Liquid CO2 Shortage: A Global Challenge for Indoor Farming

The world is currently grappling with a significant shortage of liquid carbon dioxide (CO2), a critical resource for various industries, particularly indoor farming. This shortage has far-reaching implications, not only for food production but also for the stability of global supply chains. The scarcity of liquid CO2 is being felt globally, with several countries experiencing acute shortages, each with unique challenges and consequences.

Understanding the Liquid CO2 Shortage

Liquid CO2 is essential in many industries, including food and beverage production, medical applications, and, importantly, indoor farming. In indoor farming, CO2 is used to enhance plant growth through photosynthesis, ensuring higher yields and more efficient use of space. However, the global supply chain for liquid CO2 has been disrupted due to a combination of factors:

A.???? Industrial Slowdowns: Global CO2 production fell by approximately 20% in 2023 due to reduced industrial activity. Ammonia production in Europe, a key source of liquid CO2, dropped by over 30% in the first half of 2023 compared to the previous year.

B.???? Energy Crisis Impact: The ongoing energy crisis, particularly in Europe, has increased natural gas prices by over 200% since 2022. This has forced many ammonia plants to reduce or halt operations, leading to a significant reduction in CO2 production.

C.????? Supply Chain Disruptions: The global logistics network has faced continuous disruptions especially post COVID-19, with transportation costs for liquid CO2 increasing by nearly 50% in some regions. These disruptions further complicate the supply chain, making CO2 less accessible.

CO2 Supply Challenges: Regional Impacts

• United Kingdom: The UK has experienced a 60% drop in domestic CO2 production in 2023, leading to a 300% increase in CO2 prices compared to pre-pandemic levels. This has heavily impacted the indoor farming sector, with some farms reporting a 25% reduction in production capacity.
• United States: The shutdown of the Virigina’s Hopewell plant, a key CO2 supplier in the region has contributed to a 15% decrease in CO2 availability for indoor farming across the U.S., leading to a 20-30% rise in operational costs for urban farms, particularly in densely populated areas like New York and California.
• Germany: Germany has reported a 40% reduction in CO2 availability, mainly due to the decline in ammonia production. The indoor farming sector, which is crucial for Germany’s sustainability goals, has seen yield reductions of up to 18%.

?

PORTHOS CCUS Project: A Double-Edged Sword

The PORTHOS project, another major initiative in the Netherlands, is designed to capture and store CO2 emissions from industrial sources under the North Sea. While this project is crucial for achieving climate goals, it has unintended consequences for industries that rely on CO2.

• Project Overview: The PORTHOS project aims to capture up to 2.5 million tons of CO2 annually by 2026 and store it permanently in empty gas fields beneath the North Sea. This initiative is critical to the Netherlands’ strategy to reduce industrial CO2 emissions and combat climate change.
• Impact on CO2 Supply: While the PORTHOS project is essential for reducing emissions, it may further exacerbate the CO2 shortage for industries like indoor farming. By permanently storing CO2, the project reduces the amount of CO2 available for commercial use, potentially driving up prices and deepening the supply crisis.
• Market Dynamics: The reduced availability of CO2 due to projects like PORTHOS could lead to a further increase in CO2 prices. This, in turn, could make it more challenging for indoor farming operations to maintain profitability, as they struggle with higher input costs and potential yield losses.

Impact on Indoor Farming

Indoor farming, a rapidly growing industry worldwide, relies heavily on a consistent supply of CO2 to maintain optimal growing conditions. The shortage of liquid CO2 has led to several direct impacts on this industry:

• Reduced Crop Yields: Without sufficient CO2, plants grown in controlled environments like greenhouses or vertical farms struggle to reach their full growth potential. This leads to reduced crop yields, which in turn affects the availability and price of fresh produce.
• Increased Operational Costs: As CO2 prices skyrocket due to scarcity, indoor farming operations face increased costs. For some farms, this may lead to scaling back production or even temporary shutdowns, further exacerbating food supply issues.

?

Looking Ahead: Data-Driven Solutions

As the liquid CO2 shortage continues to challenge the global agricultural sector, data-driven approaches are critical for developing effective solutions:

• Alternative CO2 Sources: Exploring alternative CO2 sources, such as biogas and direct air capture, is becoming increasingly viable. Data from pilot projects in the US and Europe suggest that these alternatives could supply up to 30% of the CO2 needs for indoor farming within the next five years.
• Energy Efficiency and Optimization: Improving energy efficiency in CO2 production and utilization can help mitigate some of the shortages. Advanced monitoring and control systems in greenhouses can optimize CO2 usage, potentially reducing overall consumption by 10-15%.
• Global Cooperation and Data Sharing: International collaboration and data sharing are essential for addressing the CO2 shortage. By pooling resources and knowledge, countries can better anticipate shortages and implement strategies to mitigate their impact.

?

Conclusion

The liquid CO2 shortage is a stark reminder of the interconnectedness of global supply chains and the vulnerabilities that exist within them. For the indoor farming industry, this shortage has highlighted the need for resilience and innovation in the face of unforeseen challenges. As countries and industries work together to find solutions, it is essential to ensure that food production, particularly in urban environments, remains sustainable and secure.

At Direct Carbon, we lead the charge in addressing the global CO2 supply challenges. Our innovative approach focuses on providing a reliable and cost-effective CO2 solution through our cutting-edge direct air capture technology, Wunderpumpe. Our modular and sustainable system is designed to efficiently extract CO2 directly from the atmosphere, ensuring a steady supply for indoor farming.

We hope you enjoyed this edition of Direct Carbon X DAC. Don't miss out on the next one - subscribe today!