Mind Over Margin: Why Brands Shouldn't Overlook Pricing Psychology

You may have seen that the most recent UK Consumer Price Index (CPI) figures showed that overall inflation in the UK had fallen to 1.7%. Whilst for many households this will be a welcome headline, the underlying data was not so black and white. Whilst inflation is falling, it continues to hold at above recorded levels for certain key consumer categories, such as food and non-alcoholic beverages (1.9%).

The reality is that many consumers will still be feeling the pressure of price increases, and this poses a difficult choice for retailers and brands. Do they continue to impose price hikes to maintain margins as costs rise, albeit with an increasingly price inelastic customer base, or do they take the hit themselves risk survival for customer loyalty?

For many retailers to manage these competing priorities will seem like a balancing act, but there are potential smarter solutions to cost pressures, that don’t solely rely on price hikes.

Enter ‘Pricing Psychology’ - a suite of pricing tactics that allow for businesses to maximize their existing margins by driving incremental gains through subtle adjustments in price presentation and perception. This small but powerful toolkit allows brands to keep customers onside while navigating tricky cost pressures.

In this article, we’ll explore what pricing psychology is, why it’s often mistakenly overlooked, and business can leverage simple psychological techniques to help find a balance between protecting profits and satisfying customers.

What is Pricing Psychology, and why shouldn’t it be overlooked?

Pricing Psychology is the strategic use of subtle price cues to influence how customers perceive value, make purchasing decisions, and react to prices. By tapping into behavioral patterns - like anchoring higher prices to make other items seem more affordable - brands can drive incremental sales and maintain healthy margins without necessarily changing the base price. It’s a way of optimizing not just what customers pay but how they feel about their purchase.

Pricing psychology tactics are often seen as relatively superficial tweaks that have limited impact on consumer behavior, with businesses instead choosing to focus on more robust pricing strategies like price matching, markdowns, or dynamic pricing that directly respond to market or cost fluctuations.?But the reality is often far from this. In dismissing psychological pricing techniques, brands miss out on significant incremental financial and strategic opportunities, which can add significant relief to margin pressures in totality.

In a landscape where customer price sensitivity is high, yet inflationary pressures remain, pricing psychology offers a valuable toolkit to maintain margins in a way that feels fair – and even appealing – to customers. But why should brands pay closer attention to these techniques, and why now?

1. Meet Customer Expectations without Raising Prices

Today’s consumers are increasingly price-conscious, but they’re also more discerning about the brands they support. By carefully managing price perceptions, brands can encourage customers to spend more without having to hike prices outright.

Pricing psychology enables businesses to add value through the way prices are presented, whether by strategically anchoring prices or tailoring how prices appear based on the type of product or purchase context. This can help brands hit revenue targets without alienating cost-sensitive customers.

2. Add Financial Value through Incremental Gains

Small price adjustments can result in substantial gains over time. Techniques like price anchoring or charm pricing may seem like minor changes, but they can drive a steady uplift in revenue, especially when applied consistently across a brand’s portfolio. These incremental increases can be powerful, allowing brands to capture additional margin without the need for aggressive price hikes or deep markdowns, both of which can erode brand perception and profitability.

3. Differentiate Through Subtlety and Brand Perception

In an era where brand loyalty is fragile, how a brand approaches pricing can set it apart. Pricing psychology allows for an “invisible hand” in guiding purchasing decisions, reinforcing a brand’s positioning. For example, using price presentation techniques can highlight the quality or exclusivity of premium offerings, while bundling helps emphasize value and convenience in a way that feels natural to customers. This not only builds trust but also creates a sense of transparency that resonates with today’s savvy shoppers.

Practical Pricing Psychology Tools for Retailers

We have established why brands should be aware of and utilizing pricing psychology methods, but what are some of the effective Here are some effective techniques that brands can actively introduce today to take advantage of the pricing benefits?

1. Anchoring

Have you ever noticed that when a new iteration of an existing product comes out, often at a higher price point, the previous iteration suddenly seems like great value? Nothing about the previous iteration product has changed, but the presenting of a higher-priced items first sets a mental reference point, making the mid-range product seem like a better deal.

By taking advantage of this further, brands can steer consumers toward higher-value products without needing to slash prices or offer significant discounts. It works particularly well during promotional periods when customers are hunting for what they perceive to be the best value.

2. Price Presentation

The way a price is presented is often just as important as the price itself, as it can have psychological implications for customer purchasing patterns.

