Modular is Boring and Doesn’t Work!
https://modularhomesource.com/modular-construction-cant-fix-the-affordable-housing-crisis/

Modular is Boring and Doesn’t Work!

I get it. You’ve seen modular companies burn through mountains of VC cash, overpromise, and then fall flat on their face. It’s easy to point fingers and say, “Modular doesn’t work.” But hold up—is it really modular’s fault? Not likely. It’s more a case of ignorance and arrogance, from folks who think they can disrupt construction without actually understanding how buildings come together. They raise huge amounts of money and then try to figure it all out on someone else’s dime, not actually solving any real problems or offering better outcomes. Spoiler alert: that’s not how you revolutionize an industry.

Let’s cut to the chase—modular construction isn’t boring, and anyone who thinks so has missed the point. Modular is the key to unlocking architectural freedom, design flexibility, and construction efficiency. It’s not some boxy, cookie-cutter solution. Modular is already all around us, and when done right, it transforms how we build. So, let’s set the record straight.

Spoiler Alert: We’re Already Building Modular

Here’s the big surprise—you’re already building modular, well somewhat. But you probably don’t call it that. Think about it: 2x4 studs, bricks, cabinets, doors, windows, and a hundred other standardized parts that fit together “seamlessly” on-site. (I laugh at the seamlessly and this highlights where the inefficiency lays) nonetheless, we don’t question it—it’s just how we build. The framework is already modular (even if it’s inefficient); it’s just hiding behind the term “traditional construction.” So, if we’re already using modular components, why not take it to the next level?

Time to Rethink the Brick... Sorta

Let’s talk bricks for a second. Bricks were designed for a reason: they’re small enough for a person to handle, and efficient enough to build with. Back in the day, it made sense. But today? Not so much.

We’re in a whole new era of construction. And no, I’m not talking about robots laying bricks faster. We can go bigger—much bigger. Why lay 10,000 bricks by hand when you can crane in an entire wall assembly or room module? Modular is about thinking bigger. We’re no longer confined to human-scale pieces when we can install larger, pre-assembled components faster, more efficiently, and with greater precision.

Modular is More Than Boxy Buildings

When most people hear “modular,” they think of shipping container like LEGO blocks that are stacked one on top of another. Sure, volumetric modular—those boxy units—is one way to do it. But it’s not the only way. Modular is a whole framework that can be broken down into different layers:

  • Systems – Think steel structures, precast concrete, mass timber… or better yet, hybrid systems that combine them.
  • Multi-Trade Assemblies (MTAs) – Entire wall sections with electrical, plumbing, and finishes pre-installed. Or volumetric solutions like bath pods and those “boxy” units we mentioned earlier.
  • Single-Trade Assemblies (STAs) – Smaller, trade-specific assemblies like modular electrical looms or light-gauge steel frames trusses etc.
  • Materials and Components – The individual pieces that make up the larger assemblies and everything else.


How it all comes together (credit Imago)

?

Here’s the beauty of modular—it’s not a rigid, one-size-fits-all approach. It’s a customizable system. We can mix and match these layers to create tailored, site-specific solutions. And when it’s done by people who actually understand how to design and build with modular in mind, the flexibility is unmatched.

The Real Deal: Precision in Design and Execution

Here’s the thing about modular construction—it’s all about precision. From design to execution, modular construction doesn’t leave room for “let’s figure it out on-site.” It’s about designing to exacting standards, and ensuring every piece fits perfectly when it hits the site.

This isn’t just about drawing pretty lines on paper or fitting a square peg into a round hole. You need to understand the real-world constraints—the suppliers, the logistics, the sequencing of assembly, and even the weather on installation day. Everything needs to be thought through ahead of time. It takes effort, planning, and knowledge, but when done right, the payoff is huge. You get fewer surprises, faster construction, and a whole lot less chaos on-site.

Skilled Labor is in Short Supply—Modular is the Answer

Let’s get real: we don’t have enough skilled labor to keep doing things the way we’ve always done them. The old “figure it out on-site” method isn’t just inefficient—it’s becoming impossible. Heck, most of the time we can’t even get the trades to show up on-site. We’re stretched too thin, and inefficiency is a luxury we can’t afford.

