The Loyalty Paradox

Brands shower customers with love but advertising agencies get dumped after years of dedication.

In the fast-paced world of advertising, one of the most disheartening experiences an agency can face is the unceremonious client dismissal. After pouring years of blood, sweat, and creative genius into an account, brilliant minds can find themselves abruptly shown the door with little more than a curt "thanks for your services" as the corporate relationship is severed. Large accounts in particular, like Tourism New Zealand, Air New Zealand, Spark, and One NZ (formerly Vodafone) make a habit of moving their advertising budgets from one agency to another.

It's a shocking reality that plays out time and time again, leaving agencies reeling from the emotional whiplash. One day, you're the trusted partner, breathing life into imaginative campaigns and propelling a brand forward. The next day? You're a casualty of corporate politics, smiled at by the receptionist on your way out as you box up years of hard work.

In the world of commerce, loyalty is a two-way street. Brands invest heavily in cultivating devoted customers, showering them with rewards programs, exclusive offers, and birthday greetings. Yet, this same dedication often seems absent when it comes to their advertising agencies. So why does this pattern persist? Why are agencies so often treated as expendable resources rather than invaluable long-term allies?

Loyal customers are the golden geese of any business. They spend more, become brand ambassadors through word-of-mouth marketing, and cost less to retain than acquire new ones. The marketing landscape, however, is a dynamic beast. A brand's needs can evolve rapidly, requiring a different skillset or approach from their advertising agency. Campaigns are awarded based on specific goals, and another agency might simply be a better fit for the next project. Additionally, competition in the advertising world is fierce. Brands are constantly presented with potentially more cost-effective options, leading to agency switches.

The brand-customer relationship thrives on a foundation of loyalty, but when it comes to agencies, the path is less clear. While short-term goals and project-based needs often dictate agency selection, fostering long-term partnerships with adaptable agencies can be a win-win for both parties. As the marketing landscape continues to shift, brands that recognise the value of a true marketing partner will be best positioned to navigate the ever-changing currents of consumer behavior.

For many clients, a lack of true loyalty drives this itinerant behaviour. Agencies are seen as vendors to be swapped out rather than partners to be cherished. With each leadership change, fresh perspectives are sought through new agency hires, leaving the old guards stranded with little sentiment.

This constant appetite for "next big thing" thinking can lead companies to discard agencies once their ideas start feeling stale after several years on the account. Never mind that those agencies built invaluable institutional knowledge and consumer insights from the ground up. In marketing, brilliance has a short shelf-life.

Sometimes, agencies simply become convenient scapegoats when strategies don't deliver promised results. Rather than look inward at the products, processes, or corporate misalignments, it's easier to point the finger at the agency team and initiate yet another costly agency review.

Cost-cutting plays a role as well. When economic headwinds blow, replacing a pricier longstanding partner with cheaper upstart shops holds clear appeal for budget-conscious clients. Payment terms and pricing model adjustments at the incumbent don't hold the same tantalising shine as lowballing from the new kids on the block looking to prove themselves.

At other times, people, not numbers, drive the farewells. When champions for an agency relationship exit a client's company, loyalties quickly dissolve. The incoming marketing leaders put their own stamp on agency rosters. The pursuits of corporate vision alignment, coupled with desires to install trusted partners, too frequently override recognising and honouring an agency's accrued value.

Whatever the root causes, the discourteous departures sting for agencies. Try as they might to remain unflappable professionals, it's demoralising to see years of heart-crafted work discarded so dismissively. The silent insult is enough to induce whiplash all on its own.

Of course, the cruellest part is that this winds up being a lose-lose scenario for both parties. Clients sacrifice years of consumer research, product-specific expertise, and ingrained tribal knowledge that bespoke agency teams have developed through sheer experience. Too often, that insider familiarity is the secret sauce behind effective advertising.

Meanwhile, agencies lick their wounds from feeling exploited, forcing disenchanted creatives to rebound and dive into the foreign beast that is a new client's business. The race to get back up to speed on intricacies like buyer personas, messaging philosophies, and regulatory landscapes is an energy suck. Worse, the void that emerges means more time idling rather than creating.

In the end, this vicious cycle benefits no one. Clients pay hefty agency fees onboarding newcomers to recoup the knowledge their outgoing shops took to the grave. Agencies say goodbye to productivity as they suffer through yet another time-consuming account transition. Shareholders of both parties are shortchanged.

Perhaps the marketing world needs to rethink this unhealthy codependent model. More enduring relationships and entrenched partnerships may be what both clients and agencies secretly crave. Until that philosophical shift happens, the revolving door will keep spinning, and the ungrateful goodbyes will persist in advertising's emotionally draining dance.

READ MORE

Are bank marketers tone-deaf?

https://grahammedcalf.substack.com/p/are-bank-marketers-tone-deaf

Critical Thinking – Marketers Superpower

https://grahammedcalf.substack.com/p/critical-thinking-marketers-superpower

Marketing and the Jargon Jungle

https://grahammedcalf.substack.com/p/marketing-and-the-jargon-jungle