Media’s Digital Dilemma
The challenges faced by TVNZ are a microcosm of the broader shifts in media consumption and the political landscape.
The developments at TVNZ underscore the broader shifts in media consumption and the challenges faced by traditional broadcasters in adapting to the digital age. The cutbacks and job losses at TVNZ are symptomatic of a larger trend: the erosion of traditional media's business models in the face of digital disruption. This situation is not unique to TVNZ but reflects a global phenomenon that has seen audiences migrate to online platforms, leaving traditional media outlets struggling to maintain their revenue streams.
As the results of the 2024 presidential election rolled in, one thing became abundantly clear: Donald Trump had not only secured a decisive victory, including the popular vote, but his campaign had also failed to resuscitate the mainstream media's previous business model. The political landscape had fundamentally shifted, reflecting a seismic change in how voters consume and engage with political content.
Throughout the campaign, Trump's strategy diverged significantly from traditional approaches. Instead of relying heavily on mainstream media outlets, his campaign doubled down on alternative platforms, leveraging the power of podcasts, live streams, and direct-to-audience communication channels. This approach not only circumvented the traditional media gatekeepers but also tapped into the growing demand for authentic and unfiltered political discourse.
The mainstream media, which had once thrived on sensational headlines and adversarial reporting, found itself struggling to adapt to this new reality. The public's trust in these outlets had eroded significantly, partly due to the perceived biases and inaccuracies in their coverage of Trump and his supporters. Voters, increasingly sceptical of the narratives presented by mainstream media, turned to alternative sources that offered more nuanced and less partisan perspectives.
Joe Rogan's podcast, “The Joe Rogan Experience,” continued to be a significant player in this new media ecosystem. Rogan's long-form interviews provided a platform for in-depth discussions that resonated with voters seeking substantive political conversations. The podcast's success underscored a broader trend: the public's appetite for genuine, unscripted dialogue over carefully curated sound bites and social media endorsements.
The 2024 campaign also highlighted the diminishing influence of social media celebrities and influencers. While these figures had played a notable role in previous elections, their impact waned as voters increasingly prioritised authenticity and depth over superficial endorsements. This shift forced political campaigns to re-evaluate their strategies, focusing more on substantive engagement and less on celebrity-driven marketing.
Trump's victory, achieved without the traditional media's support, sent a clear message to the industry. The old business model, which relied on sensationalism and partisan narratives, was no longer viable in an era where voters demanded transparency, authenticity, and balanced reporting. The mainstream media faced a stark choice: adapt to the new landscape by embracing more nuanced and fair coverage or risk becoming increasingly irrelevant in the political conversation.
Meanwhile, the cutbacks at TVNZ are a clear sign that traditional media's business models are no longer sustainable. The rapid decline in advertising revenue and the shift to digital platforms are forcing broadcasters to restructure and downsize. The acceleration of TVNZ's digital strategy, including the focus on TVNZ+, reflects the broader trend of audiences moving to online platforms. This shift is not just about technology but also about changing consumer preferences for more personalised and on-demand content.
The emotional and professional impact on TVNZ staff underscores the human cost of this transition. The restructuring affects not just the jobs but also the morale and future prospects of those who remain. Also, the pressure from the government shareholder for TVNZ to return to profitability adds another layer of complexity. The need to balance financial sustainability with public service obligations is a challenge that many state-owned media outlets face.
Traditional media outlets need to fully embrace digital innovation, not just as an add-on but as a core part of their business strategy. This includes investing in digital platforms, creating content tailored for online audiences, and exploring new revenue streams such as subscription models. In the political sphere, the success of platforms like Joe Rogan's podcast highlights the demand for authentic, in-depth conversations. Traditional media can learn from this by focusing on substantive, unfiltered content that resonates with audiences.
To regain public trust, traditional media outlets have to prioritise balanced and accurate reporting. This includes avoiding partisan narratives and providing a platform for diverse viewpoints. The future of media, both in terms of business models and content strategies, will be shaped by the ability to adapt to digital disruption and meet the evolving preferences of audiences. Certainly, the election of Donald Trump, despite the media's often adversarial stance, serves as a wake-up call, underscoring the urgent need for a new approach to political journalism.
READ MORE
Media Gaslighting
Beyond Big Media
The Podcasting Explosion is Reshaping the Media Landscape
Podcasts with Pictures are the New Mainstream Media
The Media is Dead – Long Live the Media
Did TVNZ Eat All The (Advertising) Pies?
?