Mindset Thinking in Executive Coaching – A Critical Appraisal

The concept of mindset thinking, popularized by psychologist Carol Dweck in her research on fixed vs. growth mindsets, has gained significant traction in education, corporate leadership, and personal development. The fundamental idea—that individuals with a growth mindset (believing abilities can be developed) outperform those with a fixed mindset (believing abilities are static)—has been widely embraced as a tool for fostering resilience, motivation, and high performance.

As an executive coach working with CEOs, I have realized that mindset thinking is often positioned as a leadership superpower. The idea that a growth mindset, abundance mindset, or resilience mindset can unlock transformational leadership is compelling. And to an extent, it’s true—how an senior executive thinks directly shapes how they lead.

But let’s be clear: mindset alone doesn’t run a company. Senior executives do not just need to think differently; they need to make the right decisions, influence key stakeholders, manage systemic complexity, and deliver results.

Despite its intuitive appeal, mindset theory has been oversimplified, misapplied, and subjected to scrutiny regarding its scientific robustness. While its influence on leadership, learning, and workplace culture is undeniable, its limitations must be critically examined to avoid over generalization and misinterpretation.

Mindset thinking has its place in executive coaching, but it can also be dangerously simplistic if not balanced with the hard realities of corporate leadership. Let’s take a closer look at how mindset theory applies—and where it falls short—when coaching a CEO.

Where Mindset Thinking Adds Value for CEOs

1. Helps CEOs Break Through Self-Imposed Limitations

At the top of an organization, CEOs are expected to be visionaries, strategists, and decision-makers. Yet even the most seasoned leaders can have blind spots or self-limiting beliefs. A CEO who believes they “aren’t a great communicator” may avoid engaging employees directly. One who sees themselves as “a numbers person, not a culture builder” may fail to drive the people side of the business.

Mindset work helps CEOs recognize these internal barriers and push past them. A simple but powerful coaching question—“What if that assumption isn’t true?”—can unlock new leadership potential.

2. Strengthens an Executive's Ability to Navigate Complexity

CEOs deal with relentless uncertainty—geopolitical shifts, economic volatility, technological disruption, activist investors. Leaders with a fixed or scarcity mindset often struggle in these conditions, becoming reactive, risk-averse, or overly defensive.

A learning mindset helps a CEO stay adaptive, recognizing that they don’t need to have all the answers but must create the right conditions for learning and rapid decision-making. Instead of thinking “This is a threat,” they begin to ask “What opportunity does this disruption create?”

3. Shapes the Organizational Culture from the Top

A CEO’s mindset cascades down into the company culture. If a CEO sees failure as unacceptable, the organization will become risk-averse. If they believe innovation is too risky, teams will stop experimenting. Conversely, if they model a growth mindset—acknowledging mistakes, adapting to change, and encouraging learning—they create a culture where people feel empowered to take intelligent risks.

As a coach, helping a CEO shift their mindset isn’t just about their personal growth—it’s about the kind of organization they are building.

Where Mindset Thinking Falls Short for a CEO

1. Mindset Alone Doesn’t Drive Business Performance

The most glaring limitation of mindset theory is that it assumes thinking differently leads to leading differently. But in the world of large-cap leadership, mindset without execution is meaningless.

A CEO can have the most progressive, abundance-oriented, growth-focused mindset in the world—but if they lack a clear strategy, don’t hold their executive team accountable, or fail to execute on market shifts, they will still fail.

As an executive coach, this means grounding mindset work in operational reality. If a CEO is struggling with shareholder pressure, regulatory hurdles, or market shifts, they don’t just need a new perspective—they need a plan. Instead of asking, “How can you think differently?” the better question might be:

?? “How does your thinking translate into measurable leadership actions?”

2. Can Lead to Dangerous Overconfidence or Magical Thinking

There’s a fine line between having a strong mindset and being dangerously overconfident. A CEO who embraces “I believe we will succeed” thinking without critically assessing risks can make reckless strategic moves.

History is full of CEOs who bought into their own mindset hype—ignoring dissenting voices, betting big on failing strategies, or dismissing market realities. Theranos’ Elizabeth Holmes, WeWork’s Adam Neumann, and Uber’s Travis Kalanick all embodied this problem—leaders who believed their own narratives so strongly that they disregarded operational and ethical realities.

As a coach, part of the job is ensuring that a CEO’s mindset is grounded in rigorous decision-making, constructive challenge, and real data. Instead of reinforcing blind optimism, ask:

?? “Where might your confidence be outpacing reality?”

?? “What key risks are you underestimating?”

?? “Who on your team is giving you unfiltered truth?”

3. Ignores Systemic and Structural Realities

Mindset theory often assumes that success is simply a matter of perspective. But large-cap CEOs operate within highly complex systems—regulatory constraints, shareholder expectations, board dynamics, and geopolitical forces all shape what’s possible.

A CEO can’t just think their way into an industry transformation if regulatory bodies, competitors, or economic forces are pushing in the opposite direction. A better coaching approach acknowledges these external constraints and asks:

?? “What levers do you actually have control over?”

?? “How can you navigate these systemic barriers strategically?”

?? “Who are your key influencers, and how can you align them?”

This shifts the conversation from mindset to power dynamics, strategic influence, and systemic change management—which are far more critical at the CEO level.

4. Can Be Used to Deflect Real Accountability

Another major flaw of mindset thinking is that it can subtly shift responsibility onto the individual rather than addressing real leadership failures.

If a CEO’s team is underperforming, mindset theory might suggest: “The CEO just needs to think differently about leadership.” But the harder truth might be: “The CEO is tolerating mediocrity and needs to make tough decisions.”

Similarly, if a company is struggling, mindset work might focus on helping the CEO “reframe challenges.” But sometimes, the real issue is that the CEO is making poor strategic choices, failing to engage the board effectively, or not holding their C-suite accountable.

As an executive coach, it’s essential to push beyond mindset work into tangible accountability. Instead of asking, “How can you shift your perspective?” the better question is:

?? “What leadership decisions need to happen now?”

Mindset is a Leadership Tool, Not a Leadership Strategy

Mindset thinking has real value for a CEO of a large-cap firm—it can help them overcome limiting beliefs, navigate complexity, and shape culture. But mindset alone doesn’t drive results. At the CEO level, strategy, execution, influence, and accountability are just as—if not more—important than personal beliefs.

As an executive coach, your job is to balance mindset work with the hard realities of large-scale leadership: ? Encourage a growth mindset, but demand strategic discipline and execution. ? Challenge self-limiting beliefs, but also challenge bad decision-making. ? Promote confidence, but ensure it’s grounded in rigorous analysis, not wishful thinking. ? Help a CEO shift their mindset—but don’t let mindset thinking become a substitute for leadership action.

At the end of the day, great CEOs don’t just think differently. They decide differently, act decisively, and lead with discipline. That’s where real impact happens.

Unlock Your Organization’s Full Potential

Great leadership drives great outcomes. As an executive coach/mentor, I specialize in empowering leaders and teams to navigate challenges, foster innovation, and achieve strategic transformation. Whether you’re looking to enhance leadership excellence, build stronger teams, or lead systemic change, I’m here to help.

Let’s explore how coaching can take your organization to the next level. DM me here on LinkedIn or email me at [email protected] for a free, no-obligation conversation.

#executivecoaching #teamcoaching #teamdevelopment #leadershipcoaching #systemicteamcoaching #teamleadercoaching #leadership #leadershipdevelopment #executivedevelopment #startupleadershipcoaching #startupcoaching #teamcoachingROI

Aarn Wennekers ? 2025