“Merit”ocracy? Or Just Plain Oops-tocracy?-The Future of DEI #13

Happy Friday!

When the announcement came that many large organizations were slashing DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) initiatives in favour of a so-called "merit-based" approach, my first thought was, “Oh no, not this again!” Merit, you say? In workplaces where “Kevin from accounting” keeps getting promoted because he golfs with the boss? Let’s dive into this merit merry-go-round, the future of DEI, and why AI might just be the hero we need but don’t deserve.

Meritocracy: The Unicorn That Doesn’t Exist

On paper, merit-based systems sound like a dream—people are hired and promoted purely based on their skills and accomplishments. But here’s the kicker: workplaces aren’t fancy spreadsheets! Humans bring bias into every equation all in the name of "the right fit". So, when you remove DEI policies, what you’re left with is Kevin’s Magical Climb to the top while Nkechi, who is twice as qualified, is told to “wait her turn.”

Research has shown that unconscious bias runs rampant when “merit” is left unchecked. It’s like leaving toddlers alone with glitter—they’ll make a mess, and you’ll never be able to completely clean it up.

DEI: More Than Just Buzzwords

Let’s be real—DEI initiatives aren’t just feel-good corporate policies. They’re the infrastructure that ensures marginalized voices are heard, opportunities are equal, and workplaces reflect the diversity of the world outside. Removing DEI is like taking airbags out of cars and calling it an “upgrade.”

Without DEI:

• Recruitment becomes a mirror instead of a window. Teams start to look alike, sound alike, and yes, think alike and honestly, this kills innovation.
• Bias flourishes like mould in a damp basement. Without checks and balances, discrimination thrives.
• Marginalized employees feel less seen, less valued, and are more likely to leave, leading to a talent drain that no amount of “merit” can fix.

Can AI Save the Day?

While artificial intelligence won’t solve systemic racism or sexism, it can be a game-changer when wielded wisely.

Here’s how AI can keep DEI alive even when budgets don’t:

1. Bias Detection: AI can analyze hiring patterns, pay gaps, and promotion rates to spot inequities faster than you can say “diversity training.”
2. Inclusive Recruitment: AI-powered tools can rewrite job descriptions to eliminate biased language and attract a more diverse talent pool.
3. Anonymous Evaluations: By anonymizing resumes, AI can ensure hiring managers focus on skills, not surnames.
4. Feedback Analysis: AI can sift through employee surveys to identify trends in inclusion and belonging—or lack thereof.

But let’s not pretend AI is a saint. Without proper oversight, it can amplify the biases it is supposed to reduce. After all, who programs AI? Humans. And guess what? Humans are biased. So, if we are going to lean on AI, it needs to be designed and monitored by diverse teams.

The Dangers of Killing DEI

Removing DEI policies in the name of “merit” doesn’t level the playing field—it tilts it further. Organizations risk:

• Homogeneity: A workplace full of “Kevins” isn’t just boring; it’s uncompetitive.
• Reputation Damage: Employees and customers alike notice when inclusion takes a backseat.
• Missed Opportunities: Diverse teams perform better. Period. Removing DEI is like throwing away a golden ticket because you prefer silver.

Call to Action: Don’t Kill the Dream

DEI is not a trend; it is a necessity. Workplaces are microcosms of society, and if we can’t get it right there, how can we expect progress anywhere else? So, here’s the plan:

• Advocate for DEI: Speak up when you see inclusion sidelined.
• Embrace AI: Use technology to identify and address gaps.
• Lead with Empathy: Policies are just words without action. Show people they matter.

In the end, the future of DEI depends on all of us. Because let’s face it—without diversity, workplaces are just echo chambers with vending machines.

Key Takeaways

1. DEI isn’t optional; it’s essential for innovation and equity.
2. Meritocracy without DEI is a fancy excuse for bias.
3. AI can be a powerful DEI ally—if used ethically.
4. The fight for inclusion isn’t over. It’s just beginning.

DEI might be on life support, but we’re the doctors, and AI is the new stethoscope. Let’s keep the heart of inclusion beating!

Purchase your copy from my Africa Is NOT a Country series - https://lnkd.in/gVPr2J-9

Olunosen Louisa Ibhaze

Happy reading!

#Ai #Dei #decolonizingdei #decolonizingAI #humancentereddesign #milticulturalism #diversityequityandinclusion #Blackhistory #buildingequitableworkplaces #digitalpolicies #humanityandhumour #AIEnthusiast #Techenthusiast #BlackHistoryEveryday #WeBeenRoyalty #KnowYourPower