The Main Obstacle to FDM/FFF Printing Being More Sustainable

3D printing, particularly Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) and Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF), is often hailed as a revolutionary technology that embodies the principles of additive manufacturing. Unlike traditional subtractive manufacturing methods that cut away material, 3D printing is additive - depositing material layer by layer with minimal waste. However, this innovative technology is not without its environmental challenges, including waste generation.

This paradox of being both additive and wasteful underscores the need for a sustainable approach to 3D printing.

Poll Results

In a recent LinkedIn poll, I asked 3D printer operators, "What do you think is the biggest obstacle to making FDM/FFF printing more sustainable?" The results were telling:

The overwhelming majority pointed to the lack of recycling programs as the primary barrier. This article will therefore delve into this critical issue, exploring the reasons behind the lack of recycling programs and proposing practical solutions to enhance sustainability in 3D printing.

The Double-Edged Sword of 3D Printing

FDM/FFF 3D printing offers numerous benefits, including reduced material wastage, the ability to create customised products, and the potential to lower production costs. However, the process also generates a considerable amount of waste. This waste includes failed prints, which occur due to printer errors, design flaws, or material defects; support structures, which are necessary for printing overhangs and complex geometries; and filament spools, which are often discarded after use.

The PLA Problem

One of the most commonly used materials in FDM/FFF 3D printing is Polylactic Acid (PLA), a biodegradable thermoplastic derived from renewable resources like corn starch and sugarcane. While PLA is often marketed as an environmentally friendly alternative to petroleum-based plastics, it has its own set of challenges. PLA requires specific conditions to biodegrade, which are typically only found in industrial composting facilities; in most home or landfill environments, PLA waste is unlikely to break down effectively, contributing to the growing problem of plastic waste.

Why Is There a Lack of Recycling Schemes for 3D Printing

Several factors contribute to the lack of effective recycling for 3D printing waste:

1. Contamination Risk: Difficult to distinguish between similar-looking materials like PLA and PETG, impairing the strength of recycled products.
2. Quality Control Issues: Recycled PLA degrades significantly after a few cycles, requiring the addition of virgin material, which may diminish environmental benefits.
3. Volume Requirements for Recycling: Other polymers like ABS and PETG need large waste volumes to be economically viable, excluding smaller firms.
4. Logistical Challenges: The low weight-to-volume ratio of plastic makes collection and transport costly.
5. Financial Burdens: Sorting, reprocessing, and manufacturing add substantial costs, complicating recycling efforts.
6. Operational Challenges: Without in-house capabilities, coordinating waste return to recovery facilities adds complexity.
7. Customer Willingness: Willingness to bear recycling costs varies across customer segments, with businesses more likely to pay than individual hobbyists.

For a more detailed explanation on the challenges above, please see this comprehensive blog post article.

Practical Solutions for Enhancing Recycling in 3D Printing

Despite the absence of an industry-standard recycling service for all 3D printing users, there are market-ready, sustainable options currently available.

• In-House Recycling and Extrusion Equipment: Investing in equipment like filament extruders can enable on-site recycling of waste filament. This approach reduces material costs and environmental footprint despite the high initial investment.
• External Recycling Services: Utilise external companies that offer recycling programmes specifically for 3D printing waste. This method is cost-effective and convenient for small-scale operators.
• Choosing Filament Providers Offering Waste Take-Back Solutions: Select providers that offer recycling programmes for 3D printing waste. As of April 2024, Filamentive offers free PLA 3D printing waste recycling for UK customers who have spent a minimum of ￡500 + VAT on PLA filament products. Customers can use the free recycling box scheme, where partners 3D Printing Waste (3DPW) manage the entire recycling process. This initiative provides an easy, cost-effective way to ensure PLA waste is properly recycled, promoting sustainability in 3D printing.

Towards Sustainable Solutions for 3D Printing Waste Recycling

The path to sustainability in FDM/FFF 3D printing is fraught with challenges, particularly when it comes to recycling programmes. The significant hurdles of contamination, quality control, logistical and economic viability must be addressed to create a more sustainable industry. However, by adopting practical solutions such as investing in in-house recycling equipment, utilising external recycling services, and choosing filament providers that offer waste take-back solutions, we can make substantial progress.

At Filamentive, we are committed to leading the way in sustainable 3D printing. Our new free recycling programme for PLA waste is just one step towards creating a circular economy within the 3D printing community. By working together, sharing ideas, and implementing these solutions, we can reduce the environmental impact of 3D printing.

Let's continue to innovate and collaborate, ensuring that the benefits of 3D printing are realised without compromising on environmental benefits. Share your thoughts and join us on this journey towards a more sustainable and responsible 3D printing industry!

Existing Filamentive Customer? Recycle your PLA waste with us.

Not yet a customer but open-minded to reduce plastic waste? Register Interest.

Business / Volume 3D printer user? FREE Trade Discount Sign-up.