The Maximum Viable Product
The Sundial Bridge in Redding, Califonrina at the Turtle Bay Exploration Park

The Maximum Viable Product

Last week we drove from San Diego, CA to Portland, OR. We stopped off in Redding, California, specifically to experience the Calatrava designed pedestrian bridge that crosses the Sacramento River and connects two portions of the Turtle Bay Exploration Park. All thanks to my wife and partner, Kristina, who plans all of our travel. Not only is the bridge stunning like all Calatravas, it is also the world's largest functioning sundial. Did the town of Redding need to hire an internationally renown architect to build this bridge? No they didn’t. Could it have cost less? I’m sure it could have cost much less. Would Kristina and I have stopped with our dog Enzo to have lunch and enjoy the town if it was just a regular old bridge connecting two parts of a park? No we wouldn't have. The Turtle Bay Exploration Park was packed on a 90+ degree day. Much of this foot traffic seemed to be for that bridge.

It isn't likely that making a functional sundial was part of the brief sent to Santiago Calatrava. We don't even know if the sundial function was part of his original intent. It is possible that during the iterative process Calatrava realized it started to look like a sundial and he perhaps ran with it. This is the benefit of hiring a well trained, experienced, and high skilled professional for a project and giving them a little room to run. This bridge is not the MVP (Minimum Viable Product). If it was, no one would be there. This is the Maximum Viable Product. This is the most he could get through the system, not the least.

No alt text provided for this image

As designers we need to not only know how to get things made (#realdesignersship), and not only solve problems for real users (#usercentereddesign) we also have to convince those that hold the final decision making power in the process that they should help us to build things that people love. The goal is to make something of value not only for its immediate utility, but also something that engages that aspirational side of the human psyche. As designers we can do that a bit more than anyone else in the product development process.

No alt text provided for this image

We can never forget to advocate not only for industry. Our products have to be profitable and made within the context of commerce. We have to of course design products for users. If we are not solving real problems for real people, what are we actually doing? To those two things I'd like to add a third defining principle, we have to design for culture. We should at least strive to create things that are embraced by the culture as a whole and encourage people to look up toward the horizon. It is a difficult thing to test for and hard to predict, but we can try. By naming and defining it as a goal we at least have a higher chance of achieving that. I talk about some of these thoughts on the about page of michaelditullo.com but seeing the Sundial Bridge last week really drove it home again... on the flip side, the glass and metal floor of the bridge gets so hot there is a sign warning about dog paws, so I had to carry Enzo across, but we didn't mind :-)

No alt text provided for this image

For more than 20 years Michael has been designing iconic products and brand experiences for some of the best brands in the world including Nike, Google, Motorola, Honda, and Hasbro. Located in Portland, Oregon, his studio focuses on industry leading halo projects across autonomous automotive, consumer electronics, travel, mobile devices, wearables, toys and conceptual Hollywood entertainment projects. Learn more about his studio at michaelditullo.com

Juan Duque

Sanitaryware Chief @ Organizacion Corona | Product Development, Industrial Design

5 年

Getting the "most" out of the system should be the final goal of any good design. MVP seen as a quick iteration during early design stages to reduce uncertainty in a limited resource system is a rational way of working towards that MaxVP. I really find your point of view refreshing. We tend to forget MaxVP is the real goal. Calatrava's work is highly inspiring but from my point of view more akin to art than to design. I suggest this article to get a clearer view. Design should be responsible. https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2015/jun/09/santiago-calatrava-defends-record-architect-spain

Brian Donlin

Industrial Designer, 9+ yrs, looking for new opportunity!

5 年

I wonder if the solution is a mix of both: the maximum viable *design*, with the minimum viable *product*. The former, I think, is more what you're writing about--connecting with the human psyche, which doesn't need to add cost or complexity. For example, I've heard you mention certain shoe design details before. That stuff is great. Let's call that the Maximum Viable Design. Those details are free and easy to implement, and can really strengthen the emotional bond with the user. The Minimum Viable Product, in my mind, is more about reducing functional features and complexity so that you can get to market faster and cheaper, then see what customers think and iterate. This is especially important for startups or new ventures within corporations. I think a good MVP can (and should!) have an MVD. The MVD, as you say, is "the most you can get through the system." Maybe I'm splitting hairs here?

回复
Mark Makwinski

Associate Director, Engineering Strategy & Disruptive Technology at Carrier Corporation

5 年

Thinking of the MVP as the most that you can get through the system is a challenge that would benefit many projects.

Tim Gladwin

Retired loudspeaker innovator.

5 年

Now I have another cool place for a weekend visit. Wise thoughts, as always, Michael.?

Amy Santee

Career Strategist & Coach for UX Professionals | Writer, Speaker, & Podcaster | Personal Growth Nerd | Anti-Capitalist | Radically Inspired by People

5 年

Refreshing reminder!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Michael DiTullo的更多文章

  • Seven year anniversary.

    Seven year anniversary.

    April marked the completion of the seventh year of my consulting practice. It has been another packed year and I wanted…

    28 条评论
  • Building Teams: A New Hope

    Building Teams: A New Hope

    Over the last 25 years in design and new product development I’ve been on many project teams. I became a design…

    23 条评论
  • Six Years Of Collaboration!

    Six Years Of Collaboration!

    The six year anniversary of my independent consulting practice was in April. We’ve been so busy having fun working with…

    28 条评论
  • 5 Years Of Shipping Iconic Design

    5 Years Of Shipping Iconic Design

    In 2017 I started my consulting practice with two goals. First, to help companies move people to action with strategic…

    20 条评论
  • The story behind #RealDesignersShip

    The story behind #RealDesignersShip

    Balancing the way industrial design is represented on social media. According to Wikipedia “Industrial design is a…

    36 条评论
  • The Dissatisfied Designer

    The Dissatisfied Designer

    Understanding the importance and balance of critical thinking to assess your own work and the work of others. A young…

    22 条评论
  • Celebrating Our Second Year!

    Celebrating Our Second Year!

    Two years ago I created my eponymous design consulting studio. I'm so happy with how much we have grown and…

    11 条评论
  • What I'm Learning from Designing with Kids

    What I'm Learning from Designing with Kids

    Over the last several months I've been working with the educational teams at the Del Mar Central School District in San…

    36 条评论
  • What Does it take to be a Design Leader?

    What Does it take to be a Design Leader?

    Recently throughout the business press, there have been countless articles about CCOs and CDOs and their value. Large…

    27 条评论
  • Autonomous Golf Carts of the Future?

    Autonomous Golf Carts of the Future?

    My friend and co-worker, Joel Sietsema, recently challenged me to rethink the trusty golf cart. Driving the golf cart…

    15 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了