Mixing Challenges in Industrial Crystallization

One of the key operational challenges in industrial crystallization is mixing and agitation. Crystallization is a critical process in many industries, from pharmaceuticals to chemicals, food processing, and materials manufacturing. Achieving the desired crystal size and quality can be a complex task, and proper agitation plays a pivotal role in this.

?

Understanding the Role of Agitation in Crystallization

Agitation, or mixing, during crystallization is essential for several reasons. It helps in:

• Ensuring uniform supersaturation: throughout the solution, which promotes even nucleation and growth.
• Controlling particle size distribution: by balancing nucleation and crystal growth rates.
• Enhancing heat and mass transfer, which impacts the efficiency of the process.
• Preventing sedimentation of crystals, ensuring proper suspension and reducing potential clogging.

However, improper agitation can lead to a variety of operational issues and affect the final crystal product’s quality and yield.

The Key Challenges of Agitation in Industrial Crystallization

1. Balancing Shear Forces

One of the most critical aspects of agitation is finding the right balance of shear forces. While agitation helps to keep the solution well-mixed, excessive shear can break crystals, leading to:

• Fines formation: Too much shear can lead to the formation of fine particles, which reduce the overall quality of the final product.
• Reduced crystal growth: Breakage of growing crystals disrupts the desired crystal morphology.
• Difficulty in filtration: Fine particles are harder to separate from the liquid, increasing downstream filtration challenges.

2. Scale-Up Issues

Moving from lab-scale crystallization to industrial-scale operations presents unique challenges:

• Non-uniform mixing: As reactor sizes increase, it becomes difficult to ensure that agitation provides uniform mixing across the entire vessel. Inadequate mixing can lead to uneven supersaturation and inconsistent crystal formation. This may also end up in wall scaling which starts in so called “dead zones” of the crystallizer.
• Energy consumption: Large-scale mixing often requires significant energy input. Optimizing agitation efficiency to avoid excessive energy costs is critical, particularly in processes where energy consumption already represents a significant operating expense.

?

3. Controlling Nucleation

Proper agitation influences nucleation, the process by which crystals first form. Insufficient agitation can lead to:

• Uncontrolled nucleation: This may result in a wide distribution of particle sizes, making it difficult to achieve the desired product specifications.
• Agglomeration: Poor mixing can cause crystals to stick together, forming agglomerates that alter the expected particle size distribution and lead to product inconsistency.

?

4. Crystallizer Geometry and Agitator Design

The design of the crystallization vessel and the type of agitator used are crucial factors in determining agitation effectiveness:

• Vessel shape: Different geometries may lead to zones of dead space, where mixing is poor. This can result in localized supersaturation levels, influencing uneven crystal growth.
• Impeller types and speeds: The choice of impellers or agitator types, as well as the speed at which they operate, plays a critical role in influencing the flow patterns inside the crystallizer. Poor design or operation can lead to inadequate or excessive shear.

5. Heat Transfer and Crystallization Kinetics

Crystallization is often temperature-dependent, meaning that heat transfer during the process is crucial. Agitation aids in:

• Improving heat transfer: Agitation ensures proper contact between the solution and the cooling surfaces, preventing hot spots or uneven cooling.
• Controlling crystal size: In temperature-dependent crystallization, the cooling rate can affect the rate of supersaturation and, consequently, nucleation and growth rates. Insufficient agitation may result in uneven temperature distribution, impacting crystal size and morphology.

Solutions to Address Agitation Challenges

• Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): CFD simulations can help model fluid flow patterns in large crystallizers to optimize agitation settings and predict the effects of various agitation designs and conditions.
• Variable-Speed Agitation: Using variable-speed agitators allows operators to adjust agitation speeds during different stages of crystallization. This can help balance nucleation, crystal growth, and shear forces.
• Crystallizer Design Optimization: Collaborating with EKATO can help to choose the right agitator type and mixing strategy – which can significantly enhance process performance. Customizing the setup for specific crystallization processes is key to overcoming agitation challenges.

Conclusion

Effective agitation is critical to the success of industrial crystallization processes, but it comes with its own set of challenges. Balancing shear forces, optimizing scale-up processes, and controlling nucleation are just some of the issues that can arise. However, by using modern techniques such as CFD and variable-speed agitation, and paying careful attention to crystallizer design, it is possible to mitigate these challenges and improve process efficiency, crystal quality, and yield.

EKATO has more than 90 years of experience in agitation and provided a lot of solutions when it comes to the design of large crystallizers. Do not hesitate to get in touch with our experts to discuss your specific process challenges.

?

You want to get further insights and discuss in detail about this topic?

Join now our free “Modern mixing solutions for crystallization” webinar on October 17, 2024!

Register now:

9.00-9.45 AM (CEST)

3.00-3.45 PM (CEST)

More information regarding our webinar, can be found on our website !

Stay tuned for more updates and industry insights!