Microsoft Sentinel: Overview and Role in Public Safety Organizations

Microsoft Sentinel is a cloud-native SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) and SOAR (Security Orchestration Automated Response) solution. It offers real-time threat detection, investigation, and response across multiple environments. For public safety organizations—Police, Fire, EMS, Public Utilities—the sensitive nature of their data and operations makes a robust security solution vital. Sentinel centralizes data collection across hybrid environments, allowing these organizations to defend against, detect, and respond to potential threats effectively.

In small public safety organizations (with 100-300 users), medium-sized organizations (with 300-1,000 users), and large organizations (over 1,000 users), Sentinel's usefulness becomes clear as their reliance on critical systems increases, and regulatory requirements become more stringent (e.g., CJIS compliance in the U.S.).

Microsoft 365 Without Sentinel: What’s Included in E5 and G5 Licenses?

As an M365 administrator with E5 or G5 licenses, you already have access to several advanced security and compliance features, but these are limited when it comes to SIEM and SOAR capabilities. Here’s what you get without Sentinel:

1. Microsoft 365 Defender:
2. Data Collection and Incident Response:
3. Automation:

However, while these features are useful, they are not true SIEM or SOAR solutions. Defender tools only cover security within the Microsoft 365 environment, and many manual steps are still involved in collecting logs across systems, correlating events, and responding to incidents in an automated and orchestrated fashion.

With Microsoft Sentinel: Expanding Capabilities

When you add Microsoft Sentinel on top of your M365 tenant, you transform your security posture in several key areas:

1. Centralized Data Collection and Visibility:
2. Advanced Threat Detection and Analytics:
3. Automation and Orchestration (SOAR):
4. Scalability:

Licensing and Pricing Comparison

• Microsoft 365 E5/G5 licenses include Microsoft 365 Defender features, which offer integrated threat detection across M365 applications but lack cross-environment correlation and centralized management.
• Microsoft Sentinel is priced separately, based on data ingestion and retention. This pricing model can make it costly for smaller organizations that generate large amounts of data but is cost-effective for medium to large public safety organizations where centralized threat management is crucial.
• For example: A small fire department (50-100 users) using M365 E5 may be well-served by Microsoft Defender tools, which cover their M365 workloads without needing Sentinel. A large police department (1,000+ users) using Sentinel could ingest logs from 911 dispatch systems, body camera footage databases, MDTs, and M365 workloads, offering a comprehensive view of security threats across the organization.

Key Sentinel Features

Content Hub

The Content Hub provides out-of-the-box templates for analytics rules, workbooks, and playbooks tailored for various industries, including public safety. These pre-built templates can significantly reduce the setup time for configuring threat detection rules and response workflows. Public safety organizations can leverage this to create customized threat responses for emergency systems, mobile networks, or public-facing websites.

In M365 without Sentinel, you can use Defender's built-in templates, but they are limited in scope to M365 workloads, leaving gaps in coverage for hybrid and on-prem environments.

Community Hub

Sentinel’s Community Hub allows customers to share custom rules, playbooks, and analytics with other organizations. This is particularly useful for public safety organizations looking to collaborate on best practices for securing critical infrastructure.

M365 Defender does not have a direct equivalent to this community-based sharing model. This makes Sentinel particularly valuable for organizations looking to tap into the collective knowledge of other security teams, particularly within industries like public safety where specific attack vectors and compliance requirements are common.

Analytics, Rules, and Rule Tuning

• Sentinel includes advanced analytics to correlate events across all collected data. For example, Sentinel can detect a coordinated attack on police dispatch systems and MDTs, something that would be hard to correlate using M365 Defender alone.
• Rules in Sentinel can be customized and tuned for specific scenarios in your environment. This is critical for public safety organizations that need to minimize false positives and ensure real incidents are detected promptly.
• M365 Defender rules are more restricted and less customizable, focused primarily on internal M365 data streams.

Azure Synapse Integration and Notebooks

Sentinel integrates with Azure Synapse for advanced data analysis and visualization, enabling public safety organizations to perform deep investigations across large datasets (e.g., analyzing 911 call logs or historical threat data). Notebooks provide security analysts with powerful tools for complex investigations using Jupyter-style environments.

