Mastering the UDRB & Entitlement Package: Navigating Miami's Urban Design Review Board for Project Approval

By Agustin Salas, IAAIA

Navigating the Urban Design Review Board & Entitlement process in the city of Miami, Fl is crucial if you are an Architect or a Developer working on large scale developments. Keep reading this article for a comprehensive guide to your UDRB submission, including:

• The UDRB decoded: Understand their role and how to make your project stand out.
• Crafting a winning entitlement package: Learn the secrets to a smooth and successful UDRB approval.
• Optimizing your design for Miami's unique identity: Discover how to combine creative vision with zoning code requirements.
• Unlocking the potential of TOD projects: Harness the power of transit-oriented development to gain an edge.
• Insider tips and expert strategies: Gain valuable insights from someone who understands the intricacies of Miami's design and development landscape.

By the end of this article, you'll be equipped to:

• Confidently navigate the UDRB process.
• Design projects that not only impress but also gain UDRB approval.
• Unlock the full potential of your development and contribute to Miami's architectural legacy.

Our journey doesn't end with UDRB approval. As Designers, we have a unique responsibility: to shape Miami's future with projects that not only meet regulations but also resonate with the city's soul.

Your architectural vision should:

• Interpret the Location: Embrace the history and character of your project's specific neighborhood. Does it border a bustling commercial district or a serene residential area? Understanding the context allows your design to seamlessly integrate and enhance the existing environment.
• Celebrate the People: Miami is a vibrant tapestry of cultures and lifestyles. Consider how your project caters to the needs of the community. Will it create a lively public space, provide affordable housing options, or offer a haven for artists and entrepreneurs?
• Prioritize Pedestrians: Miami's sunshine beckons exploration on foot. Design with pedestrians in mind – wide sidewalks, inviting plazas, and street-level retail create a walkable and human-scaled environment.
• Nurture the Art Scene: Miami is an artistic powerhouse. Can your project incorporate elements that showcase local talent? Public art installations, designated studio spaces, or partnerships with art institutions can create a vibrant cultural hub.
• Embrace Sustainability:?Miami's future is intertwined with environmental responsibility. Integrate sustainable design principles into your vision. Consider using recycled materials, incorporating energy-efficient systems, maximizing natural light and ventilation, and fostering green spaces.

By weaving these elements into your vision, you'll create a project that goes beyond bricks and mortar. You'll build a space that enriches the lives of Miami residents, fosters a sense of community, and leaves a lasting positive impact on the city's architectural legacy.

In the vibrant landscape of Miami, Florida, a city recognized for its vibrant culture, stunning architecture, and ever-evolving skyline, is a place where design and development intertwine. The city is where architectural innovation meets urban development, and the Urban Design Review Board (UDRB) stands as a crucial gatekeeper for projects reshaping the city skyline. Tasked with reviewing projects that are Large-Scale Developments, the UDRB plays a pivotal role in shaping Miami's urban fabric, ensuring that new developments harmonize with the city's aesthetic, cultural, and environmental values. In this article, we delve into the intricacies of creating a successful UDRB and entitlement package, combining architectural design excellence with legal acumen to secure approval in the first presentation submittal.

UDRB: The Gatekeepers of Design

The UDRB serves as the intermediary between creative visions and the city's regulations. This board, comprised of design professionals and government officials, reviews development proposals to ensure they adhere to zoning codes, urban planning objectives, and Miami's architectural heritage. The UDRB plays a pivotal role in shaping the city's aesthetic identity.

The Entitlement Package: Paving the Path

An entitlement package is a comprehensive document outlining a proposed development's details. It serves as a roadmap for the UDRB, encompassing design plans, zoning compliance analyses, and environmental impact studies. A well-crafted entitlement package, prepared by a team with expertise in both design and legal matters, increases a project's chances of approval by the UDRB.