Price Presentation techniques (often referred to as Charm Pricing) go beyond just price endings (.99 vs. rounded prices) but also how the price is displayed. For emotional purchases like fashion or luxury goods, smaller, elegant pricing can emphasize exclusivity, while for rational purchases, such as groceries, bolder colors or larger text (often in red) signal urgency or value. The key is aligning the presentation with the type of purchase, be it rational – such as electrical items or white goods - or emotional - such as fashion or homewares.

3. Bundling

Offering multi-product deals at a single price, like "12 for ￡X" versus "1 for ￡Y," boosts perceived value. This approach works particularly well when customers are looking for bulk savings, especially in categories like groceries or household goods. By using bundling, brands can increase basket size without eroding margin through steep markdowns.

It can also be a useful technique for moving aged or slow-moving inventory by combining them in bundles with newer or faster-moving products. Or for subscription based models, where users may want find it harder to cancel multiple different services at once.

The Bottom Line

Pricing psychology is often overlooked by brands, but it’s a powerful tool for navigating today’s inflationary pressures. With customers pushing back against price increases and brands needing to maintain margins, these techniques offer a smart way to optimize pricing without driving customers away.

As we move into key shopping periods like Black Friday and Christmas, the stakes are high. Brands that leverage pricing psychology can strike the right balance of protecting profits while keeping customers engaged. Now is the time to rethink how these seemingly small adjustments can deliver big results.

Capgemini Invent has a comprehensive Pricing & Promotions proposition that covers pricing psychology amongst many other pricing strategies. To find out more about how your business can adopt these pricing models or upgrade your pricing capabilities please reach out for a conversation.

References:

1.???? ONS (2024).?Consumer price inflation, UK. [online] Ons.gov.uk. Available at: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/bulletins/consumerpriceinflation/september2024 [Accessed 30 Oct. 2024].

2.???? Jerusalem Demsas (2024).?The Atlantic. [online] The Atlantic. Available at: https://www.theatlantic.com/podcasts/archive/2024/10/greedflation-inflation-grocery-prices-corporate-greed/680432/ [Accessed 30 Oct. 2024].

3.???? Holmes, H. (2024).?John West suffers first loss since 2010 after absorbing price hikes. [online] The Grocer. Available at: https://www.thegrocer.co.uk/news/john-west-suffers-first-loss-since-2010-after-absorbing-price-hikes/696663.article [Accessed 30 Oct. 2024].

4.???? Wood, S., Watson, I. and Teller, C. (2021). Pricing in online fashion retailing: implications for research and practice.?Journal of Marketing Management, [online] 37(11-12), pp.1–24. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/0267257x.2021.1900334. ?

5.???? Fairfield, G. (2024).?Keeping the Promise: The Realities Behind Never Knowingly Undersold. [online] LinkedIn. Available at: https://www.dhirubhai.net/pulse/keeping-promise-realities-behind-never-knowingly-george-fairfield-ou9ve/?trackingId=3wNZ2a57TRGiBxAzOLZgNA%3D%3D [Accessed 30 Oct. 2024].

6.????? Fairfield, G. (2024).?The Markdown Mirage: Why Discounts Don’t Always Add Up. [online] LinkedIn. Available at: https://www.dhirubhai.net/pulse/markdown-mirage-why-discounts-dont-always-add-up-george-fairfield-ftpse/?trackingId=3wNZ2a57TRGiBxAzOLZgNA%3D%3D [Accessed 30 Oct. 2024].

7.???? Fairfield, G. (2024).?Don’t Look Back in Anger: How Businesses Can Adopt Dynamic Pricing without Frustrating Customers. [online] LinkedIn. Available at: https://www.dhirubhai.net/pulse/dont-look-back-anger-how-businesses-can-adopt-dynamic-fairfield-gasye/?trackingId=3wNZ2a57TRGiBxAzOLZgNA%3D%3D [Accessed 30 Oct. 2024].

8.???? McGregor, J. (2024). Apple Shows Why You Should Sell Your iPhone 14.?Forbes. [online] 15 Sep. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/jaymcgregor/2024/09/15/why-you-should-sell-your-apple-iphone-14-iphone-16-trade-in/ [Accessed 30 Oct. 2024].

9.???? Harding, S. (2024).?Streaming’s bundling obsession ignores the real problem with subscription costs. [online] Ars Technica. Available at: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2024/07/streamings-bundling-obsession-ignores-the-real-problem-with-subscription-costs/ [Accessed 30 Oct. 2024].