Mind the Gap: Navigating the Transition from Star Salesperson to Sales Manager

Often, the best salespeople are promoted to become sales managers. This transition, however, isn't always as smooth as organizations would hope for. Why? The skills that make someone a top-performing salesperson aren't necessarily the same as those that make a successful sales manager. In fact, promoting solely based on sales numbers can sometimes lead to a situation where managers, although experts in sales, lack the critical people skills needed to lead a team effectively. Here's how to navigate this often complex transition.

The Challenge

The greatest salespeople excel in fostering relationships with clients, understanding their needs, and delivering the right solutions at the right time. These attributes are invaluable in a sales role but are only part of the toolkit needed for effective management. A sales manager must be able to inspire and lead a team, communicate effectively, resolve conflicts, and make strategic decisions, all while maintaining a strong understanding of the broader business landscape.

The issue of managers, particularly in sales, being promoted due to their performance but lacking in people skills once they're in a leadership position is a prevalent problem in today's work environments. This phenomenon is often referred to as the Peter Principle, which states that people tend to be promoted to their level of incompetence. In the sales field, for example, an employee might excel in a role that emphasizes individual performance and target achievement. However, upon promotion to a managerial role that requires different skills like team leadership and people management, they may struggle 1 .

What's more, a report by Gartner found that the traditional method of promoting the best performers into leadership positions can sometimes lead to adverse results. The report revealed that organizations filled nearly 45% of their open roles with high-performing incumbents who, when promoted, saw their performance drop by an average of 7.4

Upskill and Train

The transition to sales manager is a significant shift and requires a comprehensive approach to upskilling and training. This starts with recognizing the different skill sets required for each role:

• For salespeople, it's about understanding customer needs, presenting solutions, and closing deals.
• For sales managers, it's about developing and managing a team, setting strategic goals, managing budgets, and maintaining relationships with stakeholders.

By identifying these differences, organizations can tailor training programs that address these gaps. Training should include workshops and courses focused on leadership, conflict resolution, strategic thinking, and emotional intelligence.

Mentorship and Support

One effective way to help new sales managers is to provide a mentor - someone who has walked the path before and can offer guidance and support. This mentor can be a senior manager or leader within the organization who can share their experiences and provide insights on managing a sales team. It's about having someone to turn to when the road gets tough, which it inevitably will.

Regular Feedback and Reviews

Regular feedback and performance reviews are crucial for new sales managers. This feedback should be constructive and aimed at helping the manager grow in their role. Both positive feedback (highlighting what they are doing well) and constructive criticism (highlighting areas for improvement) are valuable for their development.

Creating a Safe Environment

Promoting a culture where it is safe to make mistakes and learn from them is essential. New managers, like anyone learning a new skill, will make mistakes. It's important that these mistakes are seen as opportunities for learning and growth, not as failures. This encourages a growth mindset and supports continuous development.

Tips and Tricks for New Sales Managers

1. Be a Coach, Not a Player: As a manager, your role is to coach your team to success, not to close deals yourself. Focus on helping your team develop the skills they need to succeed.
2. Communicate Clearly and Often: Regular, open, and clear communication is key to building trust and ensuring everyone is aligned on goals and expectations.
3. Delegate Effectively: Delegating tasks allows you to focus on strategic matters. It also helps your team develop new skills and gain confidence.
4. Stay Positive: Your team will look to you for guidance, especially in challenging times. Maintaining a positive outlook can help motivate your team and keep morale high.
5. Never Stop Learning: The best leaders are lifelong learners. Keep up to date with new sales techniques, management strategies, and industry trends.

What are your thoughts on this?