A Fusion of Expertise for Miami's Success

Miami's architectural landscape thrives on the collaboration between designers and legal minds. Designers bring their creativity and knowledge of current trends to the table, while legal professionals ensure projects comply with regulations and navigate the entitlement process. This fusion of expertise is what breathes life into Miami's iconic skyline and fosters a sustainable urban environment.

Looking Ahead: A Collaborative Future

As Miami continues to grow and evolve, the UDRB and the entitlement package process will remain at the forefront of ensuring responsible and aesthetically pleasing development. By working together, developers, designers, architects, and legal professionals can craft a future for Miami where bold visions meet legal requirements, shaping a city that is both beautiful and functional.

Understanding the UDRB Process:

Before embarking on the journey of crafting a compelling UDRB package, it's essential to comprehend the intricacies of the review process. The UDRB comprises multidisciplinary experts, including architects, urban planners, landscape architects, and community representatives, tasked with evaluating projects based on design quality, contextual integration, and adherence to zoning regulations along with urban design guidelines.

Integrating Architectural Design Excellence:

The key to a winning UDRB package lies in the “Architectural Design Excellence”. Every aspect of the project, from massing and scale to fa?ade treatment and materiality, must reflect a thoughtful response to Miami's unique urban context. Embracing the city's eclectic architectural heritage while incorporating contemporary trends, successful projects seamlessly blend innovation with sensitivity to cultural and historical contexts.

Key elements of architectural design to consider:

1. Contextual Integration: Demonstrating a deep understanding of the surrounding urban fabric and responding to local architectural typologies and urban design principles.

2. Iconic Identity: Creating a distinctive architectural identity that enhances Miami's skyline while fostering a sense of place and community.

3. Sustainable Solutions: Integrating sustainable design strategies to mitigate environmental impact and promote resilience in the face of climate change.

4. Human Scale and Connectivity: Prioritizing pedestrian-friendly design elements, such as activated ground floors, public spaces, and walkable streetscapes, to enhance urban connectivity and vitality.

Legal Considerations:

In tandem with architectural design, navigating the legal landscape is critical to securing UDRB approval. A comprehensive entitlement package must address zoning compliance, land use regulations, building codes, and other legal requirements to ensure a smooth approval process.

Key legal considerations include:

1. Zoning Compliance: Ensuring that the project aligns with the city's zoning regulations, including setbacks, height limits, and land use designations.

2. Public Benefit: Articulating the project's contribution to the public realm through amenities, open spaces, and community benefits.

3. Environmental Impact: Conducting thorough environmental assessments and addressing any potential impacts on natural resources, wildlife habitats, and water quality.

4. Community Engagement: Demonstrating meaningful engagement with local stakeholders, including residents, businesses, and community organizations, to solicit feedback and address concerns.

The Art of Presentation:

Crafting a compelling presentation is essential to effectively communicate the project's vision and merits to the UDRB. Utilizing a combination of visual aids, renderings, diagrams, and narrative descriptions, the presentation should articulate the project's design rationale, contextual response, and compliance with regulatory requirements.

In the dynamic realm of Miami's urban development, securing approval from the Urban Design Review Board (UDRB) stands as a pivotal step in bringing architectural visions to life. Comprising nine members and one alternate, all appointed by the city commission, including architects, urban planners, landscape architects, and community representatives, the UDRB holds the authority to approve Large-Scale Developments. At the helm of this esteemed board is the Director of Planning, whose role involves facilitating the review process, ensuring adherence to regulations, and ultimately granting project approval.