Without Sentinel, M365 offers basic security analytics via Defender portals, but it lacks the deep integration with big data tools like Synapse or the customizability provided by Notebooks.

Hunting Capabilities

Sentinel’s hunting features allow security teams to proactively search for indicators of compromise (IOCs) across their environments using KQL (Kusto Query Language). This is a major advantage over M365 Defender, which provides some hunting features but only within M365 data streams.

For a large public safety organization, the ability to proactively hunt across different environments (M365, Azure, AWS, on-premises) is crucial in preventing or stopping sophisticated attacks.

Automation

While M365 Defender provides some automation features (AIR), Sentinel’s SOAR capabilities allow for fully orchestrated responses. Sentinel's playbooks can automatically respond to incidents across multiple systems (e.g., triggering a lockdown procedure on a compromised MDT or isolating a compromised device in a fire station’s network). This level of automation is beyond what M365 alone offers.

Integration with Microsoft Defender for Cloud

Sentinel works closely with Microsoft Defender for Cloud, providing security posture management for cloud and on-premises resources. This is critical for public safety organizations with hybrid deployments. Defender for Cloud covers basic compliance and security for cloud resources, but Sentinel integrates across the entire stack, offering deeper visibility and control.

Intelligent Detection and Key Vault

Sentinel’s Intelligent Detection uses machine learning models to automatically detect and block advanced threats across the organization. Azure Key Vault ensures secure management of credentials and encryption keys, enabling secure automation of responses (e.g., encrypting sensitive data in response to a breach).

M365 Defender’s detection capabilities are advanced, but Sentinel adds another layer of intelligence by learning from data across multiple environments, making it better suited for larger, more complex public safety deployments.

Public safety organizations like police departments, fire services, EMS, and public utilities are increasingly being targeted by sophisticated cyberattacks. Ransomware, data breaches, and other security threats have the potential to disrupt critical emergency services, posing risks to public safety and organizational stability. For IT leaders in public safety, ensuring the security of communication systems, mobile data terminals (MDTs), dispatch networks, and sensitive data (like personally identifiable information or medical records) is paramount.

In this article, I explore whether Microsoft Sentinel—Microsoft’s cloud-native security information and event management (SIEM) and security orchestration automated response (SOAR) solution—is the right fit for public safety organizations. I’ll discuss its key features, compare it to the built-in capabilities of Microsoft 365, and offer insight into current trends and best practices.

Trends Impacting Public Safety Cybersecurity

Before diving into Sentinel’s features, it’s important to understand the broader trends driving the need for enhanced cybersecurity in public safety:

1. Increased Cyber Attacks: Public safety organizations are frequently targeted by ransomware and other cyberattacks. The sensitive nature of the data these organizations handle makes them high-value targets. These attacks can result in the loss of crucial data or disruptions in emergency response systems.
2. Adoption of Cloud-First Strategies: Public safety organizations are moving toward cloud-first models to improve scalability, disaster recovery, and collaboration. Cloud-based systems offer improved uptime, flexibility, and security, which are vital for 24/7 emergency response operations.
3. Compliance with Regulatory Frameworks: Public safety agencies must comply with strict data privacy and security regulations like CJIS (Criminal Justice Information Services) for law enforcement and HIPAA for handling health-related information. Sentinel helps automate compliance monitoring and reporting, easing the burden on IT teams.
4. Multi-Cloud and Hybrid Environments: Many public safety organizations use hybrid setups, relying on both cloud-based and on-premise systems. Sentinel offers the ability to monitor security across diverse environments, ensuring unified visibility and control.
5. Zero Trust Architecture: With the increasing complexity of cybersecurity threats, public safety organizations are adopting Zero Trust security models. This approach requires verification for every user and device accessing the network. Sentinel enhances the Zero Trust model by continuously monitoring and analyzing activity across all devices, users, and applications.

