Mastering Code Reviews: Best Practices, Common Mistakes, and Pro Tips

Code reviews are a cornerstone of modern software development. They ensure code quality, foster collaboration, and help developers grow. However, reviewing JavaScript code can be tricky, especially when dealing with dynamic typing, asynchronous operations, and complex frameworks.

In this article, we’ll dive deep into JavaScript code reviews, covering common mistakes, best practices, and pro tips to help you become a more effective reviewer. Whether you’re a junior developer or a seasoned pro, this guide will equip you with the knowledge to write and review cleaner, more maintainable JavaScript code.

Why Code Reviews Matter

Before we dive into the technical details, let’s understand why code reviews are so important:

1. Improve Code Quality: Catch bugs, anti-patterns, and performance issues early.
2. Share Knowledge: Team members learn from each other’s code and approaches.
3. Maintain Consistency: Ensure the codebase follows consistent patterns and standards.
4. Foster Collaboration: Build a culture of trust and teamwork.

Now, let’s get into the nitty-gritty of JavaScript code reviews.

Common Mistakes in JavaScript Code Reviews

1. Missing Error Handling

JavaScript’s dynamic nature makes it prone to runtime errors. A common mistake is forgetting to handle errors properly.

Example:

function processOrder(order) {
    if (order.status === 'Paid') {
        order.status = 'Shipped';
        console.log(`Order ${order.id} is now Shipped.`);
    }
}        

Issues:

• No error handling. If order is null or undefined, the app will crash.
• Hardcoded status strings make the code error-prone.

Fixed Version:

function processOrder(order) {
    if (!order) {
        console.error('Order is null or undefined.');
        return;
    }

try {
        switch (order.status) {
            case 'Paid':
                order.status = 'Shipped';
                console.log(`Order ${order.id} is now Shipped.`);
                break;
            default:
                console.warn(`Unknown status for order ${order.id}: ${order.status}`);
        }
    } catch (error) {
        console.error(`Error processing order ${order.id}:`, error);
    }
}        

Key Takeaways:

• Always validate inputs.
• Use try-catch blocks for error handling.
• Avoid hardcoding values; use constants or enums.

2. Tightly Coupled Code

Tightly coupled code is hard to test and maintain. Here’s an example:

Example:

class OrderService {
    constructor() {
        this.paymentService = new PaymentService();
    }

      processOrder(order) {
              this.paymentService.processPayment(order);
          }
      }        

Issue:

• OrderService is tightly coupled to PaymentService.

Fixed Version:

class OrderService {
    constructor(paymentService) {
        this.paymentService = paymentService;
    }
    processOrder(order) {
            this.paymentService.processPayment(order);
        }
    }        

Key Takeaways:

• Use dependency injection to decouple classes.
• This makes your code more testable and flexible.

3. Magic Numbers

Magic numbers are hardcoded values that make code difficult to understand and maintain.

Example:

function calculateTax(income) {
    if (income <= 50000) return income * 0.10;
    if (income <= 100000) return income * 0.15;
    if (income <= 200000) return income * 0.20;
    return income * 0.30;
}        

Fixed Version:

const TAX_RATES = [
    { limit: 50000, rate: 0.10 },
    { limit: 100000, rate: 0.15 },
    { limit: 200000, rate: 0.20 },
    { limit: Infinity, rate: 0.30 }
];

  function calculateTax(income) {
      const { rate } = TAX_RATES.find(({ limit }) => income <= limit);
      return income * rate;
  }        

Key Takeaways:

• Replace magic numbers with constants or configuration objects.
• This makes the code easier to update and understand.

Best Practices for JavaScript Code Reviews

1. Follow the DRY Principle

DRY (Don’t Repeat Yourself) is a fundamental principle of clean code. Avoid duplicating logic.

Example:

class DiscountCalculator {
    calculateDiscount(amount, discountPercentage) {
        const discount = amount * discountPercentage;
        return amount - discount;
    }

    applyDiscount(amount, discountPercentage) {
            const discount = amount * discountPercentage;
            return amount - discount;
        }
    }        

Issue:

• The same logic is repeated in two methods.

Fixed Version:

class DiscountCalculator {
    calculateDiscount(amount, discountPercentage) {
        return this.calculateDiscountedAmount(amount, discountPercentage);
    }

    applyDiscount(amount, discountPercentage) {
        const discount = this.calculateDiscountedAmount(amount, discountPercentage);
        return amount - discount;
    }

    calculateDiscountedAmount(amount, discountPercentage) {
        return amount * discountPercentage;
    }
}        

Key Takeaways:

• Extract repeated logic into a separate method.
• This reduces redundancy and makes the code easier to maintain.

2. Apply the YAGNI Principle

YAGNI (You Aren’t Gonna Need It) encourages you to avoid over-engineering.

Example:

Think about this Requirement

Implement a discount system for orders based on a predefined discount rate. The discount should be calculated as a percentage of the order amount, and the final price should reflect the discount applied.

class OrderProcessor {
    processOrder(order, discount) {
        const discountAmount = this.calculateDiscount(order, discount);
        let finalAmount = order.amount - discountAmount;

        if (order.couponCode) {
                    const couponDiscount = this.applyCoupon(order.couponCodeDiscount);
                    finalAmount -= couponDiscount;
                }
            }
            calculateDiscount(order, discount) {
                return order.amount * discount;
            }
            applyCoupon(couponCodeDiscount) {
                return order.amount * couponCodeDiscount;
            }
        }        

Issue:

• The applyCoupon method is unnecessary if coupon handling isn’t a requirement.

Fixed Version:

class OrderProcessor {
    processOrder(order, discount) {
        const discountAmount = this.calculateDiscount(order, discount);
        const finalAmount = order.amount - discountAmount;
        console.log(`Final Amount: ${finalAmount}`);
    }

    calculateDiscount(order, discount) {
            return order.amount * discount;
        }
    }        

Key Takeaways:

• Only implement what’s needed right now.
• Avoid over-engineering and keep your code simple.

Pro Tips for Effective Code Reviews

1. Be Respectful: Focus on the code, not the person.
2. Be Constructive: Suggest improvements instead of just pointing out flaws.
3. Ask Questions: Understand the reasoning behind the code.
4. Stay Open-Minded: Be willing to accept different approaches.
5. Respect Time: Provide timely and concise feedback.

Conclusion

JavaScript code reviews are an art and a science. By spotting common mistakes, following best practices, and adopting a collaborative mindset, you can significantly improve the quality of your codebase. Remember, the goal of a code review isn’t to criticize but to learn, grow, and build better software together.

Now it’s your turn! What are your go-to practices during code reviews? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Buy me a Coffee?

If you enjoy this content and want to support me, feel free to [buy me a coffee].