Make pragmatism great again
Photo by Caleb Perez | Unsplash

Make pragmatism great again

What Could Go Right? is a free weekly newsletter from?The Progress Network?written by our executive director, Emma Varvaloucas. In addition to this newsletter, which collects substantive progress news from around the world, The Progress Network publishes an?anti-apocalypse conversational podcast also called What Could Go Right?.

Make pragmatism great again

Ten Republicans and ten Democrats have struck a deal on a gun safety framework. The deal, which is a guide for legislation hopefully?to be passed before July 4, includes the following, taken from?The Trace’s explainer?here:

  • Funding for mental health services as well as safety measures and violence prevention efforts in schools
  • Closing the “boyfriend loophole,” which means romantic partners convicted of misdemeanor domestic abuse or under restraining orders will not be able to pass background checks for guns
  • Expanding who is required to register as a firearms dealer, like sellers at gun shows
  • Enhanced background checks, including juvenile and mental health records, for gun purchasers under 21, as well as a waiting period
  • Model red-flag laws and incentives to pass them, “which allow for courts to temporarily take firearms from people who pose a threat to themselves or others”
  • Increased penalties for interstate gun trafficking and straw purchasing (when someone purchases a gun on behalf of another who cannot)

Click the second link above for more detail; it’s both clear and brief.

The legislation has to be written and passed, of course, so it’s not a sure thing, but as Isaac Saul, writer of the nonpartisan newsletter?Tangle?wrote in his coverage, “We don't have the text, but we have a fairly good idea of how it will be written. . . . Most of the language that is going to be in this bill will be pulled from previous gun bills and mental health funding from the past. None of this is new material, and none of this is a new debate.” While some of our Democratic readers might see this as a negative—nothing new here!—we see it as a positive. Familiar language means a smaller chance that the passing of the legislation won’t get killed by details. Meanwhile, Senate minority leader?Mitch McConnell has expressed support, so that’s another good omen.

When we posted news of the agreement on social media, many of the comments expressed disappointment that the legislation would not include the kinds of reforms certain European countries passed in the wake of their own shootings, like an all-out ban on handguns or assault rifles. Many wrote that the deal was “not enough.”

We understand this point of view. But we’d also like to point out that despite all the comparisons, the United States is not Europe. The United States is unlike?any?other nation when it comes to guns, actually, because no other country protects the right to bear arms in its founding document. The dialogue gets paralyzed when it isn’t properly understood that banning guns, for many, many American constituents, is quite simply a no-go. So the deal may not be everything the Democrats wanted—and?Republicans have their own concerns—but public support of many of the individual items included in it?is high?and cuts across political affiliation. Why would we not cheer that on? Many of us decry polarization and the fact that our politicians can’t get anything done but then refuse to see when we are contributing to the problem. If we want more cooperation among our elected representatives, we should support them when they actually do it.

No alt text provided for this image

In the spirit of dialogue,?this podcast?from Substacker Bari Weiss brought together conservative and gun owner David French with Barnard College professor Rajiv Sethi, who researches gun violence and has no particular love for the Second Amendment. (“I wouldn’t shed any tears if we got rid of [it],” he says.) The last third of the conversation presents solutions from a place of common ground. Many of them are ones that are actually in the Senate’s proposal, and they also discuss others like smart guns and civil penalties for not keeping a gun safely stored. The solutions are in the last 25 minutes, but the entire conversation is interesting, including their thoughts on an “honest” argument for repealing the Second Amendment.?

At the end, Weiss asks what each would say to Democrats and Republicans when it comes to the gun debate. “The enemy is maximalism,” French replies. The Democrats come to the table with “maximum demand.” The Republicans come with “maximum resistance.” Meanwhile, the American people “are anguished that we can’t pass anything.”

This is why supporting this Senate deal, from a perspective that counts less gun violence as the major indicator of progress, makes eminent sense to us. Folks, let’s get this deal?signed, sealed, and delivered.?

Before we go

More young women are refusing genital cutting ceremonies in Sierra Leone, at great personal cost to themselves. While there is no ban there, it is “one of the few places where the practice seems to be showing a sustained decline.”?Do read this one.

Timbuktu’s tourism industry was devastated when Islamist jihadis took over parts of the country in 2012, leading to years of instability and violence. There’s a really fun way to help former tourist guides, though, without leaving your house—send someone you love?a postcard from Timbuktu. We can’t wait to try this!?

