The MLB Draft has long been a focal point for aspiring baseball players, with the potential to change lives overnight. But one noticeable shift in recent years is the increased number of college players selected over high school players. For parents and young athletes navigating the recruiting landscape, understanding these trends—and the pros and cons of each path—is crucial to making informed career decisions.
Draft by the Numbers: College vs. High School Players
Historically, MLB teams have selected a balanced mix of high school and college players, each group offering unique advantages. However, the current trend favors college athletes, with the majority of recent picks coming from universities rather than high schools. In 2022, for example, nearly 70% of draftees were from college programs, leaving high school prospects to make up a smaller portion of selections.
Why Are Teams Drafting More College Players?
There are a few key reasons for this shift:
- Player Development: College players come with a more refined skill set due to their years of experience at the college level, often making them more “game-ready” than high school prospects. MLB teams prefer college players because they typically have higher levels of strength, stamina, and mental resilience, making the transition to the rigorous demands of pro baseball smoother.
- Reduced Risk: High school players, though talented, carry more uncertainty. Many are still developing physically and emotionally, which means there is often a greater risk in predicting their potential. College players, having faced higher competition and experienced personal growth, present a more predictable investment for MLB teams.
- Data and Performance Metrics: College players offer a wealth of data due to advanced tracking and analysis in college programs, which allows MLB teams to better evaluate performance. High school stats can be less reliable due to variations in competition, coaching quality, and other factors.
The Benefits of Being Drafted Out of College
- Higher Signing Bonuses: College players tend to command higher signing bonuses due to the reduced risk MLB teams take by selecting them. The financial incentives can make a college career, followed by an MLB draft selection, an attractive path.
- Increased Maturity and Readiness: College athletes are generally more mature and ready for the demands of professional baseball, as they’ve spent years in structured training programs with seasoned coaches.
- Educational Backup: Attending college allows players to pursue an education, giving them a backup plan in case their baseball career doesn’t pan out. Many players feel more confident entering the draft with a degree in hand or nearly completed.
The Challenges and Advantages for High School Draftees
- Quicker Path to the Pros: High school players who are drafted immediately join MLB’s farm system, potentially reaching the majors faster than those who choose the college route.
- Longer Development Timeline: Drafting high school players can be advantageous for MLB teams willing to invest time and resources in developing young talent. They have the flexibility to mold these players within their system from an early age.
- Financial and Maturity Challenges: However, going pro out of high school can be challenging. Many high school players are unprepared for the demands of a professional career, both financially and mentally. The sudden shift to adulthood, combined with the physical demands of minor league baseball, can be a steep learning curve.
Weighing the Options: Choosing the Right Path
For players and families considering the MLB Draft, the decision to pursue college baseball or aim for a high school draft pick should be made carefully. Considerations should include not only talent level and maturity but also personal goals, family support, and the importance of an educational backup.
Key Advice for Aspiring Draftees:
- Consider Development Needs: Players who could benefit from more structured development may be better suited for college. Those with exceptional talent, maturity, and readiness may thrive as high school draftees.
- Weigh the Long-Term Benefits: While immediate entry to the minor leagues may sound appealing, the benefits of a college degree, higher maturity, and greater MLB readiness are undeniable advantages.
- Understand Your Financial Options: Evaluate the signing bonus structures and overall financial incentives. For some, college offers a greater long-term payoff, while others may find that early entry into the draft is more financially beneficial.
The MLB Draft represents more than just an opportunity; it’s a major decision that impacts a young athlete’s future. While the allure of turning pro immediately after high school is appealing, the current trend shows that college players are gaining favor in the draft. For parents and players navigating this landscape, understanding these dynamics and making thoughtful choices is key to maximizing both athletic potential and career longevity.
If you’d like more guidance on navigating the college vs. high school draft decisions or recruiting insights, reach out to learn how we can help you make the best choices for your baseball journey.
Co-Host with former Chicago Cubs General Manager and MLB player, Ed Lynch's Surfing Baseball Show | Mental Health Advocate/Volunteer for #SameHere Global 501(c)(3)
2 周I was reading an article last night about how Mark Prior turned down a 1.5 million dollar signing bonus by the Yankees to go to college. One of his biggest reasons was exactly what you mentioned, the maturation process. It worked out well for him financially as he signed with the Cubs for 4.5 million 3 years later. Just one of many instances. One of the selling points scouts will tell high schoolers sometimes is "we will pay for your college when you're done". I know of one instance where someone I know was promised this to sign after their junior year of college and when he eventually went back to school after retiring from the Minor Leagues, the team only paid for 15 credit hours when he needed 18 to graduate.