Requirements:

While the exact requirements for an entitlement package can vary depending on the specific project and Miami's zoning code, here are some general inclusions:

• Project Details: This section will outline the details of your development. It should include architectural drawings, floor plans, and detailed descriptions of the project's use (residential, commercial, etc.).
• Zoning Compliance Analysis: This section demonstrates how your project adheres to the existing zoning code for the area. It may include details like building height restrictions, setbacks from property lines, and permitted uses within the zone. Implement massing and setbacks to reference your conditions.
• Site Plans and Surveys: A detailed site plan outlining the project's footprint on the property and any necessary modifications is crucial. Additionally, a land survey will be required to establish property boundaries and potential environmental concerns.
• Traffic Impact Study: This study assesses the potential impact of your project on surrounding traffic flow and proposes mitigation strategies if necessary.
• Environmental Impact Assessment: Depending on the project's scale and location, an environmental impact assessment may be required. This would explore potential effects on wildlife, water quality, and overall ecological health.
• Financial Feasibility Analysis: This demonstrates the project's financial viability and its potential impact on the surrounding area.
• Architectural Plans: Detailed drawings and renderings illustrating the project's massing, scale, fa?ade treatment, and spatial layout.
• Site Analysis: An assessment of the project site's context, Photographs including surrounding buildings, streetscapes, and natural features.
• Narrative Description: A written narrative outlining the project's design concept, contextual response, and adherence to urban design guidelines.
• Visual Aids: Supplementary visual materials, such as diagrams, models, and digital presentations, to enhance the board's understanding of the project.

?Additional Considerations:

• Historical Impact Review: If your project involves a historic district or potentially impacts a historical site, a review by the city's historic preservation board may be needed.
• Public Comment Documentation: The entitlement package should document any public outreach or community meetings held regarding the project.

If your development requires a variance here are some tips!

Variance Requests in Miami's Entitlement Package Process

When your client's project requires a variance from Miami's zoning code, the entitlement package becomes even more crucial. Here's a breakdown of the process:

Understanding Variances:

A variance is a modification of a specific zoning code requirement. Common variances requested in Miami include:

• Lot size: The client's lot might be smaller than the minimum required by the zoning code for the specific use.
• Setbacks: Variances might be sought for setbacks from property lines, allowing for a building to be closer to the street or neighboring properties than typically permitted.
• Building Height: The project might exceed the maximum building height allowed in the zone.

Preparing the Entitlement Package:

For variances, the entitlement package becomes even more critical in demonstrating why the deviation from the code is necessary. Here's what to include:

• A Detailed Variance Request: Clearly outline the specific code provision from which a variance is requested and the extent of the deviation.
• Hardship Demonstration: Explain why adhering to the existing code would create an undue hardship for your client. This hardship should be specific to the property and not simply economic hardship. Examples of hardship could be: The lot size or shape makes strict adherence to setbacks impossible. The existing structure has historical significance and adhering to current setbacks would negatively impact its preservation.
• Alternatives Considered: Demonstrate that alternative designs that adhere to the code were explored and explain why they are not feasible.
• Compliance Plan: Outline how the project, even with the variance, will still comply with the overall intent and purpose of the zoning code and not negatively impact the surrounding area.
• Community Impact Assessment: Address how the project, with the variance, will benefit the community. This could involve increased green space, improved traffic flow, or revitalization of a neglected area.

The Approval Process:

• The UDRB will review the entitlement package, including the variance request, and hold a public hearing to receive community input.
• The Board will consider the hardship presented, the project's design merits, and its impact on the surrounding area before granting or denying the variance.

FAR Explained:

FAR (Floor Area Ratio) is a crucial aspect of development in Miami, and understanding its calculation is essential for preparing a successful entitlement package. Here's a breakdown of FAR based on the City of Miami codes and zoning: FAR is a numerical value that represents the total floor area of a building compared to the gross lot area. In simpler terms, it tells you how much building you can construct on a specific piece of land.

Finding Your FAR Requirements:

Miami's zoning code, Miami 21, dictates the maximum FAR allowed for different zoning districts. Here's how to find the FAR requirements for your project:

1. Identify Your Zoning District: As mentioned earlier, Miami 21 divides the city into various zoning classifications (e.g., T6, D2). You'll need to determine the specific zone applicable to your project's location. This information can be found through property records or zoning maps provided by the city.
2. Consult Miami 21: Once you know your zoning district, refer to the Miami 21 code (specifically Article 6 - Supplemental Regulations) This section outlines the allowed uses and corresponding maximum FAR for each district.
3. Mixed-Use Projects: For mixed-use projects, the FAR might be calculated separately for each use type (residential, commercial, etc.) based on the regulations for each category.

