My Unorthodox Life. Tragic story.
Rabbi Shlomo Ezagui
Author - Lecturer - A Spiritual Soul Book & Maimonides Advice for the 21st Century. Chabad Palm Beach Fl. HQ
Disgusting of the lowest caliber – on ALL levels.
My critic of the new Netflix series, My Unorthodox life. “Everyone” at least in the orthodox world, is talking about it.
It is vulgar (for no reason), promiscuous, terrible parenting, a total sell out of values period, to gain some publicity. It is cheap, and calling it superficial, would be a false compliment.
Miriam, Julia’s daughter, comes home telling her mother she is going out on a blind date with another girl. The mother immediately encourages Miriam to feel comfortable trying out a kiss with this total unknown person on a first date!!! Great Parenting, right?
Has the mom no concern for all the sexually transmitted diseases with a total unknown figure.
Miriam the daughter wants to dress with the “classic Monsey look” when discussing making a visit there, but the Mom doesn’t want her daughter to have respect for the father they are planning to visit, and sensitivities for the community. She encourages Miriam to dress the “I own my body” do what I want manner.
The daughter who has more sense, tries telling that to her mother but Julia insists Miriam should flaunt her independence in the face of the Monsey community. Julia continues telling her gay Ceo Robert, to convince Miriam not to dress “Monsey style”.??
Pretty awful education on the part of a mother to teach her child to not give a hoot of where they are, crash the wedding, dressed in a beach party costume.
Aaron the youngest, a sweet kid, who appears to have a problem looking at his mother’s immodest dress, decided he wants to stay away from television and girls while he is in school. This is a perfect reasonable and mature choice, supported mind you by plenty of “secular “studies as being a wise decision.
Mom does not accept or respect this perfect reasonable disciplined choice and calls it “a tragic choice.” Really??Besides the idiocy of that statement, and any “normal” parent should be proud of their child taking education serious. How about accepting in a respectful manner the choices of your child.
Mom tells the kid his choice is, “brainwashing”, and tells him, that his choice is “fundamentalism”!!
领英推荐
Kudos to Aaron, he is strong all along and responds, “I see the world, I just don’t want to be part of, that world”.?Who could blame Aaron when you just see the varied lifestyles and behaviors of the people on this show itself.?I would say if anyone is a "fundamentalist" in this show, it is Julia, crying in front of her son, and pressuring her poor 14-year-old and anyone she can persuade, to “be part of this (her) world”.
When Bat Sheva recounts how her husband was somewhat surprised at her wearing jeans, which is not how the two of them understood each other when they got married, Julia tell her daughter, “no one gets to tell you what you wear on your body”.
Can she not understand what Bat Sheva tells her, it’s a shock to Ben. And Julia goes on swearing a four letter word at Ben! What type of mother helps fuel a friction between her own daughter and husband? Especially under these understandable circumstances. I know the answer.
Bat Sheva herself who totally changed her lifestyle from what the two talked about before their own marriage and dreamt about during their dates, expresses herself with, “I still respect his feelings, I am frustrated he isn’t where I’m at” and has a problem when he asks for more time and a chance to talk things over with his parents.?
Bat Sheva is single minded focused.?“I want him to understand, I want him to come around” and change his world view, his spiritual sensitivities, drop all that, for a dramatically changed lifestyle and do it, overnight.
Why is there so much pressure being placed on Ben an adult to give up his preferences, his family and his entire life upbringing? What’s nice and kind about that???
On the show Julia says, in that (orthodox) world, girls aren't allowed to drive a car. That's just an outright lie. They talk about, not being “educated” in their orthodox lives. That’s another lie. They did go to school. They were and are educated. They were educated in all the regular "secular" studies and, in addition, they were and are educated in a thousands of years tradition, that has withstood the tornadoes of changing civilizations and failed societies.
There is no intellectual, or honest content, vis a vis living an Orthodox life. None whatsoever. It’s all one sided propaganda, literally propaganda bashing a Jewish orthodox lifestyle, on the basis of lies and innuendo.
The show is about a private woman who gave up a spiritually beautiful rich lifestyle that has made the Jewish people special for thousands of years, and that millions of people feel fulfilled and happy with. She follows a familiar path so many have unfortunately taken and later on regretted, because they were weak living with meaningful rules which was too difficult for her, and in the process taking (coercing) her entire family with her. The superficial and short lived enticements and flashing lights of in truth a very troubled and dark world, got the better of her.
It’s a very tragic story for all the members of this family.?
General ophthalmologist
3 年The haredi life is not for everyone, and there is plenty to criticize and bemoan there. But she is throwing out the baby with the bath water. Why doesn’t she encourage her kids to be modern orthodox? Why is it so important for her to go shopping on shabbes, her kids to have sex with strangers, and marry a non-jew? Why? Why is that so great?!! Sigh. She is so angry, she can’t think straight. If she were poor living in some awful studio, you think for a second anyone would listen to her advice and exhortations about life and religion?! ?As Tevye said- when you’re rich, they think you really know! And that poor kid Miriam is so mixed up, she can’t understand why it’s not appropriate to make out with some girl she hardly knows in front of everyone at her mom’s party, and she is so enamored with money, she is happy to throw away her last name. Sigh. This show is depressing, though at times it’s entertaining.?
Lawyer/consulant
3 年To me this is a sad commentary and ironic. Today there are more Jews identifying as Orthodox than ever before. 38% of Jews identify as Chabad or Orthodox. The numbers reflect not only those that are born into Chabad or Orthodox but those that have sought out a deeper meaning in life. So many people want to know their purpose in life. Many have found the answer with Chabad. A few weeks ago, four of us traveled to Crown Heights for the wedding of Laizer and Bassie Raksin. The wedding was at 770 and it was filled with tradition and yiddishe nachas. In addition to the wedding we went to the Ohel, davened at 770, visited a sofer making tefillin, went to the Rebbe's mikva, and toured 770. This experience was moving and enlightening. Weeks later we can't stop talking about the experience and can't wait till our next trip. And the four of us wished that we would have been born into Chabad or had the opportunity to learn in Yeshiva. So as far as Unorthodox goes it is sad that they can't appreciate the richness of the traditions that Orthodox Judaism has to offer. Many Jews have lost their way , but it is only a matter of time until they realize their roots. Good Shabbos and an easy, meaningful fast.
PSYCHOTHERAPIST/BCBA
3 年I hear you. I’m modern orthodox abd I don’t agree with those shows. It gives us a bad reputation and erodes our morals and values of who we really are and our Faith. It’s a sad situation and can hurt many children, teenagers and adults. I stay away from any shows or radical movies. My patients are my best work. They’re more important than unrealistic soap boxes.
Custom Shopify Websites - CEO @cotique.media | Real Estate Investor | Considering a 3rd business venture
3 年Tragic story indeed