Microsoft 365 Without Sentinel: Built-In Security Tools

Public safety organizations with Microsoft 365 E5 or G5 licenses already have access to a range of powerful security tools designed to protect against threats within the M365 environment. Here’s what’s included:

1. Microsoft 365 Defender:
2. Data Collection and Incident Response: These tools allow you to detect, investigate, and respond to security incidents within M365 services (like Exchange, SharePoint, or Teams). However, security logs and insights remain somewhat siloed within each service, making it harder to correlate incidents across hybrid environments.
3. Automation: Microsoft 365 Defender includes automated workflows for common security threats, such as automatically isolating malware-infected emails. But the automation features available in Defender are more limited compared to the comprehensive orchestration capabilities of Sentinel.

With Microsoft Sentinel: Unlocking Advanced SIEM and SOAR Capabilities

While Microsoft 365 offers robust security features, Sentinel provides a more powerful, centralized solution for organizations that need to extend their security posture beyond the M365 ecosystem. Here’s how Sentinel enhances your capabilities:

1. Centralized Data Collection: Sentinel aggregates logs from a variety of sources, including Microsoft 365, Azure, AWS, on-premise systems, and custom applications. For public safety organizations, this means that logs from 911 dispatch systems, MDTs, and emergency management systems can be centralized for easier monitoring and analysis.
2. Advanced Threat Detection and Analytics: Sentinel’s machine learning capabilities allow for more intelligent threat detection, recognizing patterns and anomalies that may not be immediately obvious. For example, Sentinel could detect a coordinated attack across multiple systems—such as a police department’s 911 system and MDTs—that M365 Defender might miss.
3. Automation and Orchestration (SOAR): Sentinel’s playbooks allow public safety organizations to automate complex security responses. For example, if a cyberattack is detected on a public utility’s system, Sentinel could automatically isolate the affected server, block the attacker, and alert IT staff—all without manual intervention.
4. Compliance and Auditing: Sentinel can track compliance with regulatory frameworks such as CJIS and HIPAA in real-time. Its ability to integrate with Azure Policy and Microsoft Defender for Cloud helps automate the tracking of compliance-related metrics, reducing manual effort.
5. Proactive Hunting: Sentinel’s hunting tools allow security teams to search for threats proactively using custom queries across their environment. This is particularly useful for preventing sophisticated, coordinated attacks on critical infrastructure.
6. Scalability: Sentinel scales seamlessly with the size of your organization, making it suitable for both small fire departments and large police forces. Pricing is based on the amount of data ingested, allowing you to adjust based on your organization’s needs.

Licensing and Pricing Comparison

• Microsoft 365 E5/G5 Licenses: These licenses provide excellent security coverage within the M365 ecosystem, including threat detection and response for email, SharePoint, Teams, and endpoints. However, they do not offer centralized log collection across hybrid environments, nor do they include full SIEM or SOAR capabilities.
• Microsoft Sentinel Pricing: Sentinel is priced based on data ingestion and retention, making it more cost-effective for medium to large public safety organizations. Smaller organizations with a lighter data load might find M365 Defender sufficient for their needs. However, for agencies dealing with complex, multi-system environments (e.g., large police departments or utility companies), Sentinel’s ability to centralize and automate security tasks is invaluable.

Key Sentinel Features for Public Safety Organizations

1. Content Hub: The Content Hub offers pre-built rules, playbooks, and workbooks designed for various industries, including public safety. These templates can help streamline the setup of Sentinel in public safety environments. In contrast, M365 Defender offers similar templates but only within the M365 environment, leaving gaps in hybrid or multi-cloud environments.
2. Community Hub: The Sentinel Community Hub allows users to share custom rules, playbooks, and analytics with other organizations. Public safety agencies can benefit from the collective knowledge of other users, contributing back by sharing solutions specific to public safety threats.
3. Rule Tuning and Analytics: Sentinel provides detailed analytics and customizable rule tuning, allowing public safety agencies to minimize false positives and focus on the most critical security alerts.
4. Azure Synapse Integration: Sentinel integrates with Azure Synapse for advanced data analysis, enabling deep investigations into security incidents. For example, public safety organizations can analyze large datasets such as 911 call logs or body camera footage for anomalies or threat indicators.
5. Hunting and Notebooks: Sentinel’s hunting capabilities allow IT teams to proactively search for threats across their entire environment. Notebooks provide a powerful tool for forensic analysis, especially useful for investigating complex attacks on critical infrastructure.