Additional Considerations:

• Exceptions and Bonuses: Miami 21 might offer exceptions or bonuses that increase the allowable FAR under certain circumstances. These could be related to affordable housing inclusion, sustainable building practices, or historic preservation efforts. Exploring these options can maximize your project's potential.
• Calculating Gross Lot Area: The gross lot area is the entire area of your property, excluding public rights-of-way like sidewalks and streets. Knowing this value is crucial for calculating the FAR.
• Professional Help: Due to the complexities of zoning codes and FAR calculations, consulting with an architect or engineer familiar with Miami's regulations is highly recommended. They can ensure your project adheres to the FAR limitations for your specific zoning district and maximize the usable building space.

Miami's parking regulations and how to find the specifics for your project:

Miami's Zoning Code (Miami 21):

The foundation for parking requirements lies within the Miami 21 zoning code, specifically Article 4. This section outlines minimum parking requirements for various uses.

Finding Your Specific Requirements:

How to navigate the code to find the parking requirements for your mixed-use project:

1. Identify the Project's Zoning Classification: Miami 21 divides the city into different zoning classifications (e.g., T6, D2). You'll need to determine the specific zone applicable to your project's location.
2. Mixed-Use Calculations: Since your project is mixed-use, you'll need to calculate the parking requirements for each use type (residential, commercial, etc.) The code outlines minimum parking requirements per unit or square footage for each use category.
3. Accessible Parking: Miami 21 also mandates a specific percentage of parking spaces be designated as accessible. This information is typically included within the general parking requirements for each use category.
4. Loading Areas: The code might have separate regulations for loading areas, specifying the number and dimensions required based on the project's anticipated use.
5. Street Parking & Visitor Parking: Miami 21 primarily focuses on on-site parking provisions. Street parking availability and its impact on your project would likely require separate research into the specific area's parking regulations.

While the code provides the minimum requirements, it's important to note that developers can choose to exceed these minimums.

Miami's parking regulations differ between regular areas and Transit Oriented Development (TOD) zones.

Regular Areas:

• Minimum Parking Requirements: Miami's zoning code dictates minimum parking requirements based on the type of development (residential, commercial, etc.). These requirements can be quite strict, often mandating a specific number of parking spaces per unit or square footage of commercial space.
• Limited On-Street Parking: On-street parking in popular Miami areas can be scarce and often comes with metered fees or permit requirements.
• Parking Garages: Many developments in regular areas incorporate private parking garages to meet the mandated minimums. This can add significant cost to the project.

Transit Oriented Development (TOD) Zones:

• Reduced Parking Requirements: Recognizing the emphasis on alternative transportation in TOD areas, Miami's zoning code often offers reduced minimum parking requirements for these projects. This allows for more efficient use of space and potentially lowers development costs.
• Shared Parking: TOD zones might encourage shared parking arrangements between residential and commercial uses within the development. This maximizes space utilization and reduces the overall number of parking spaces needed.
• Focus on Alternative Transportation: TOD regulations might incentivize developers to prioritize bike storage, electric vehicle charging stations, and convenient access to public transportation options within the project.

?Additional Considerations:

• Parking Studies: While TOD zones offer reduced parking requirements, a parking study might still be required in the entitlement package. This study would analyze potential parking demand and demonstrate how the project accommodates it through a combination of on-site parking, alternative transportation options, and proximity to public transit.
• Impact on Residents: The entitlement package should address how reduced parking will impact residents. Will there be car-sharing programs offered? Is there ample bike storage? These details are crucial to demonstrate a well-rounded approach to transportation within the TOD project.