That’s why modular is more important than ever. We need to maximize the skilled labor we do have, which means designing smarter and pre-assembling as much as possible. That way, teams can spend their time on the important stuff, not fixing mistakes or solving problems that could’ve been avoided. The more we build off-site, in controlled environments, the better. It’s about creating scalable, repeatable kits of parts that can be delivered and assembled on-site without sacrificing quality or creativity.

Modular is the Future—Get On Board

Still think modular is boring and won’t work? You’re stuck in the past. Modular isn’t a compromise—it’s a solution. It’s the key to building better, faster, and smarter. This isn’t about cranking out boring, repetitive buildings. It’s about creating a system that works for you—that lets you build (or should I say assemble) with precision, efficiency, and freedom.

Modular lets us push the boundaries of what’s possible in construction. It’s how we rethink the entire process, from design to execution, and solve problems before they even arise. This isn’t the future—it’s already happening. The sooner we get on board, the sooner we unlock the full potential of modular.

So, is modular boring? Hell no. It’s time to start a real conversation about how modular can transform construction from the ground up—because if we’re not doing that, we’re missing out.

Follow us Imago to see how we’re tackling this as designers, builders, and developers.

?

Cesar Ocampo

Creative Entrepreneur | Award Winning Storyteller?? Empowering brands in the commercial construction & Engineering sectors attracts premium talent & projects by visualising their capabilities.

2 个月

Love your take, Joel! Modular construction does have huge potential when approached the right way. What do you think is the key to successfully implementing it in today’s market?

回复

Great insights, Joel—thanks for sparking this discussion! At Radius Track, we specialize in creating solutions that bring unique designs to life, and panelized assemblies are a big part of that. While some might differentiate between modular and panelized approaches, we see both as opportunities to innovate. In addition, by using kitted parts and sub-assemblies that can be locally assembled, we eliminate logistical hurdles and allow builders to focus on executing the design intent with even fewer limitations—creativity included. (The best example of this is our dome structures that are hoisted into place once built on the ground locally.) For us, it’s about enabling the extraordinary not limiting it. We have literally hundreds of examples. Whether this residence project shown, which was a completely panelized framing solution or something as large as Logan Terminal E - we have literally thousands of examples where pre-built panels and kits for local construction is the next best approach to modular building with few limits.

  • 该图片无替代文字
回复
Jason Bos

Modular & Traditional Construction Professional

4 个月

Joel, I’m tired of being a fanboy, but I’m NOT tired of you being right! Why is it that every other industry can burn cash, have companies come and go, and generally be allowed to evolve, while Offsite gets all the haters? It’s because very few people trying to “disrupt” construction at the micro or macro levels understand the intricacies of the industry. For the newcomers, this means standardization at the system level to achieve economies of scale. It means thoughtful deployment of automation. It means implementing software systems that enable data-driven operations. Spoiler alert: all of this requires time, money, and people willing to take risks. Everyone else needs to buckle up and stay seated; it’s going to be a bumpy ride.

Stuart Waters

B.App.Sc(Const.Mgt)(Hons)

4 个月

Great post. Nothing less than a paradym shift in the way we approach all stages of the construction life cycle is required to realise a wider, more sophisticated adoption of Of Site Construction. Biggest hurdle I can see is adopting new technologies that facilitate agility and discarding old ways that stifle our professional and sector evolution. Not talking about big changes at all - I think we inhibit our ability to grow because we don’t look small enough. Just off the top of my head: 1. How about using “resources” in construction programs. 2. How about MS Teams in lieu of a phone call and outlook… If you’re feeling a little braver: How about integrating your time, cost, scope into one unified 4d system - yep the tech exists. Check out Synchro 4D, Asta Power Project, Autodesk Construction Cloud, not to mention the raft of Enterprise Management systems flooding the Market since COVID. The technology is there and some of it we already use, we just need to be curious and spend time ‘on’ the business of the built environment rather than playing an industry wide short game. Understand the challenges, embrace the suck and make your professonal, company and industry evolution a corner stone of your daily labours.

Patrick Kelly Donahue

Lignoloc Market Development Specialist North America | Value Proposition Design

4 个月

The future construction key is precision like a Swiss watch.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Joel Hutchines的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了