Best Practices for Implementing Sentinel in Public Safety

1. Leverage Automation: Use Sentinel’s playbooks to automate responses to common incidents, such as isolating infected endpoints or notifying staff of a potential breach.
2. Optimize Data Retention: Given that pricing is based on data ingestion, public safety organizations should carefully manage their data retention policies to balance cost and effectiveness.
3. Proactive Threat Hunting: Encourage your IT teams to use Sentinel’s hunting features regularly to search for new and emerging threats, especially as the cybersecurity landscape continues to evolve.
4. Focus on Compliance: Integrate Sentinel with Azure Policy and Defender for Cloud to continuously monitor and audit your organization’s compliance with CJIS, HIPAA, and other relevant regulations.
5. Collaborate via the Community Hub: Engage with other public safety agencies through Sentinel’s Community Hub to share best practices and enhance your own organization’s security posture.

The true costs of implementing and operating Microsoft Sentinel depend on several factors, including data ingestion volumes, retention periods, and the complexity of your organization's security environment. Sentinel’s pricing structure can be broken down into three main categories: data ingestion, data retention, and additional services like automation and machine learning analysis. Below is a detailed breakdown of the key cost components and considerations that will help public safety organizations estimate the overall cost of using Sentinel.

Key Cost Components of Microsoft Sentinel

1. Data Ingestion Costs: Sentinel is priced based on the amount of data ingested from various sources into the platform. The more data sources (e.g., 911 systems, mobile data terminals, dispatch systems, and Microsoft 365 services) you connect to Sentinel, the more logs and events it will need to process.
2. Data Retention Costs: Once data is ingested, you need to store it for analysis and compliance purposes. Public safety organizations may have strict regulatory requirements (like CJIS) that mandate longer retention periods for security logs and incident data.
3. Automation and SOAR Costs: Sentinel includes built-in Security Orchestration, Automation, and Response (SOAR) capabilities using Azure Logic Apps to automate responses to incidents. While basic automation is included in Sentinel’s core pricing, more complex workflows and integrations with third-party systems may incur additional costs.
4. Machine Learning and AI Costs: Microsoft Sentinel uses machine learning (ML) models to detect threats and perform advanced analytics. While these models are included in the base price of Sentinel, additional costs can arise when integrating with other AI-driven services, such as Azure Synapse for big data analytics or Azure Machine Learning for custom model training.
5. Log Analytics Workspace Costs: Sentinel relies on Azure Log Analytics to collect, process, and store logs. Pricing for Log Analytics is included in Sentinel’s data ingestion and retention costs, but complex queries and larger datasets may incur higher compute charges based on the volume and frequency of queries.
6. Additional Integration Costs: Public safety organizations often rely on hybrid or multi-cloud environments, meaning Sentinel may need to ingest data from on-premise systems, cloud applications (e.g., AWS, Google Cloud), or custom applications (e.g., 911 dispatch software). While many connectors are included, custom integrations or third-party data sources may require additional costs or development resources.
7. Staffing and Expertise: While Sentinel itself is a powerful tool, public safety organizations must account for the costs of staff training, ongoing management, and potential consulting services to set up and operate the system effectively.

Cost Estimation for Public Safety Organizations

Let’s break down the cost based on three hypothetical scenarios for small, medium, and large public safety organizations:

1. Small Public Safety Organization (100-200 seats)

• Data Ingestion: 10-20 GB per day (~600 GB per month)Monthly ingestion cost: $1,656 (600 GB * $2.76/GB)
• Retention: 300 GB of data stored for 6 monthsMonthly retention cost (after 90 days): $36 (300 GB * $0.12/GB)
• Automation and SOAR: Limited use (~10,000 executions/month)Monthly cost: ~$0.25 (10,000 executions * $0.000025)
• Estimated Monthly Total: $1,692
• Annual Total: $20,304

