The Myth of Designer Frames: Why You’re Killing Your Margins

It's time to poke the bear again. Independent eyecare professionals (ECPs), let’s have a brutally honest conversation. You’re killing your own margins—and your business—because of one stubborn belief: that patients won’t buy anything unless it has a big designer name slapped on it.

Here’s the hard truth: 68% of patients don’t care about designer brands as much as you think. Sure, a few (32%) will walk in asking for a specific name, but most care about style, quality, and price. What’s really driving your obsession with these brands? Ego? The belief that you need them to "compete"? Let me show you why this mentality is outdated, costly, and holding your practice back.

The Hidden Costs of Designer Brands

Selling designer frames often looks good on the surface, but the numbers tell a different story:

1. Sky-High Wholesale Prices Are Eating Your Profits Designer frames cost you $150-$200 wholesale. Even with a 2.7x markup (which is common), you’re barely covering overhead after insurance reimbursements.
2. Returns Come at a Price The return policies offered by major wholesalers seem appealing, but they come with hidden costs. The price you pay for each frame includes the cost of those generous returns—estimated at 30% or more.
3. Insurers Don’t Care About Designer Labels Insurance pays the same reimbursement whether the frame costs $65 or $200. Every time you choose a higher-cost frame, your profit shrinks.The Luxottica Dilemma

Who’s Really Winning?

Here’s a reality check: Most designer brands aren’t truly independent. They’re licensed and manufactured by a global conglomerate that also happens to be your biggest competitor. Every time you sell one of their frames, you’re boosting the profits of a company that owns major retail chains like LensCrafters and Sunglass Hut—not to mention dominating online platforms like EyeBuyDirect.

These conglomerates aren’t just competitors—they’re data-driven powerhouses. Some of the market insights they use to sharpen their strategies (including commerical real estate) come directly from independent ECPs like you. That data helps them outpace small practices, leaving independents to fight an uphill battle. Are you comfortable fueling the very machine that’s working to edge you out of the market?

The Dirty Little Secret of Designer Frames

Here’s a little-known secret: designer frames aren’t always the highest quality. The high costs of royalties, advertising, sales commissions and point-of-purchase materials force manufacturers to cut corners elsewhere—usually on the actual product. While patients may assume they’re paying for superior craftsmanship, much of what they’re really paying for is the brand name and the marketing behind it. Private-label frames, on the other hand, focus on delivering exceptional quality without the inflated costs of a designer label. Only the label is missing.

Why Designer Brands Are a Trap

Designer brands were originally created to help eyecare professionals address a significant challenge: keeping patients who were tempted to ditch glasses for contact lenses or LASIK surgery. By offering fashionable, recognizable designer frames, these brands gave patients a reason to embrace eyewear as a style statement rather than just a necessity.

However, as the market evolved, these brands shifted their focus. Today, they serve more to enrich wholesalers and big corporations than to support independent practices. Their marketing teams prioritize their bottom line, not your margins, capture rate, or ability to compete with online retailers and chains.

While designer frames can still offer appeal, they often overshadow your own brand and limit your practice’s potential to build a unique identity. By relying too heavily on these brands, you will miss the opportunity to differentiate your practice and create lasting value for your patients. It’s time to reassess their role and embrace strategies that truly work in your favor.

The Growing Power of Private Label

Private-label products are no longer just a budget-friendly alternative—they’ve become a powerful force in nearly every industry. In the U.S., private-label goods now account for roughly 19% of all consumer goods sales, with that number reaching as high as 22% in sectors like grocery. Globally, regions like Western Europe boast private-label market shares as high as 36%, with some countries exceeding 50%.

This trend underscores a major shift in consumer behavior: people are increasingly prioritizing quality, fit, and price over brand names. For eyecare professionals, this is a golden opportunity. Private-label eyewear offers the ability to provide high-quality frames at a fraction of the cost, delivering better margins and giving practices a unique edge in a crowded marketplace.

As private label continues to grow, it's not just about keeping up—it's about leading the charge. Practices that embrace this trend position themselves not only to compete but to thrive in an industry that’s rapidly changing.

A Better Approach:

This Doesn't Mean Abandoning Designer Frames

Designer frames have their place in your practice. But to build a healthier, more profitable dispensary, you need to look beyond the big names and focus on your own brand.

1. Invest in Private Label Private label frames cost significantly less—typically around $29-$65 or 60-80% less than what you're paying from comparable frames through wholesale. You control the branding, the narrative, and the pricing, which means healthier margins and a stronger identity for your practice. Start small, then gradually increase to about 1/3 of your borad space. Reach out to Your Brand Eyewear to get started.
2. Support Independent Brands Many industry-independent eyewear brands offer stylish, high-quality options that set your practice apart from big-box retailers. While more costly than private-label, patients love finding something unique, and these brands typically come with fewer strings attached. Their quality is often superior to "designer" brands. Look at OVVO, MYKITA, Barton Perierra, ic! berlin, MAD in Italy, Robert Marc, JF Rey, Morel, Tom Davies, Lafont ... and there are others. Ask around.

The Takeaway

Designer brands can’t be the foundation of your dispensary. They’re a tool—but only one piece of a bigger strategy. Practices that thrive today are the ones that diversify their frame boards, invest in private label, and align with independent industry brands that support the independent eyecare community.

Your patients already trust you. Why not give them something that benefits both of you—frames that represent the quality of care you provide while protecting your margins?

The choice is yours: Keep playing by the big brands’ rules—or create a strategy that’s designed to help your practice grow.

#OpticalIndustry

#EyewearBusiness

#VisionCare

#DesignerEyewear

#EyewearTrends

#LuxuryFrames

#IndependentOptometry

#EyewearProfitability

#OptometryBusiness

#PrivateLabelEyewear

#DisruptTheIndustry

#RethinkEyewear

#EyewearRevolution