Understanding these contrasting regulations is key when crafting an entitlement package. In regular areas, the focus is on meeting the minimum parking requirements, often through on-site garages. In TOD zones, the emphasis shifts towards alternative transportation options and potentially reduced parking needs. By highlighting the benefits of TOD and demonstrating a well-conceived plan for accommodating transportation within the project, you can strengthen your client's entitlement package for a TOD project in Miami.

Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) and the Miami Entitlement Package: A Match Made in Mobility

Miami is a city on the move, and transit-oriented development (TOD) is at the forefront of its future. When your client's project embraces TOD principles, it strengthens the entitlement package and unlocks a multitude of benefits for both the project and the city.

TOD Benefits for Miami's Entitlement Process:

• Alignment with City Goals: Miami has ambitious plans to improve public transportation and walkability. A TOD project demonstrates alignment with these goals, making it more attractive to the UDRB.
• Reduced Traffic Impact: TOD projects encourage car-free living, reducing traffic congestion, a major concern in Miami. This can be a significant advantage during the entitlement review process.
• Increased Density with a Purpose: TOD projects often involve denser development near transit hubs. The entitlement package can highlight how this density translates into a vibrant, walkable community, appealing to the UDRB's desire for well-designed urban spaces.

Beyond the Entitlement Process: Additional TOD Benefits

• Economic Boost: TOD projects attract residents, businesses, and investment, stimulating the local economy. The entitlement package can showcase how the project will contribute to Miami's economic growth.
• Environmental Sustainability: TOD projects reduce car dependence, leading to lower greenhouse gas emissions. Highlighting these environmental benefits strengthens the project's overall appeal.
• Enhanced Quality of Life: TOD creates walkable, pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods with easy access to public transportation, shops, and amenities. This improves residents' quality of life, a key factor for the UDRB.

Examples of TOD Elements to Showcase in the Entitlement Package:

• Mixed-Use Development: Residential units integrated with retail, office space, and restaurants within walking distance.
• Pedestrian-Friendly Design: Wide sidewalks, bike lanes, and street trees that create a welcoming environment for walkers and cyclists.
• Proximity to Transit: Easy access to bus stops, metro stations, or other forms of public transportation.

By incorporating TOD principles and highlighting these benefits in the entitlement package, your client's project can gain a significant edge in the UDRB approval process. Remember, a TOD project not only benefits the developer but also contributes to a more vibrant, sustainable, and mobile Miami.

Additional Considerations:

• Legal Counsel: Involving a legal professional with expertise in Miami's zoning code is highly recommended. They can guide you through the variance process, ensure your request is properly documented, and represent your client during the public hearing.
• Public Relations: Proactive community outreach can be beneficial. Explain the project's merits and the rationale behind the variance request to garner community support.

The UDRB Review Process:

The journey towards UDRB approval begins with a meticulously prepared presentation that outlines the project's architectural design, contextual integration, and compliance with zoning regulations. During the presentation, developers and architects are given the opportunity to showcase their vision, addressing concerns and engaging in dialogue with the board members.

The Vote Process:

Following the presentation, the board members engage in a thorough review, evaluating the project based on design quality, contextual relevance, and adherence to regulatory requirements. A majority vote is required for project approval, with each member's perspective contributing to the decision-making process.

Levels of Approval:

In the event of approval, the project moves forward to subsequent stages of the entitlement process, including permitting and construction. However, if the project is denied, developers have the option to revise and resubmit their proposal, addressing the concerns raised by the board members.

Booking Your Presentation:

To book a presentation with the UDRB, developers must submit a formal application to the City of Miami's Planning Department. The application should include a comprehensive package that outlines the project's details, including architectural plans, site analyses, renderings, and a narrative description of the design rationale.

Additional Considerations:

• Entitlement Package: While the code outlines minimums, the entitlement package can propose alternative parking solutions, especially for TOD projects. A parking study might be required to demonstrate how the project accommodates parking needs with reduced on-site spaces and a focus on alternative transportation.
• Professional Help: For a mixed-use project, consulting with an architect or engineer familiar with Miami's zoning code is highly recommended. They can help you navigate the code, calculate the specific parking requirements for your project, and ensure your entitlement package adheres to all regulations.

