Model Dogma - The Map is NOT the Territory

Model Dogma - The Map is NOT the Territory

I'm taking an online project management course right now. While it's pretty good, I simultaneously find the standards surprisingly low while some of the test questions range from plain stupid, to very challenging to irrelevant or even wrong. By that I mean, some of the answers are both possible and reasonable options in the REAL world but were marked wrong on the multiple choice tests.

Here's the gist:

Q: As a project manager, how could you assure that a SMART goal was attainable within the set timeline?

A: Ask relevant stakeholders. Was it wrong?

And yet the remaining options were so vague as to be almost irrelevant to the question:-?

All models are wrong, but some are more accurate.

This was the inspiration for this article, and reminiscent of my Nothing is Everything Article.

George Box, a statistician brilliantly said " All models are wrong, but some are useful." and he's right. And the more famous " The map is not the territory " Both make the same point, a model is a pale imitation of reality. Maps and models are very useful and convenient, but once you start forcing reality, and your processes to comply with the simplified analogie of reality, you've probably gone astray.

Back in the real world, if I was managing a project, or working with a client to improve a business process, I'd be an arrogant idiot to think that I knew better than a software engineer how long it will take to program ANYTHING.

Other than looking at historical data of similar tasks, I'd have no way of judging how long the programming would take. Even then, I know about as much about programming as a software engineer is likely to know about the electro-physiology of a neuron. I'm not qualified to judge if that data is equivalent:-? I therefore REJECT, asking a subject matter expert as an incorrect answer in said " test ".

Models and system frameworks are useful generalized GUIDES, but never forget that they're merely convenient reality wannabes. Drive the model until it's wheels fall off by all means, but then hold solutions up to the harsh light of reality, common sense and empirical testing aka science to produce the best possible results.

tim #bgreen??

P.S. How Do You Assure That Your Processes Match REALITY, Rather Than an Inevitably Oversimplified Model of It ?

P.P.S. My Next Article: Track Results Not Data...



要查看或添加评论,请登录

Tim B. Green??的更多文章

  • Don't Assume, Be Happy

    Don't Assume, Be Happy

    How to depersonalize being let down. We're all more sensitive than we admit.

    2 条评论
  • Question ALL "Science" You Learn in the Media

    Question ALL "Science" You Learn in the Media

    Be VERY Skeptical About ALL "Science" You Learn from the Media..

    4 条评论
  • Track Results, Not Data...

    Track Results, Not Data...

    That Leads to Them To be clear, I'm NOT saying don't use data, but I am saying manage what gets measured. I sometimes…

    2 条评论
  • Book Review: Idea to Execution by Ari Meisel & Nick Sonnenberg

    Book Review: Idea to Execution by Ari Meisel & Nick Sonnenberg

    I've gone a bit crazy on book reviews lately, but only for good books that do something well. This book is all about…

  • Why Prevent Defensiveness in Ourselves and Others ?

    Why Prevent Defensiveness in Ourselves and Others ?

    This article was inspired by this TED Talk I recently shared on Green Zone and Red Zone chickens. Red Zone Chickens are…

    3 条评论
  • Match Your Mentor to the Goal

    Match Your Mentor to the Goal

    If you want a mentor or service provider to help you succeed, Match Your Mentor to the Goal If you want to learn how to…

    2 条评论
  • Put Your Money ( or Skills ) Where Your Mouth Is

    Put Your Money ( or Skills ) Where Your Mouth Is

    I normally don't pay for courses or training from other entrepreneurs. It's not because I'm cheap, well maybe a little,…

    2 条评论
  • Book Review: Brain Bugs: By Dean Buonomano

    Book Review: Brain Bugs: By Dean Buonomano

    Brain bugs was an interesting listen for me because it was shockingly close to my entire psychology education from the…

  • " Learning Styles " are a Myth

    " Learning Styles " are a Myth

    Teach from your strengths & learn from the best teachers. While teaching using different modalities is a good thing…

  • Which " SMART " Goals?

    Which " SMART " Goals?

    I stand by my conclusion / opinion that SMART Goals are Stupid IFF by SMART you mean: Specific Measurable Attainable…

    7 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了