The Market Reaction to the Federal Reserve Rate Cuts

S&P 500 and Dow Jones Dip As Unexpected Result of Fed Rate Cut

Executive Summary

The Federal Reserve implemented a 50 basis point interest rate cut on September 18, 2024, the first reduction in four years. Key highlights include:

• The federal funds rate was adjusted to a range between 4.75% and 5%.
• Market reaction was unexpectedly negative, with all three major U.S. market indices declining.
• Factors contributing to the negative reaction included long-term rate projections, higher terminal rate expectations, and concerns about labor market data reliability.
• The S&P 500 decreased by 0.29%, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell by 0.25%.
• Expert opinions varied, with some praising the Fed's proactive stance and others expressing concerns about recession risks.
• Fed Chair Jerome Powell emphasized confidence in the labor market and stated no heightened risk of recession.
• The rate cut had implications for global markets, with European and Asian markets reacting cautiously.

?

The Fed Rate Cut: An In-Depth Analysis and Market Impact

On September 18, 2024, the Federal Reserve implemented a significant 50 basis point interest rate cut, marking the first rate reduction in four years. This move ended the longest cycle of rate hikes in recent history, reflecting the Fed's strategic shift in monetary policy to address current economic conditions. Despite being anticipated by investors, the rate cut led to mixed and volatile market reactions. This article provides an in-depth discussion of the rate cut's impact on the market, particularly focusing on the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA).

?

The Rate Cut Decision

The Federal Reserve's decision to cut interest rates by 50 basis points was perceived as a dovish move, indicating a proactive stance to support economic stability amidst uncertainties. This decision aligns with the Fed's broader strategy to recalibrate monetary policy in response to evolving economic conditions, including concerns about inflation and labor market stability. The federal funds rate was adjusted to a range between 4.75% and 5% (CNBC, September 18, 2024).

?

Market Reaction

Contrary to initial expectations that a rate cut would provide a boost to the market, the reaction was surprisingly negative. After a brief surge following the announcement, markets experienced highly erratic trading, leading to declines in all three major U.S. market indices by the end of the day:

• Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA): Fell by 0.25%.
• S&P 500: Decreased by 0.29%.
• Nasdaq Composite: Sank by 0.31%.

This negative reaction can be attributed to various factors that influenced investor sentiment.

?

Reasons for Negative Market Reaction

Several key factors contributed to the negative market reaction:

1. Long-term Rate Projections: The Fed's Summary of Economic Projections indicated two additional 25 basis point cuts this year and another 100 basis points in 2025 (Euronews, September 19, 2024). However, these projections did not align with investor expectations for a transition to a less restrictive or neutral policy, causing concerns about an impending recession.
2. Higher Terminal Rate: The long-term rate continues to be adjusted upward, suggesting a higher terminal rate. This implies that while the immediate 50 basis point cut was dovish, there are no indications of more significant cuts on the horizon.
3. Perception of Being Behind the Curve: Some experts believe that the substantial rate cut signifies an acknowledgment that the Fed should have initiated cuts earlier. Fed Chair Jerome Powell addressed these concerns, stating that the Fed does not believe it is behind, but many experts remain skeptical.
4. Labor Market Data Reliability: The reliability of labor market data has been questioned, particularly after revisions indicated that the U.S. economy had 818,000 fewer jobs from March 2023 to March 2024 than previously thought. This has led to doubts about the accuracy of the data driving the Fed's decisions.

?

Expert Opinions

The varied opinions among experts likely contributed to the market's volatility:

• Rick Rieder, BlackRock: Rieder noted that the market has priced in a rate path that resembles what would be necessary during an impending recession, rather than a transition to a less restrictive policy (Washington Post, September 18, 2024).
• Thomas Simons, Jefferies: Simons echoed this outlook, stating that the long-run rate continues to be revised up, implying a higher terminal rate and no signs of more big cuts coming (CBS News, September 18, 2024).
• Jay Hatfield, Infrastructure Capital Advisors: Hatfield praised the Fed's decision, saying it was the first time since the pandemic that the Fed took decisive action to stay ahead of the curve by cutting rates to prevent the economy from slipping into recession (CNBC, September 18, 2024).

?

Powell's Comments

Fed Chair Jerome Powell's comments during the press conference also influenced market sentiment:

• Confidence in Labor Market: Powell emphasized that the rate cut was meant to demonstrate officials' confidence in the labor market's strength and its ability to continue with an appropriate recalibration of monetary policy.
• No Recession Indication: Powell reassured that he does not see anything in the current economy that suggests a heightened risk of a recession or downturn.
• Neutral Rate: Powell's comment that the neutral rate is probably significantly higher than it was before the pandemic could have exacerbated the sell-off, as investors are looking for clarity on where interest rates might land in the long term.

?

Asset Analysis: S&P 500 and Dow Jones

The S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) are two of the most closely watched indices in financial markets. Here's how they were impacted by the Fed's rate cut:

S&P 500

The S&P 500, which comprises 500 of the largest publicly traded companies in the U.S., saw a decrease of 0.29% following the rate cut announcement. The index's performance reflects broader concerns about future economic conditions and investor uncertainty regarding long-term interest rates. Key sectors within the S&P 500, such as technology and financials, were particularly sensitive to changes in interest rates. The tech-heavy nature of this index means it is more vulnerable to shifts in monetary policy as higher rates can increase borrowing costs and compress profit margins for tech companies (CNBC, September 18, 2024).

Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA)

The DJIA, consisting of 30 large publicly traded companies in various sectors, fell by 0.25%. The DJIA's decline can be attributed to similar factors affecting the S&P 500, with added pressure from industrial and consumer-facing companies that may experience tighter profit margins due to higher borrowing costs and potential decreases in consumer spending power. Additionally, companies within the DJIA that are sensitive to global economic conditions might also have reacted negatively due to concerns about international trade and economic stability (Washington Post, September 18, 2024).

?

Global Market Implications

The Fed's rate cut also had implications for global markets. European and Asian markets reacted with caution as invest ors weighed the potential for further monetary easing by other central banks in response to the Fed's actions. The interconnected nature of global financial markets means that significant policy shifts by the Federal Reserve can lead to ripple effects worldwide (Euronews, September 19, 2024).

?

Conclusion

The Federal Reserve's decision to implement a 50 basis point rate cut on September 18, 2024, was a significant move aimed at bolstering economic stability amidst uncertainties. However, the market's negative reaction underscores the complexities and uncertainties surrounding monetary policy decisions. The mismatch between immediate rate cuts and longer-term projections, coupled with skepticism about labor market data reliability and perceptions of being behind the curve, contributed to volatile trading observed across major indices like the S&P 500 and DJIA. As investors continue to process these developments, it remains crucial to monitor how these factors will influence future economic and market trends.

?

Being able to produce high quality market commentary is vital for writers in the financial services sector. However, personalising said market commentary for each intended audience can be very time consuming. Daizy Scribe brings a suite of generative AI tools for writers in the financial services space that produce personalised, compliant, and accurate writing. With help from Daizy Scribe I was able to produce this article in minutes. If you are interested in how Daizy could revolutionise your workflow, check out our website here!

?

This document was created by Daizy using institutional-grade data and in collaboration with several external Large Language Models. All calculations were performed by the Daizy LLM Analytics Service. The contents of this document do not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice, and Daizy (Vesti.ai Ltd) is not authorized to give any advice. [Please refer to our terms of use.]