Managing Redundancies and Restructuring: A Guide for Senior Executives with Management Role

Welcome to my latest LinkedIn newsletter! In each issue, I will be sharing Employment Law insights on important topics with my connections and followers.?

In today’s competitive and unpredictable business environment, managing redundancies and restructuring can be among the most challenging tasks a senior executive with management responsibilities faces.

It is almost inevitable that at some point in your career, you will be asked to make members of your team redundant. Some of these team members you will have worked with for many years and indeed may have socialised with outside of work and consider as friends.

As your employer's agent, you will be tasked with placing them in one of the most difficult and distressing positions in their working lives. How you navigate this can have lasting impacts not only on your organisation's stability and reputation but also on your own professional relationships and reputation in the industry.

Whether driven by financial pressures, market shifts, or strategic realignment, these processes are fraught with legal and emotional complexities. This guide offers insights not only on ensuring legal compliance and strategies for handling redundancies and restructuring effectively but also provides some tips for managing your relationships with exiting staff and, importantly, those who will remain following a restructuring.

Legal Compliance: The Fundamentals of Any Redundancy Scenario

Before you and the organisation make any decisions, it’s crucial to understand the legal framework governing redundancies in the UK. Failure to comply with these laws can lead to claims of unfair dismissal, discrimination, or breach of contract, all of which can be costly and damaging to you and your organisation's reputation.

Understand the Definition of Redundancy

Redundancy occurs when an employer needs to reduce their workforce because a role is no longer required due to business closure, relocation, or a reduced need for particular skills. It's essential to ensure that the reasons for redundancy are genuine and not a cover for other issues, such as poor performance or personality conflicts.

Consultation Process

Legally, you are required to engage in a consultation process with employees at risk of redundancy. In all redundancy situations, you should hold individual consultation meetings with affected employees and, where 20 or more redundancies are contemplated, collective consultation with employee representatives or trade unions is also mandatory and must begin at least 30 days before any dismissals. During consultations, transparency is key.

Best Practice:

Clearly communicate the reasons for the proposed redundancies, the selection process, and any alternatives to redundancy. While you may feel the outcome is inevitable, you need to listen to employee feedback and consider any suggestions that may avoid or reduce the need to make their role redundant. Failure to do so will not only open up challenges that the consultation process is not genuine but will also create suspicion and, as a result, irrecoverably damage the trust going forward.

Fair Selection Criteria

If redundancies are necessary, you must apply fair and, importantly objective selection criteria. These may include factors such as performance, skills, qualifications, and length of service. Avoid criteria that could be seen as discriminatory, such as age, gender, or disability, or sick days, family leave or other criteria that put some employees at a disadvantage to others for example those with care responsibilities or part-time workers.

Best Practice:

Engage HR early to ensure your criteria are legally sound and aligned with best practices. Ensure the rationale for the selection criteria is clearly established, for example, skills needed to ‘future proof’ the organisation, reflecting business strategy going forward or areas or products the organisation is seeking to develop. Regularly review the selection criteria throughout the consultation process to reflect valid challenges, and carry out an audit of the selection process prior to making any final decision to ensure consistency and fairness.

Handling Redundancies: Strategies for delivering a difficult decision

Managing redundancies goes beyond legal compliance; it's also about maintaining morale, protecting your brand, and ensuring a smooth transition for those leaving and those staying.

Negotiating Exit Terms

When discussing exit terms with affected employees, it's important to handle negotiations sensitively and fairly. This includes:

Redundancy Pay:

Ensure you offer statutory redundancy pay at a minimum and consider whether enhanced packages are appropriate. An enhanced package will help support redundant employees during this difficult and normally unexpected period, giving them breathing space and time to search for a new job.

Better still, having a pre-agreed enhanced redundancy pay policy, (usually in exchange for signature of a settlement agreement) will ease financial worries from the outset and likely allow the process to come to an early resolution, allowing employees to focus on finding their next role.

