Are my design ideas bad?

Are my design ideas bad?

Dear?Designer,

Today's advice is on a very personal question:

Q: What if people say my idea is bad?

"I don't think that's a good idea," says the project manager, dismissing your work with a wave of her hand.

You suspect she's only saying the idea is bad so that she can hit her project deadlines. But?it's her opinion against yours.

You know you shouldn't take it personally, but you do.

Your body reacts for you as a tear forms in the bottom of your eye.

It's painful when people don't respect your expertise.

Try telling yourself this:

  • Feedback on screens isn't feedback on people.
  • Stakeholders don't determine the goodness of an idea...that is up to the user.
  • Ideas themselves aren't "good" or "bad."?They're bets on human behavior.

When we make bets on human behavior, we're often wrong.

There have been studies that show?most ideas are bad. 72% of new products and services fail. (Kucher 2014)

If most ideas will fail, how do you know which ones will succeed?

It's impossible to predict the future, but it is possible to de-risk an idea.

Today, I want to talk about a culture of experimentation that can help you?avoid personal judgments?of ideas from your team.

It's a way to do?user-centered idea evaluation.

1.) Challenge assumptions, not ideas.

An assumption is?something that you accept as true without question or proof.?(Cambridge Dictionary)

No alt text provided for this image

Instead of arguing about which idea to build, find assumptions hidden within the idea. It's the assumptions that will kill an idea so find them.

Try these questions on stakeholders:

Q:?Are we making assumptions that could cause this idea to fail?

Q:?What's the riskiest assumption here? How sure are we that this assumption is true? 10%? 90%?

Q:?What would it take to test this assumption?

Questions like this help us see the risk in our ideas. It helps avoid a binary "right" or "wrong" mentality.

It's?less combative to talk about assumptions?rather than ideas.

If you take it personally when your ideas get shot down, the CEO does, too. Listen for the difference between these two examples.

Example without assumptions: "Hey CEO, can we test your idea to see if it's good or not?"

Example with assumptions: "Hey CEO, can we run some tests on the riskiest assumptions in your idea?"

Hear the difference?

No alt text provided for this image

2.) Seek evidence for risky assumptions

Assumption Maps are a great place to think about the priority and evidence of assumptions.

If we have an important idea without much evidence, it’s good to find evidence before you build anything.

No alt text provided for this image

You might realize you have pretty weak evidence on most of your ideas.

That's where a product experiment like a concept test or a hypothesis-driven design prototype could help.

People sometimes call this approach “data-driven,” “lean,” or “experimental,” but those words don’t do the concept justice.

It's a way to reduce bias and judge ideas objectively with user-centered evaluations.

Don't worry, you don't need to be a data scientist to design based on user data. You're probably generating data already, and every prototype can become an experiment.

If it’s early in the product design process, an experiment might look like an interview, a card sort, or a survey.

Once you know?how to set up a proper experiment, you can?stop relying on subjective feelings?and?let customer behaviors decide.

"We must design for the way people behave, not for how we would wish them to behave.” -Don Norman

3.) Process every idea

I've noticed that when ideas come from the intern or the junior, they're assumed to be bad and shot down immediately.

But if they come from a CEO or a VP, we grumble and build them anyway.

That's a problem.

It's a problem because?users don't care who has the idea. They only want it to work for their lives.

A process is how you save good ideas and ensure you're not biased.

In my career, I've designed dozens of features that were a "good idea" for the company, but the customer didn't find them desirable.

We were so clueless that we didn't even know they were unwanted features until we checked the analytics months after launch. Checking the analytics is a pretty slow, blunt way to check if users like an idea.

You need a process for testing ideas as they come. And instinct or salary is not a good test.

Here's what a process could look like:

  1. Pull out assumptions on the idea
  2. Prioritize the assumptions
  3. Research & experiment on assumptions with weak evidence
  4. Glean insights from the research
  5. Integrate your learnings into the idea
  6. Design the MVP (ideally, this is also an experiment)
  7. Keep iterating and de-risking

A process like this flattens the org and encourages learning from the customer.

And I think that can be a pretty good thing for you.

If ideas evolve from research and experiments, they become something more than "your idea."

They become user-centered ideas.


Learn More

Read this guide on testing assumptions→

Watch this masterclass on assumption testing→

Take a free course on product experiments→


Until next week!

P.S.?We just announced the next LIVE masterclass:?How to Lead with Facilitation. Here's the poster:

How to Lead with Facilitation, a free masterclass by Hannah Baker


This is your Linkedin edition of?Beyond Aesthetics, a free newsletter for UX and Product Designers from the?Fountain Institute.

For more design education, follow us on?Linkedin,?Instagram, or?YouTube

Jon Simmons

Marketing for Independent and Family-Owned Restaurants

2 年

I appreciate the focus on assumptions - this helps build a shared language for evaluating ideas. You're right that "This is a bad idea" is equivalent to "I don't like this idea" - there's very little information there to help someone process why this idea might or might not work. I like building an assumption map as a way of 1) calling out assumptions and 2) categorizing them based on their likely impact and supporting evidence - thanks for sharing Jeff Humble!

Chris Apollo Lynn

Global Marketing & Content Strategist | Creative Problem Solver | Mindful Communicator | Electronic Musician

2 年

Nice one! ????

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jeff Humble的更多文章

  • How to Shift from Reactive Design to Strategic Design

    How to Shift from Reactive Design to Strategic Design

    Some people spend their whole careers reacting to other people's moves. I remember being in this position as a design…

    1 条评论
  • Chasing Competitors Instead of User Needs

    Chasing Competitors Instead of User Needs

    Have you ever had a CEO overly obsessed with beating the competition? I know I have. Usually, this obsession comes at…

    2 条评论
  • Designing an AI-Powered Automation System with Activepieces & Discord

    Designing an AI-Powered Automation System with Activepieces & Discord

    If you’ve ever used Zapier, Slack, or an AI agent to manage work, this article is for you. I hacked this automation…

    4 条评论
  • 28 Testing Methods That Are Not A/B Testing

    28 Testing Methods That Are Not A/B Testing

    Dear Product Person, Today I'm thankful for all the ways you can test that are not A/B tests. Executives and product…

  • Spirit of Halloween Costume Meme Special ??

    Spirit of Halloween Costume Meme Special ??

    Dear Designer, This year, I went a little crazy with the Halloween memes. So today, it's all about ridiculous designer…

    18 条评论
  • The Secret Killer of Strategic Projects

    The Secret Killer of Strategic Projects

    Strategic projects can fall into a million difficulties, but one thing takes down more projects than any other, and the…

  • 5 Ways to Do Strategy Research

    5 Ways to Do Strategy Research

    You may have done some user research and thought, what does the next level of research project look like? Well…

  • The 4 Signs of a Good Strategy

    The 4 Signs of a Good Strategy

    I teach a strategy course for designers, and one of my jobs is giving feedback on strategies. And it is NOT easy.

  • The Big Lesson Behind Figma AI

    The Big Lesson Behind Figma AI

    Designers are on the frontlines of something every software worker will soon be going through. It’s a question you…

    7 条评论
  • Why Designers Should Align to the Business Strategy

    Why Designers Should Align to the Business Strategy

    by Jeff Humble Dear Designer, Lots of designers never "get" their company's business strategy. And to the executives…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了