Misleading SEO Metrics: What SEO Providers Often Use and What to Track Instead

SEO reporting can sometimes feel like navigating a sea of numbers, especially when certain metrics are presented as indicators of success but don’t actually translate into real business impact. While reputable SEO providers focus on delivering meaningful results, some agencies may rely on vague or inflated metrics to create a favorable impression of their work.

In this article, we’ll dive into common SEO metrics that can be misleading, why they’re problematic, and which metrics provide a clearer picture of true SEO success!

?

1. Total Keyword Rankings

Why It’s Misleading:

Total keyword rankings are often touted as a sign of success, as providers show clients how many keywords their site ranks for. While the sheer volume of ranked keywords may look impressive, it doesn’t tell you if those rankings are valuable. Many keywords in the ranking count may be low-traffic, low-value, or irrelevant terms that don’t align with your target audience’s needs or business goals.

?

Better Metric: Ranking for Targeted, High-Intent Keywords

Rather than looking at the total number of keywords, focus on the specific, high-intent keywords that were identified as strategic targets. A successful SEO campaign should be improving rankings for keywords with real business value—those that potential customers are likely to search for at different stages of the buyer journey!

?

2. Overall Website Traffic

Why It’s Misleading:

Overall website traffic is another common metric that may be used to exaggerate the impact of SEO efforts. General traffic growth can come from various sources, including direct visits, social media, email marketing, or paid ads. While a spike in traffic looks promising, it’s not an accurate reflection of SEO performance if the traffic isn’t primarily from organic search.

?

Better Metric: Organic Traffic Growth to Target Pages

To truly gauge the success of an SEO campaign, focus on organic traffic growth and break it down by the specific pages that were optimized as part of the campaign. Growth in organic traffic to these pages shows that SEO efforts are driving search-based visitors and that optimized content is attracting the right audience!

?

3. Impressions in Google Search Console

Why It’s Misleading:

Impressions refer to how often your site appears in search results. SEO providers may use impression growth as evidence of campaign success, claiming that increased impressions indicate greater visibility. However, impressions alone don’t mean much if they don’t lead to clicks or conversions. High impressions for low-intent or irrelevant keywords can be misleading if users aren’t engaging with your content.

?

Better Metric: Click-Through Rate (CTR) for Targeted Keywords

Click-through rate (CTR) reveals how many people are clicking through to your site from search results. By focusing on CTR for targeted keywords, you get a better understanding of how compelling your content appears in search results. Improved CTR on high-value keywords indicates that title tags and meta descriptions are well-optimized, making your content more attractive to users!

?

4. Backlink Quantity

Why It’s Misleading:

Backlinks are an essential SEO ranking factor, but some providers focus on quantity over quality, showcasing the total number of backlinks acquired. However, not all backlinks are valuable. Links from low-authority or irrelevant sites can actually harm your site’s credibility and may even lead to penalties. A high volume of backlinks from questionable sources might inflate numbers without boosting your SEO.

?

Better Metric: Quality and Relevance of Backlinks

Instead of looking at backlink quantity, focus on the quality and relevance of backlinks. Links from high-authority sites within your industry are far more valuable than a large number of links from low-quality sources. Quality backlinks from relevant sites indicate that your content is seen as a credible resource, which helps build domain authority and boosts rankings!

?

5. Bounce Rate

Why It’s Misleading:

Bounce rate refers to the percentage of visitors who leave your site after viewing only one page. While a high bounce rate is often seen as negative, it doesn’t always mean users are dissatisfied. Bounce rate can be high for pages where users quickly find the information they need, like a blog post or a contact page. Focusing solely on bounce rate can give a skewed view of user experience.

?

Better Metric: Engagement Metrics (Time on Page and Pages per Session)

Rather than fixating on bounce rate, look at time on page and pages per session. These metrics provide a better sense of user engagement and content effectiveness. If users spend a significant amount of time on a page or click through to other parts of the site, it indicates that they find the content valuable and are interested in exploring more!

?

6. Domain Authority (DA)

Why It’s Misleading:

Domain Authority (DA) is a metric created by Moz to estimate how well a site might rank in search engines, but it’s not an official Google ranking factor. Some SEO providers may use increases in DA as evidence of success, but DA can fluctuate for reasons unrelated to SEO performance. It’s not an accurate indicator of how well a site is meeting its SEO objectives.

?

Better Metric: Growth in Organic Traffic and Keyword Rankings

To assess SEO success, focus on real metrics like organic traffic growth and improvements in targeted keyword rankings. These metrics show how well your site is performing in search results and attracting relevant users, providing a clearer picture of SEO effectiveness than a third-party metric like DA!

?

7. Social Media Metrics in SEO Reports

Why It’s Misleading:

While social media can drive traffic and support brand awareness, it’s not a direct ranking factor for SEO. Some SEO providers may include social media metrics in their reports to boost overall traffic numbers, but this traffic isn’t necessarily a result of SEO efforts.

?

Better Metric: Organic Search Traffic Alone

In SEO reports, isolate organic search traffic from other sources to get a true measure of SEO performance. By focusing on traffic from search engines, you can more accurately assess the impact of SEO optimizations without influence from social media or other channels!

?

8. Total Pageviews

Why It’s Misleading:

Total pageviews may sound impressive, but they don’t necessarily correlate with business goals. If users are landing on multiple pages but not converting, the increased pageviews might simply indicate that visitors are struggling to find relevant information.

?

Better Metric: Conversion Rate from Organic Traffic

Focus on the conversion rate of visitors from organic traffic. A successful SEO campaign should not only increase pageviews but also guide users toward meaningful actions, like signing up for a newsletter or completing a purchase. By tracking conversions, you can measure whether your SEO efforts are driving real business results!

?

9. Ranking for Low-Value Keywords

Why It’s Misleading:

Ranking for keywords that are easy to target but lack relevance to your business can inflate performance metrics without generating value. Low-value keywords typically have low search volume or don’t align with buyer intent, so ranking for them won’t attract the right audience or drive conversions.

?

Better Metric: Rankings for High-Intent, Business-Relevant Keywords

Prioritize high-intent keywords that are directly relevant to your business. These are keywords that indicate users are more likely to convert, such as those including phrases like “buy,” “services,” or “best.” Ranking for high-value keywords aligns SEO performance with business goals and ensures traffic quality!

?

10. Non-Specific “Visibility” Metrics

Why It’s Misleading:

Some SEO providers may use visibility metrics like “impressions” or “overall visibility score” without explaining what they actually mean. These metrics can be broad and vague, providing little actionable insight into real SEO performance or business impact.

?

Better Metric: Click-Through Rate and Impressions for Specific Keywords

A more focused visibility metric is CTR for targeted keywords. Higher CTR on keywords with high intent indicates that the SEO campaign is driving meaningful engagement. Combine this with impressions for specific keywords to understand how often your content is shown to users likely to click through!

?

Focus on Metrics That Drive Real SEO Success

A successful SEO campaign should be measured by metrics that directly align with business goals, such as traffic quality, keyword performance, and conversion rates. By focusing on high-intent keywords, organic traffic to optimized pages, and meaningful engagement, you can evaluate SEO efforts based on their true impact.

When reviewing SEO reports, be cautious of metrics that seem inflated or disconnected from business objectives. By holding your SEO provider accountable to metrics that matter, you’ll gain a clearer view of campaign success and ensure that SEO efforts are truly contributing to your growth!