When considering enhanced redundancy termination payments, it's important to remember that payments up to ￡30,000 are generally viewed as tax-free. Employees are likely to focus on how much money will be in their hands when their employment ends, so this should be explained to them.

Bonuses and Shares:

Clarify the status of any unpaid bonuses or unvested share options. While these are often tied to employment status, negotiation around partial payouts or other arrangements, such as accelerated vesting, can demonstrate goodwill and protect your reputation.

Other Benefits:

Consider extending healthcare, counselling, or outplacement services to support employees through the transition.

Best Practice:

Involve legal and HR advisors in these discussions to ensure that any agreements are legally binding and fair.

Managing Professional Relationships and Reputation

How you manage redundancies will significantly impact your and your organisation's professional relationships and reputation. To minimise the negative impact:

Communicate Transparently:

Keep lines of communication open with all stakeholders, including remaining employees, customers, and partners. Clear, honest communication helps manage uncertainty and maintains trust.

Support for Departing Employees:

Offer comprehensive outplacement services to help redundant employees find new roles. This can include career counselling, CV writing services, and interview coaching.

Reputation Management:

Consider the broader impact of redundancies on your employer brand. Engaging with media and industry peers to frame the redundancies within the context of broader business challenges can help protect your and the company’s reputation.

Other terms:

Consider the psychological impact of the redundancy on the employee. Consider offering mutually agreed internal and external announcements so they feel they have an element of control over the narrative of their leaving.

Enforce only what is needed:

Consider placing the employee on garden leave so they have time and mental space to make plans for the future. Consider relaxing restrictive covenants to provide them with greater access to the market and limit the financial implications of an unanticipated termination of their employment.?

Maintaining Morale Among Remaining Employees

Redundancies can create fear and uncertainty among the remaining workforce, which can lead to decreased productivity and morale. To mitigate this:

Clear Communication:

After redundancies are announced, clearly communicate the rationale and the future direction of the company. Ensure that remaining employees understand their roles in the company’s future.

Employee Support:

Offer counselling services or employee assistance programs to those affected by the redundancies, both directly and indirectly. Recognise the emotional toll that these processes can have on everyone involved.

Rebuilding Trust:

Invest time in rebuilding trust and morale. This might include team-building activities, revisiting company values, and ensuring that any further changes are managed transparently.

Managing Career Prospects and Personal Reputation

As a senior executive, your role in managing redundancies and restructuring will be closely scrutinised. How you handle these situations can have a lasting impact on your career prospects and personal reputation.

Act with Integrity

Making difficult decisions with empathy and integrity will earn you respect from both within and outside the organisation. Uphold your values, even when facing tough choices, and be consistent in your approach.

Seek External Support

It’s wise to seek advice from mentors, peers, or even professional coaches during these processes. They can offer a different perspective and help you navigate the emotional challenges of managing redundancies.

Learn and Reflect

After the process is complete, take time to reflect on what went well and what could have been done differently. Learning from these experiences will not only improve your future decision-making but also demonstrate your commitment to continuous improvement.

Conclusion: Balancing Business Needs with Compassion

Managing redundancies and restructuring is never easy, but it’s a critical part of ensuring your organisation’s long-term success. Remember, how you handle these situations will shape not only the future of not only your organisation but also your legacy as a leader. Balancing business needs with empathy and integrity will ensure that you lead through these challenges with professionalism and care.

Feel free to Get In Touch if you are an employee experiencing problems at work, [email protected]

For more information on my employment law practice see my Penningtons profile here. https://bit.ly/RubyDinsmore ..

You can also find more information on the advice we at Penningtons provide for senior executives here: https://bit.ly/Senior-Executive-Employment

Ruby Dinsmore Employment Lawyer (UK)

Thanks for reading, and please subscribe. I'd love to know your thoughts in the comments below. If you enjoy my content, then follow me.

?