Mastering User Identity Resolution in Amplitude & Mixpanel: From Anonymous to Known Across Devices

In a world where users interact with digital products across multiple devices and contexts, accurately understanding who’s doing what — and when — is essential for any data-driven organization. User identity resolution enables teams to track user behavior from anonymous exploration to authenticated engagement, creating a single cohesive narrative across sessions, devices, and user states.

Both Amplitude and Mixpanel offer powerful identity resolution frameworks, but leveraging them effectively requires a deep understanding of how identities are tracked, merged, and analyzed.

Understanding Identity: Anonymous vs Known

At the core of identity resolution is the differentiation between:

• Anonymous users: Users who have not logged in or identified themselves; typically tracked using a device ID or anonymous ID.
• Known users: Users who have authenticated or provided an identifier like an email or user ID.

The challenge arises when a single user interacts with your product:

• Across multiple devices (e.g., phone → laptop),
• With multiple sessions as an anonymous user before signing in,
• Or logs in after performing actions, and you want to merge all this behavior under one user profile.

Amplitude’s Identity Resolution Framework

Amplitude uses three types of IDs for identity management:

• Device ID: Automatically assigned per device/browser.
• User ID: Explicitly set by your app when the user logs in.
• Amplitude ID: An internal identifier used to track users across sessions.

How Amplitude Handles Identity Resolution

Anonymous Tracking (Pre-login)

• Amplitude assigns a device_id.
• Events are tied to the amplitude_id and device_id.

Known Tracking (Post-login)

• When you call setUserId("12345"), Amplitude starts associating events with that user ID.
• Amplitude automatically merges the anonymous history with the known user if: The session contains both anonymous and known identifiers. Or you explicitly use identify() API with matching traits.

Multiple Devices

• If a user logs in from Device A and then Device B, and both use the same user_id, Amplitude merges the data.
• Device-specific activity is still preserved but tied to the same user.

Best Practices

• Call setUserId() as soon as the user logs in.
• Avoid changing the device_id manually unless for very specific cases.
• Use setUserProperties() to enrich the profile with metadata (e.g., plan tier, signup date).

Mixpanel’s Identity Resolution Strategy

Mixpanel uses:

• Distinct ID: A unique identifier for every user (can be anonymous or known).
• $identify(): Explicitly tells Mixpanel to merge anonymous and known profiles.
• $anon_distinct_id: Temporary ID for anonymous users.

Anonymous to Known in Mixpanel

Anonymous Phase

• Mixpanel tracks the user with a randomly generated distinct_id.
• Events are stored under this anonymous profile.

Transition to Known User

• When the user logs in, you call $identify("user_123").
• This merges the anonymous profile with the known one.
• All previous events under the anonymous ID now belong to user_123.

Multiple Devices

• If the user logs in with the same ID on another device and you call $identify("user_123"), Mixpanel will associate all activity under that ID.
• Without $identify(), each device will generate separate anonymous profiles, even for the same user.

Mixpanel Identity Merge Rules

• Mixpanel merges profiles only when $identify() is called.
• It’s a one-time irreversible merge.
• It's important to not reuse distinct_id across different users or devices before calling $identify().

Additional Best Practices

• Always capture $anon_distinct_id and send it with $identify().
• Set super properties to track persistent user context.
• Avoid hardcoding distinct IDs before user authentication.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Real-World Implementation Tips

Scenario: A User Browses on Mobile Then Signs Up on Web

On Mobile (Anonymous)

• User interacts without logging in.
• Event data is sent with device_id / anonymous distinct_id.

On Web (Sign-up/Login)

• The user provides an email and logs in.
• You now: Amplitude: Call setUserId("user_123"). Mixpanel: Call $identify("user_123") with the anonymous ID.

Result

• Both platforms will merge historical activity from the anonymous phase into the known user’s timeline.
• You get a holistic user journey, from first anonymous touchpoint to conversion and beyond.

Advanced Considerations

Handling Identity Conflicts

• Avoid assigning the same user ID to multiple real people.
• Ensure your backend issues consistent, stable IDs for known users.
• In Mixpanel, misuse of $identify() can lead to polluted profiles if anonymous IDs are shared across users.

Cross-Platform Identity Sync

• Use cookies/local storage to pass anonymous IDs between web and mobile.
• Consider implementing a backend identity service to orchestrate ID mapping centrally.

GDPR & Data Privacy

• Be mindful of data subject rights when merging profiles.
• Both tools offer APIs to delete or export user data upon request.

Conclusion

User identity resolution is a cornerstone of accurate behavioral analytics. Both Amplitude and Mixpanel offer sophisticated tools to help product teams connect the dots across anonymous browsing, authenticated sessions, and multiple devices. But it’s on you — the builder, analyst, or developer — to implement it thoughtfully.

By carefully managing identity transitions and understanding each platform’s nuances, you can unlock the full power of your user data and drive smarter, more personalized experiences.

Pro Tip: Want to test your implementation? Trigger anonymous events, then log in and inspect the user profile in your analytics UI. You should see a complete timeline — not two separate user records.

Let me know if you'd like code snippets for different SDKs (JavaScript, iOS, Android) or real-world tracking plans for identity resolution!

I’m passionate about empowering organizations with data-driven decision-making while respecting user privacy.

Here’s how you can connect with me or view my work:

Upwork Profile: Upwork

Freelancer Profile: Freelancer

My Blog on GTM & Website Analytics: Google Tag Manager Solution

If you or someone in your network is looking for an experienced professional in this space, I’d love to connect and chat further!