Losing Trust with Creepy Tracking
??Randall Craig
Advisor on business growth, marketing strategy, thought leadership, and digital. Author. CEO at Pinetree Advisors. Hall of Fame business speaker.
Have you visited a website recently, and then noticed that every advertisement relates to the website you had just visited? Or received an email that begins, "We saw that you left some items in your shopping cart on our website"?
Perhaps even worse is the notification that pops up on your phone from a retailer or service provider when you go to a particular location. Many people are completely unaware that many "loyalty" apps track your location, sometimes 24h/day, then send that information to data brokers, who cross-reference this with other data. They infer your home, work, where you buy your coffee, the restaurants you go to, and so on. And since this is done with zero visibility to you, each of us is completely in the dark as to who else our data is sold to, and what purpose is it being used for. Creepy tracking is today's dirty little marketing secret.
Why should an organization do it, if it's so creepy? From a corporate perspective, engaging in these practices has clear benefits: more efficient (and effective) ad buys, a better understanding of prospect behavior, and higher sales. "Big Data" is so big because it contains everything about you!
While people are only now becoming aware of the creepy tracking that is happening. And when they eventually find out, there will be a steep loss of trust that will be just about impossible for brands to recover from.
There is some hope, however, that the current free-for-all "wild west" of data tracking may be coming to an end. Consider the relief that is coming from three important directions:
Regulators: Privacy regulators around the world are starting to recognize that data tracking must be subject to at least some degree of regulation. Some of the regulations are driven by a desire for data sovereignty, but many are focused on privacy and transparency.
Apple: While Facebook and Google are wholly dependent on ad revenues, and therefore have built "creepy" into the core of their Chrome browser, Search engine, and Social platforms, Apple is building in transparency and privacy. Given its ubiquity, Apple's move will force Google and Facebook to modify its most egregious practices.
Consumers: Consumers are waking up that "free" services are not actually free: they have been unknowingly paying with their personal and private data. Whether they are spooked by media stories on creepy tracking, notice it themselves, or decide to "shutdown" as much tracking on their devices as they can, this will also have an impact on the practice.
This week's action plan:
It's time to do some detective work: what creepy tracking — if any — is your organization doing? Start with the web by looking at all of the trackers on your website, then check whether there are any trackers in your organization's apps. Finally, look to see if you are buying data from third-party data brokers. Once you know what type of creepy tracking you are doing, then you can take steps to remove it.
Creepy Tracking insight: Even if you don't do creepy tracking yourself, you may still be funding it through deals with data brokers, purchases of targeted pay-per-click online ad buys, and retargeting. The cost of using these techniques is not just in dollars: you're also paying with trust.
Your thoughts? Contrarian views welcome.
-Randall
[Content Authenticity Statement: 100% original content. No AI was used in creating this content.]
领英推荐
??? Join our next virtual conversation and Q&A session for leaders! This month's topic: Driving Your Leadership Performance
As a leader, you motivate and set expectations for everyone within your organization… but what about yourself? For your partners? And for your leadership team?
In this month’s session, we’ll explore high-performance leadership:
???Date: Wednesday, June 19 at 12 noon ET
Register here (no cost to attend) ?? https://randallcraig.net/leadership
Questions can be submitted in advance to [email protected] and we’ll do our best to address them during the hour.
??More Business Growth Ideas to Get You on Track
Contact us
PrivSec Director and Industry Speaker
6 个月There's a balance to be struck in this, in that the "creepy" can also be beneficial and take some of the pain out of finding products or hearing about products that you normally would not have. Done behind closed doors, definitely creepy and probably in contravention of most privacy laws, but done with transparency (and, as you say, trust), it can be beneficial on both sides. South of the border there are some crazy tactics, but privacy laws are coming in state by state (and hopefully at a federal level soon, though there are complications with that). Here in Canada, many of the creepier practices wouldn't pass muster for being a legitimate approach. We work on this daily with responsible retailers, there are ways to do this that benefit people and reduce harm, and I am actually pro targeted marketing if it benefits me as a consumer - just let me know what you're doing and how I can have meaningful choice in all of it.