which independence and national holidays are treated today, where they are seen more as opportunities for vacation rather than as solemn reminders of the price of freedom.

Sociologist Maurice Halbwachs’ theory of collective memory underscores the importance of maintaining a shared narrative of these historical sacrifices. Institutions like the Holocaust Museum in Washington, D.C., and the Civil Rights Museum in Memphis exemplify how national memory can be preserved and made emotionally resonant. These museums are not just repositories of history; they are temples of national identity, where the sacrifices of the past are made present and tangible to future generations. They serve as powerful reminders of the struggles that have shaped the nation and the ongoing responsibility to uphold the values for which so many have fought.

Similarly, initiatives like the "Har Ghar Tiranga" campaign, which encourages citizens to display the national flag, are attempts to create everyday rituals that reinforce national pride. These acts are psychologically significant because they transform abstract notions of patriotism into concrete, visible symbols of belonging. Drawing from Erving Goffman’s theory of symbolic interactionism, these small, everyday acts can be seen as performances that reinforce the collective identity of the nation. The flag, much like a religious icon, becomes a totem that embodies the shared values and emotions of the community.

3????????????? Nation vs. Religion: The Modern-Day Religion

If we consider the nation as a modern-day religion, then its symbols, rituals, and emotional bonds function in much the same way as those of traditional religions. Nations, like religions, require sacred spaces—temples—where the collective memory and values of the community are enshrined. But while religions have physical temples, the temples of the nation are often found in its institutions, monuments, and national holidays.

The absence of a single messianic figure in nation-building is another parallel between nationalism and religion. While religions often revolve around the teachings and legacies of a divine or prophetic figure, nations must create their heroes—individuals who embody the ideals and struggles of the nation. The celebration of figures like Mahatma Gandhi or Nelson Mandela is akin to the veneration of saints in religious traditions. These individuals become the moral exemplars whose lives and sacrifices are held up as models for the nation.

From a sociological perspective, the rituals and symbols associated with nationalism serve as what Clifford Geertz called "cultural systems"—frameworks of meaning that provide coherence and continuity to the national narrative. These cultural systems are essential for maintaining the emotional bonds that sustain the nation, especially in times of crisis.

4????????????? Public Service Motivation and National Responsibility

The liberal critique of nationalism often overlooks the importance of public service motivation in sustaining national identity. Public service is not merely an obligation; it is a sacred duty that stems from the emotional relationship between the citizen and the nation. Max Weber’s concept of the "Protestant work ethic," which links religious duty with economic productivity, can be adapted to understand the role of public service in nation-building. Just as the work ethic in Weber’s theory is tied to religious beliefs, public service in a nationalist framework is tied to the belief in the nation’s ideals and the desire to contribute to its prosperity.

Citizens who engage in public service, whether through paying taxes, volunteering, or civic engagement, are participating in the rituals of nationhood. These acts are the modern-day equivalent of religious offerings, where the sacrifice of personal resources or time is made in service of the greater good. The concept of civic nationalism, which emphasizes shared values and responsibilities, provides a framework for understanding how public service can be integrated into the everyday practices of citizens. In doing so, it helps to build the "social capital" that is essential for a healthy and unified nation.

5????????????? Unity and Division Within the Nation

India’s experience as a melting pot of diversity highlights both the potential and the challenges of nationalism as a unifying force. The divisions along religious, linguistic, and regional lines that led to the horrors of Partition are a reminder of the destructive power of identity-based conflict. Yet, the concept of the nation as a modern-day religion offers a way to transcend these divisions by providing a shared identity that can unite people across these differences.

Benedict Anderson’s theory of "imagined communities" is particularly relevant here. Nations are not defined by the physical proximity of their members but by the shared narratives, symbols, and rituals that create a sense of collective identity. By nurturing this imagined community, the nation can serve as a bridge between the diverse identities within its borders, creating a sense of unity that is stronger than the forces that seek to divide.

6????????????? Conclusion

The liberal approach to nationalism, which often focuses on its potential for exclusion and division, fails to fully appreciate the emotional, psychological, and sociological dimensions of national identity. In a world divided by religion, ethnicity, and language, nationalism—when understood as a modern-day religion—offers a powerful framework for unity and collective meaning. The nation, like religion, provides sacred spaces and rituals that sustain its emotional bonds, preserve its collective memory, and inspire its citizens to contribute to the common good.

As we navigate the complexities of the modern world, it is essential to recognize the role of nationalism in fostering a sense of belonging and responsibility among citizens. By embracing the nation as the new religion, we can build the temples—whether physical or symbolic—that are necessary to sustain our collective identity and ensure the continued prosperity of our communities.

?