2. Medium Public Safety Organization (300-1,000 seats)

• Data Ingestion: 50-75 GB per day (~2,000 GB per month)Monthly ingestion cost: $5,520 (2,000 GB * $2.76/GB)
• Retention: 1,000 GB of data stored for 6 monthsMonthly retention cost (after 90 days): $120 (1,000 GB * $0.12/GB)
• Automation and SOAR: Moderate use (~100,000 executions/month)Monthly cost: $2.50 (100,000 executions * $0.000025)
• Estimated Monthly Total: $5,642
• Annual Total: $67,704

3. Large Public Safety Organization (1,000+ seats)

• Data Ingestion: 100-150 GB per day (~5,000 GB per month)Monthly ingestion cost: $13,800 (5,000 GB * $2.76/GB)
• Retention: 2,500 GB of data stored for 6 monthsMonthly retention cost (after 90 days): $300 (2,500 GB * $0.12/GB)
• Automation and SOAR: Heavy use (~1,000,000 executions/month)Monthly cost: $25 (1,000,000 executions * $0.000025)
• Estimated Monthly Total: $14,125
• Annual Total: $169,500

Ways to Optimize Sentinel Costs

1. Filter Data Ingestion: Limit the amount of data ingested into Sentinel by excluding unnecessary log data (e.g., development environments or low-priority systems). Focus on high-risk sources such as critical infrastructure and user activity logs.
2. Retention Policies: Implement strict data retention policies that balance regulatory requirements with cost control. For example, store only security-critical data in real-time storage and archive less important data.
3. Leverage Commitment Pricing: Microsoft offers discounts if you commit to a specific amount of data ingestion over a defined period. This is especially useful for larger public safety organizations with predictable data volumes.
4. Optimize Automation Usage: Use automation judiciously. While Sentinel’s SOAR features are powerful, overuse of automated workflows can increase costs. Focus on automating high-value tasks.
5. Monitor Costs Regularly: Use Azure’s cost management tools to track your spending in real-time. This allows your IT team to quickly identify areas where costs can be optimized, such as adjusting ingestion volumes or fine-tuning retention settings.

Conclusion: Is Sentinel Cost-Effective?

Microsoft Sentinel’s cost structure may appear high, especially for large public safety organizations, but its centralized visibility, advanced threat detection, and automation capabilities offer significant value for ensuring the security of critical systems. For smaller public safety agencies, M365 Defender may suffice, but as security needs grow and organizations expand their hybrid environments, Sentinel becomes a more attractive option. Costs can be optimized with proper planning, data management policies, and automation strategies.

Conclusion: Is Sentinel Right for Your Public Safety Organization?

Microsoft Sentinel provides a comprehensive SIEM and SOAR solution that goes beyond the capabilities of M365 Defender. For small organizations, Microsoft 365’s built-in security tools may be sufficient, particularly if they operate solely within the M365 ecosystem. However, medium and large public safety organizations dealing with complex, hybrid environments and stricter regulatory requirements will find Sentinel invaluable for improving their overall security posture.

Sentinel’s centralized data collection, advanced threat detection, and automation features make it a powerful tool for public safety organizations looking to safeguard their critical infrastructure while staying compliant with industry regulations.

Conclusion: When Does Sentinel Make Sense?

Sentinel should be considered by:

• Medium to large public safety organizations handling high volumes of sensitive data or having complex hybrid environments.
• Organizations requiring full SIEM and SOAR capabilities with centralized log management, cross-platform threat detection, and automated responses across all systems.
• Smaller organizations may rely on the built-in features of M365 Defender, but as security needs grow, particularly in compliance-heavy environments like public safety, Sentinel becomes more of a necessity.

Pricing is based on data ingestion, so medium to large organizations with higher security budgets will find Sentinel more valuable and cost-effective.

Are you ready to take your Cloud-First strategies to the next level but you don't have the necessary time or expertise? Ask me how Green IT Consulting can be your partner in Cloud-First Technologies. Our comprehensive IT Assessment service provides expertise and insights needed to strengthen your IT and Cloud-First framework to ensure your organization is well-prepared for the demands of the modern digital workplace. Schedule a free 30-minute consultation today and start your journey toward Cloud-First.