Want to live past 90? Keep reading this newsletter. Research shows that?optimists live longer. Want to develop an optimistic mindset? It may go?hand and hand with developing a patriotic one.?

Another win for Pride Month. “The Defense Department has officially ended a 1980s-era policy that restricted HIV-positive service members from deploying overseas and being promoted into leadership and management positions.”

Below in the links section,?scientists are performing experiments remotely in robot-powered labs, Ukrainians are using 3D scanning tech to preserve their?cultural heritage, and more.

Emma Varvaloucas

New from The Progress Network

Facing America's Biggest Challenges | S2 Ep. 12

No alt text provided for this image

After a string of heartbreaking news in the United States, are we doomed to fear, anger, and a descent into gridlocked politics? Today, Judge Victoria Pratt, an advocate for reforming the criminal justice system, and Lauren Leader, the cofounder and CEO of All In Together, discuss America's biggest challenges and how each have enacted change in large, complex systems.?|?Listen to the episode

Lauren Leader:?

You go on your phone in the morning, and it's the polar bears, and it's the crime rate, and it's Covid-19, and it's the shootings. It's all the stuff. It is very easy to get numb from that and to turn off. Part of what we try to encourage people to do in order to keep their energy and their enthusiasm for change-making is to focus on one issue that really matters to them—because it's urgent, or it's something they have personal experience with and can relate to?in a deep way. Because it gets them out of bed and fires them up.

?We ask people to pick one area where?they want to make a difference. If it's climate, if it's abortion rights—pick one. And give yourself the grace, and give yourself a break, that you can't solve all the problems of the world. There is a mental piece to this, which is this stuff is all very overwhelming. The fact is, you?can?chip away at problems, but not if you're trying to chip away at?all?the problems. It’s not to tell people not to care. But if we actually want movement, if we want progress, if we want change, that requires sustained focus over the long term. And you can only do that if you make a real commitment to do that work over the long term.

Listen to the full episode?here. Read the full transcript?here.

Brewing Milk in Bioreactors

No alt text provided for this image

Cellular agriculture startups are culturing human and bovine cells in bioreactors to produce more sustainable milk without animals. |?Read more

Other good stuff in the news

Found good news we should hear about? Drop a link in the comments!

Environment:

Science & Tech:

Politics & Policy:

Covid & Public Health:

Society & Culture:

Economy:

TPN Member?originals:??

Department of Ideas?

Your Twitter activism is numbing you: Doing politics on the internet has enfeebled our democracies. |?Wisdom of Crowds

Why we picked it:?It might seem funny to hear from us, the people who run an online publication, but we believe it: there’s a much higher chance you can help make the world a better place if you get off the internet. —Emma Varvaloucas

Upcoming Events


Until next Thursday, we recommend against traveling?to?Saudi Arabia with?rainbow-colored toys or clothing?at this time.?

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Zachary Karabell的更多文章

  • Justice, One Kit at a Time

    Justice, One Kit at a Time

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we are testing out a new format for the top of our newsletter that summarizes…

  • Lifejackets, Not Tobacco Enemas

    Lifejackets, Not Tobacco Enemas

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we are here to remind you about the perils of prediction journalism. What Could…

  • Operation Thunder

    Operation Thunder

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we suggest managing stress by booking an inacupuncturist appointment. What Could…

  • Incoming!

    Incoming!

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where this discovery really calls for a remake of the movie Hot Tub Time Machine. What…

    1 条评论
  • What USAID Does

    What USAID Does

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we are pleased that Greenland understood the assignment. What Could Go Right? is…

    1 条评论
  • Take It to Court

    Take It to Court

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we support this radical political take. What Could Go Right? is a free weekly…

  • Navigating the Chaos

    Navigating the Chaos

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we’re realizing that NASA hasn’t heard the story of Icarus. What Could Go Right?…

  • Poetic Justice

    Poetic Justice

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we agree that this is the only solution to the homeschool debate. What Could Go…

    1 条评论
  • The Year Ahead

    The Year Ahead

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we're watching skilled pilots battle the fires in Los Angeles, California. What…

  • The Best News of 2024

    The Best News of 2024

    Welcome to What Could Go Right?, where we will be off for the holiday break until January 9. In the meantime, please…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了