?

Pro Tips for a Winning UDRB Entitlement Package in the city of Miami

From my experience, I highly recommend following these 5 tips.

Miami's melting pot of design flair and legal complexities can make navigating the UDRB process daunting. But fear not, intrepid developer! Here are some unique tips to craft an entitlement package that shines under the Miami sun:

1. Know Your Audience: Miami's UDRB is keen on projects that not only meet code but also elevate the city's architectural identity. Research past projects that have been approved to understand the design aesthetic the board favors.

2. Design with Context in Mind: Miami's architectural landscape is a beautiful tapestry of old and new. Highlight how your project complements the surrounding area, whether it's incorporating design elements from neighboring historical structures or creating a harmonious contrast with modern materials.

3. Embrace Transparency: Miami residents are passionate about their city. Be proactive and engage with the surrounding community early on. Include a well-documented public outreach section in your entitlement package, showcasing how you've incorporated community feedback into your design.

4. Think Green from the Get-Go: Sustainability is a major concern in Miami. Showcase how your project incorporates green building practices, such as using recycled materials, optimizing energy efficiency, and incorporating green spaces.

5. Tell a Story: Don't just submit a dry packet of legalese. Craft a compelling narrative that tells the story of your project. Explain how it will benefit the community and add vibrancy to Miami's urban fabric.

Bonus Tip: Assemble a Dream Team: Miami is full of talented designers and legal professionals. Put together a team that understands the city's design sensibilities and the intricacies of the UDRB process, as it is not an easy task. Their combined expertise will be your strongest asset.

By following these tips and tailoring them to your specific project, you can create an entitlement package that stands out from the crowd and secures that coveted UDRB approval. Remember, a successful package is about more than just checking boxes; it's about showcasing your vision for a project that enriches Miami's unique identity.

Resources related to the UDRB entitlement package in Miami:

• City of Miami Zoning Code:

https://www.miami.gov/Planning-Zoning-Land-Use/View-City-of-Miami-Zoning-Code-Miami-21

• Urban Development Review Board (UDRB) Information:

https://www.miami.gov/My-Government/Boards-Committees/Urban-Development-Review-Board-UDRB

• Miami Historic Preservation Board:

https://www.miami.gov/My-Government/Departments/Planning/Historic-Preservation-Main-Page (Relevant if your project is in a historic district)

• Miami-Dade County Planning Department:

https://www.miami.gov/planning

Note: The City of Miami website doesn't have a webpage explicitly outlining general entitlement package requirements. However, the Zoning Code (https://www.miami.gov/Planning-Zoning-Land-Use/View-City-of-Miami-Zoning-Code-Miami-21) provides a foundation for understanding what the entitlement package should address. For specific requirements, it's advisable to consult with a professional with expertise in Miami's zoning code.

?

Conclusion:

In the dynamic landscape of Miami's urban development, navigating the UDRB approval process requires a delicate balance of architectural innovation and legal expertise. By integrating design excellence with a thorough understanding of regulatory requirements, developers and architects can create compelling UDRB and entitlement packages that resonate with stakeholders and secure approval in the first presentation submittal. As guardians of Miami's urban identity, the UDRB plays a vital role in shaping the city's future, ensuring that each new development contributes positively to its vibrant tapestry of culture, history, and innovation.

?

Thank You for Building Miami's Future!

I hope this article empowered you to navigate the UDRB process and translate your architectural vision into reality. Remember, a successful project goes beyond approvals; it contributes to the vibrant tapestry of Miami's urban landscape.

Do you have questions about the UDRB process, FAR calculations, or crafting a winning entitlement package? Are you seeking a design partner who understands Miami's unique identity and can help you create a project that leaves a lasting positive impact?

Feel free to reach out to me!

Let's collaborate and turn your Miami development dreams into a reality.

All the Best

Agustin Salas

?